In 1985, press censorship was officially banned in Brazil, following the overthrow of a dictatorship that had for decades crippled journalistic freedom. Since then, Brazilian journalists have investigated government corruption and unearthed environmental and social stories with a zeal that made the nation’s watchdog press appear robust. In 2006, Marcelo Baêta, then a graduate student in journalism, changed that impression with his video, Liberdade, Essa Palavra (“Freedom, That Word”), which linked the firing of several reporters in Minas Gerais, one of Brazil’s largest states, to stories they wrote that were critical of Aécio Neves, the state’s powerful and popular governor. Neves is a likely candidate for president in 2010, and so the issue of press manipulation continues to unfold in Brazil. Elizabeth Tuttle spoke with Baêta in July.
How did this project evolve for you?
While I was still a student, the journalism program coordinator sent around an e-mail that she had received anonymously, which listed cases in which the government was reportedly interfering in the press to block negative stories. This interference allegedly caused the dismissal of several journalists from the Globo Minas network, the biggest television network here; the Minas Network, a state network; and Itatiaia, the largest radio station. That’s when I began to research other alleged instances of this kind of suppression.
Complete access to this article will soon be available for purchase. Subscribers will be able to access this article, and the rest of CJR’s magazine archive, for free. Select articles from the last 6 months will remain free for all visitors to CJR.org.
It’s unbelievable that Columbia Journalism School has published this story without showing “the other side” of this controversial subject. Yes, because it’s very controversial in Brazil. The statements used for supporting the author’s accusations against the governor were clearly and categorically denied by the journalists alleged censored in Minas Gerais State. I thought this subject was buried in the past, but it returns again like a ghost. Why is it coming back? For the same reason that it has appeared in 2006... At that moment, the alleged censorship in Minas Gerais was a leitmotiv in the opposition campaign, when Aécio Neves was running for a second term. Macelo Baêta’s video was a precious item of propaganda against Aécio Neves and largely scattered by anonymous spams in the internet. Now, Aécio Neves is one of the names most seriously considered for nomination in the next Brazilian presidential campaign. As CJR recommends Marcelos Baêta’s video, I humbly suggest you to see “the other side”, also available at You Tube. There’s an English version around the same subject. I’m sending both links.
“Liberdade de Imprensa em Minas” (Portuguese)
http://br.youtube.com/watch?v=tGeBcvdzcc4
“Gagged in Brazil: The Oher Side” (English)
http://br.youtube.com/watch?v=mgbdpM09ysk
Posted by Diógenes Pinto Carvalhaes on Wed 5 Nov 2008 at 11:29 PM