With new communication technologies there is this temptation to believe that speed is information. But it is based on a self-destructive logic: The content is now standardized, and your newspaper, your magazine, no longer has any distinctiveness, and so there is no reason to pay for the reporter. I mean, for the news, I have the Internet—and for free. The crisis today is of the media, not of the readership. Readers are still there, and contrary to what many editors believe, they are bright readers who ask for simplicity without simplification. They want to understand, not simply to know. Every time I publish an eyewitness account from the war, I get a dozen emails from people who say, “Okay, great piece, great tableaux, but I want to understand what’s going on in Syria.” And it would so please me to reply that I cannot submit an analysis piece, because the editors would simply spike it and tell me, “Who do you think you are, kid?”—even though I have three degrees, have written two books, and spent 10 years in various wars, first as a human-rights officer and now as a journalist. My youth, for what it’s worth, vanished when bits of brain splattered on me in Bosnia, when I was 23.
Freelancers are second-class journalists—even if there are only freelancers here, in Syria, because this is a dirty war, a war of the last century; it’s trench warfare between rebels and loyalists who are so close that they scream at each other while they shoot each other. The first time on the frontline, you can’t believe it, with these bayonets you have seen only in history books. Today’s wars are drone wars, but here they fight meter by meter, street by street, and it’s fucking scary. Yet the editors back in Italy treat you like a kid; you get a front-page photo, and they say you were just lucky, in the right place at the right time. You get an exclusive story, like the one I wrote last September on Aleppo’s old city, a UNESCO World Heritage site, burning as the rebels and Syrian army battled for control. I was the first foreign reporter to enter, and the editors say: “How can I justify that my staff writer wasn’t able to enter and you were?” I got this email from an editor about that story: “I’ll buy it, but I will publish it under my staff writer’s name.”
And then, of course, I am a woman. One recent evening there was shelling everywhere, and I was sitting in a corner, wearing the only expression you could have when death might come at any second, and another reporter comes over, looks me up and down, and says: “This isn’t a place for women.” What can you say to such a guy? Idiot, this isn’t a place for anyone. If I’m scared, it’s because I’m sane. Because Aleppo is all gunpowder and testosterone, and everyone is traumatized: Henri, who speaks only of war; Ryan, tanked up on amphetamines. And yet, at every torn-apart child we see, they come only to me, a “fragile” female, and want to know how I am. And I am tempted to reply: I am as you are. And those evenings when I wear a hurt expression, actually, are the evenings I protect myself, chasing out all emotion and feeling; they are the evenings I save myself.

Your writing is terrific but... no one, and I mean, no one, is forcing you to remain in the hell that is Syria. That you choose to is your perogative but please don't complain that many people can't get too upset about brutal Syrians killing other brutal Syrians.
War is hell.
#1 Posted by Ethel, CJR on Mon 1 Jul 2013 at 04:23 PM
"Gaza, as usual, was being bombed." Really? It's Sderot that's bombed daily, not Gaza.
#2 Posted by Abu Nudnik, CJR on Tue 2 Jul 2013 at 11:37 AM
Well, these two comments say a lot about everything that Francesca is trying to say ..
Of course nobody is forcing her, but she probably believes that journalism has a sense, and she is informing us on the difficulties of this work.
Difficulties: in the lack of freedom of expression, in the way that she would consider it appropriate in order to make the readers understand; and the daily difficulties of the profession.
Probably, in her opinion, journalism should groped to make it clear to readers what is happening in a country full of problems, caught in between the rebels and the regime.
And above all, she tells us of the difficulties of doing the work of journalist in these specific conditions. Ruthless, for the dangers of course, but also for the lack of humanity and respect on the part of employers, and colleagues.
And these two comments are a further confirmation of the lack of empathy in failing to grasp what someone is trying to express; but tear apart with a few superficial phrases, the account.
#3 Posted by marta filardi, CJR on Tue 2 Jul 2013 at 03:29 PM
"Gaza, as usual, was being bombed."
This is 100% accurate. Palestinians in Gaza regularly come under Israeli fire. Only last November, nearly 100 Palestinian civilians, including at least 33 children, were killed as a result of Israeli airstrikes and shelling (source: UN OCHA).
