Pulitzer: A Life in Politics, Print, and Power | James McGrath Morris | Harper | 559 pages, $29.99
What is most striking about the latest biography of Joseph Pulitzer is how little time he actually spent tending to his two newspapers, the St. Louis Post-Dispatch and the New York World. A close reading of James McGrath Morris’s Pulitzer: A Life in Politics, Print, and Power suggests that the press baron, who spent more than three decades as a newspaper owner, was a hands-on publisher for no more than ten of those years.
Pulitzer’s ascent to the pinnacle of journalism in this country was remarkably swift. Morris devotes the first third of his book to this rags-to-riches trajectory. After a childhood in Hungary, Pulitzer arrived in the United States in the midst of the Civil War, an ambitious teenager unable to speak a word of English. He settled in St. Louis, then the country’s fourth-largest city, and within five years he was elected to the state legislature, where he made a name for himself as a foe of corruption.
Meanwhile, he had begun contributing to the Westliche Post, a German-language newspaper. There he first tasted the joy and power of the press. In 1878, at age thirty-one, Pulitzer founded the St. Louis Post-Dispatch out of the wreckage of two local papers, the Post and the Dispatch. The afternoon daily, which remains in operation to this day, prospered—and within three years, Pulitzer passed the day-to-day management on to others, since the Post-Dispatch “practically ran itself.” Until his death nearly three decades later, he would visit the paper only three times, the last being in 1888.
By now, in any case, Pulitzer was seeking a larger stage. He was eager to outdo his younger brother, Albert, who had started the New York Journal. To do so, Pulitzer purchased Jay Gould’s money-losing New York World in 1883, taking a loan from Gould himself—a robber baron whom Pulitzer deemed “one of the most sinister figures that have ever flitted bat-like across the vision of the American people.” At once the new owner brightened the paper’s dull headlines and admonished his staff to “write in a buoyant, colloquial style comprising simple nouns, bright verbs and short, punchy, sentences.”
Within six months, the paper’s circulation tripled to 45,000, and grew to 300,000 by the fifth anniversary of Pulitzer’s ownership. With its war on monopolists, efforts to protect immigrants, and its work on behalf of the poor, the World soon became the widely read newspaper in American history.
Pulitzer worked very hard, and that took its toll. His fragile health led to a habit of perpetual flight. And in 1887, the onset of blindness pulled a curtain down on his world. Within five years of purchasing the paper, he had cemented his role as an absentee owner.
In 1888, for example, he spent the first six months of the year in California. Then, after a brief return to New York, he left for Europe for eighteen months. Of the twenty-eight years he spent at the helm of what Morris calls “the nation’s most important newspaper,” Pulitzer was in New York for only a fraction of that time. And even when he was in the city, he stayed away from the office. He even skipped the opening of the World’s grand building on Park Row in 1890, and visited only three times.
Indeed, if this book were all you were to read about Pulitzer, you might be hard pressed to understand why such greatness has been attributed to him. From Morris, it is hard to get a good fix on where his subject actually stood. Early on, the biographer asserts that Pulitzer was the “midwife to the birth of the modern mass media.” Later, Morris concludes that “although he was a times an innovator in journalism, this was not his strength.” Pulitzer’s real contribution, argues the author, was his business acumen, his “uncanny ability to recognize value where others had not.”