But as for Brokaw’s parting statement, it reflected a largely Republican view of the world, camouflaged as a tribute to fairness and balance. “The American people have been part of the problem.” How much? Ten percent? A quarter? Three quarters? Half? Such a statement, while balanced, is empty. Of course those who availed themselves of cheap back-loaded loans, assuming the bubble would never burst, are complicit. Missing from this account: the deregulation that permitted the banks to pass the bucks and conceal the bubble’s dimensions. Missing from this account: the marketing apparatus that shoves credit cards into people’s hands. Missing too, under the general rubric of “entitlements”: the excellent solvency of the Social Security system, whose efficiency is a modern marvel—thanks to Congress for refusing the Bush privatization that John McCain supported.
Brokaw’s bland evasiveness here does not bode well for what we can expect from his turn as moderator, at this Tuesday’s debate. But then again, Brokaw lowered his own bar.
- 1
- 2





Noonan: "What we need now is grace." I am assuming that she held up a copy of her most recent book, Patriotic Grace" for emphasis? Or was she just wearing the T-shirt and baseball cap?
Posted by Jo in Maryland on Mon 6 Oct 2008 at 10:18 AM
Actually, the book was shown on-screen courtesy of the network.
Posted by Todd Gitlin on Mon 6 Oct 2008 at 11:02 AM
Todd,
I too was shocked by Brokaw's foxy concluding remarks.
Strangely, the show transcript does not appear to contain the strange concluding remarks by Brokaw that you have quoted (and I remember).
Here is where I expected to find the remarks you have quoted, on the final page of the Oct 5. "Meet the Press" transcript:
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/27034205/page/4/
I wanted to track down Brokaw's remarks because I intended to do post on my blog about Brokaw's not-so-impartial remarks just prior to moderating the debate. (It occurred to me that another blogger might have been similarly shocked by Brokaw, so that's how I tracked down your article, via Huf. Post).
I'm curious where you got the text for Brokaw's concluding remarks -- and very happy that you have preserved the record!
My post is here:
http://jotman.blogspot.com/2008/10/tom-brokaw-presidential-debate.html
Posted by Jotman on Tue 7 Oct 2008 at 06:48 PM