Subscribe Today

Campaign Desk

What’s Missing in Petraeus/Crocker Coverage

Public sentiment on Iraq and the way forward

By Zachary Roth Tue 8 Apr 2008 03:34 PM 

Looking through the major print coverage of General Petraeus’s appearance before the Senate Armed Services Committee this morning, something jumped out: In their write-ups of Petraeus’s testimony, along with that of Ambassador Ryan Crocker, The New York Times, Washington Post, and Los Angeles Times fail to even touch on the crucial underlying fact of the war’s unpopularity.

And it is unpopular. A Gallup poll released today shows that 60 percent of Americans support setting a timetable for withdrawal regardless of what happens on the ground (essentially the Democratic position), while only 35 percent favor remaining in Iraq until the situation improves (the Bush/McCain position). But those findings clearly haven’t filtered into the coverage of today’s hearings.

Sure, these stories are intended to be immediate reports on the day’s events, not lengthy analyses of America’s ongoing Iraq commitment. But the whole point of hearing from Petraeus and Crocker is to help Congress—and the press and public—figure out the best way forward on Iraq. And once President Bush leaves office, public opinion is likely to be a major determinant of our future Iraq policy, so it’s certainly relevant to the issue at hand.

It’s not that the press should assume the public is necessarily right on the issue. But those arguing for an ongoing US military presence in Iraq are explicitly going against the grain of public sentiment. That’s important for all sorts of reasons, and it’s worth reporters taking a moment to make it clear.


CJR

If you enjoy this kind of press criticism please consider a subscription to our magazine, Columbia Journalism Review—a deal via the Web site at $19.95.

To subscribe, to give CJR as a gift, to renew, or to check student and CJR in the Classroom rates, click here.

Subscribe Today
Post a comment




About the Author
Zachary Roth is a writer based in New York City.
Also by Zachary Roth
Current Cover

July / August 08

Table of Contents Browse Back Issues Subscribe Crossing Lines Second Life More...
Campaign Email
Campaign Tools
The American Newsroom Series

The Associated Press. Miami, Florida. Photo by Sean Hemmerle. More...

Top Stories
  • Parting Thoughts: An Invitation

    Give us your thoughts on journalism’s state and its future

  • Opening Bell: Oil Slicks

    As prices soar, U.S. looks for scapegoats; UBS ready to roll over; Jimmy Cayne, pariah; Rachael Ray, jihadi; etc.

  • Mort Rosenblum on Dispatches

    New quarterly bucks industry trend, exudes smart idealism

  • Cut the Dividends!

    Newspaper companies fork over hundreds of millions a year—and for what?

  • Opening Bell: The Hours

    Americans are working fewer, but not by choice; cuts on Wall Street; jobless ranks swell; etc.

  • Wiring Journalism 2.0

    Brad Stenger on the intersection of the press and computer science

  • Opening Bell

    In CJR's a.m. guide to the business press: Grim tidings on housing; WP says a veto threatened on bailouts; 50 bank failures? etc. etc.

  • The Opening Bell

    Pause in the panic; the Times on useless insurance; more bad news for a fallen titan, etc.

Recent Comments