Subscribe Today

Behind the News

Newsweek’s Little Photoshop of Horrors

As we noted yesterday, Newsweek devotes its cover story this week to the impending release of federal prisoner number 55170-054, better known outside of Camp Cupcake as Martha Stewart. In that story, Newsweek informs us that the billionaire Doyenne of…

By Susan Q. Stranahan Wed 2 Mar 2005 02:17 PM 

As we noted yesterday, Newsweek devotes its cover story this week to the impending release of federal prisoner number 55170-054, better known outside of Camp Cupcake as Martha Stewart.

In that story, Newsweek informs us that the billionaire Doyenne of Domesticity has shed 20 pounds and some “worry lines.” And, because a photo is worth a thousand words, we are treated to a shot of a positively glowing Stewart in pink gracing the cover.

There’s one tiny catch. Turns out Newsweek’s photo is as dubious as jurors decided Stewart’s story was about her role in the ImClone stock scandal.

USA Today’s Mark Memmott reports today that Newsweek — which headlines its profile “Inside the Martha Makeover Machine” — did a little makeover of its own:

Newsweek put Stewart’s head on a model’s body for a cover story that looks at how she will emerge from prison “thinner, wealthier and ready for prime time.”

Assistant managing editor Lynn Staley says the photo won’t mislead readers — though it sure fooled us. “Anybody who knows the (Stewart) story and is familiar with Martha’s current situation would know this particular picture” was a “photo illustration,” she says.

Sort of like this one?

S.Q.S.

CJR

If you enjoy this kind of press criticism please consider a subscription to our magazine, Columbia Journalism Review—a deal via the Web site at $19.95.

To subscribe, to give CJR as a gift, to renew, or to check student and CJR in the Classroom rates, click here.

Subscribe Today
About the Author
Susan Q. Stranahan wrote for CJR.
Current Cover

Sept / Oct 08

Table of Contents Browse Back Issues Subscribe Attitude Adjustment Blind Spot More...
The American Newsroom Series

The Associated Press. Miami, Florida. Photo by Sean Hemmerle. More...

Top Stories
  • Parting Thoughts: An Invitation

    Give us your thoughts on journalism’s state and its future

  • Opening Bell: Oil Slicks

    As prices soar, U.S. looks for scapegoats; UBS ready to roll over; Jimmy Cayne, pariah; Rachael Ray, jihadi; etc.

  • Mort Rosenblum on Dispatches

    New quarterly bucks industry trend, exudes smart idealism

  • Cut the Dividends!

    Newspaper companies fork over hundreds of millions a year—and for what?

  • Opening Bell: The Hours

    Americans are working fewer, but not by choice; cuts on Wall Street; jobless ranks swell; etc.

  • Wiring Journalism 2.0

    Brad Stenger on the intersection of the press and computer science

  • Opening Bell

    In CJR's a.m. guide to the business press: Grim tidings on housing; WP says a veto threatened on bailouts; 50 bank failures? etc. etc.

  • The Opening Bell

    Pause in the panic; the Times on useless insurance; more bad news for a fallen titan, etc.

Recent Comments