#4 Posted by Adam, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 05:07 AM
A great, great piece on today's journalism.
#5 Posted by Catherine, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 05:08 AM
absolutely agree with Marta's comment
#6 Posted by Jeanne, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 05:21 AM
Great work ! Keep it up, and stay safe ! for the Rab's sake ( arabic, not russian)
Your fan,
Roland J.P Sylvester, admirer of bravery
#7 Posted by Roland Sylvester, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 05:24 AM
"You who tomorrow are still alive, what are you waiting for? Why don’t you love enough? You who have everything, why you are so afraid?"
Those words...they stopped my breath. I've never had such a strong physical reaction to reading something before.
Wow.
#8 Posted by Eve, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 05:35 AM
I'm an italian freelance too, all my support to Francesca. I suppose she works for the same newspaper I write for and I can confirm each single word. When I've been detained in Pakistan I didn't get any support, not even an email from colleagues, they wrote an article about the story 3 days later and just for fear of the meagre figure they were doing with other media covering the story. I've got out of troubles just because of Limes - Italian review of geopolitics editor in chief (I write for them too) who did the hell to get me out of there.
And yes, nobody is forcing us to do this job: but is our job, we love it and we try to do it at its best and with all the intellectual honesty we can.
#9 Posted by Francesca Marino, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 05:42 AM
Thks for your piece. I totally recognised myself and my life in Kabul as a freelance journalist: competition between stringers, ridiculous price for pieces that cost you much more... good luck. Don't stay too long though. It s important to get back to "reality" before you lose your leg and lose yourself.. email me if you ever come to Paris! Stay safe in Syria...
#10 Posted by Aurelia du Vignau, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 05:43 AM
Brilliant Francesca.
If editors wonder why their readership is falling they need only blame themselves. I've always been more interested in how people survive, not how they die.
#11 Posted by Melany, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 06:03 AM
"Because the editors back in Italy only ask us for the blood, the bang-bang." Maybe is that the case for the journalists on the rebel side. As a freelancer covering the Syrian war on the government side (Damascus, Aleppo), I didn't experienced that. Francophone magazines asked me instead to write reports on the everyday life in the cities, the hopes and the fears of the people, the question of the internal displaced persons, without asking me to go to the frontline. Also, there is almost no journalists in Damascus and Aleppo. I felt really alone.
#12 Posted by François Janne d'Othée, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 06:08 AM
And how much did CJR pay her for this article? $150? $200?
#13 Posted by Joe, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 06:09 AM
The best piece about freelancing and covering conflict I have ever read - and I've read a lot of them. Bon courage from a fellow freelancer.
#14 Posted by Gareth Harding, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 06:11 AM
A brilliant and moving piece that all editors should read: if you can write for magazines, I think you should. UK Marie Claire would publish your account I bet you- You may be wasted in the news papers. if you want a contact there on the features department email me; Good luck out there. Louis Quail
#15 Posted by louis quail, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 06:15 AM
"Gaza, as usual, was being bombed." Really? It's Sderot that's bombed daily, not Gaza."
@Abu Nudnik: shame on you. yes, sderot has been bombed, but it is certainly not bombed daily. your lies harm any prospects for peace between us all - you are pathetic.
to the author: a very powerful piece for so many reasons. it is greatly troubling that the media is so controlled by a few powerful people who are able to show the "reality" they wish to create rather than the one that is the reality of the people and their lives that you try to report.
#16 Posted by bandora etrog, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 06:23 AM
Bottom line, You agree to work for 70$ per story. That is nobody's fault but yours.
You are risking your life to work in an industry that you help destroying.
#17 Posted by Free Lancer, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 06:30 AM
No words to explain how deep your words reached my soul, Francesca.
You are the best example I can try to follow.
#18 Posted by Alice, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 06:32 AM
As a freelance photojournalist I totally agree with this article - it hits spot on and is by far the best written peace on this topic...
Francesca, stay safe out there and keep on your outstanding work, as difficult as it may be for all of us freelancers nowadays...
#19 Posted by Benjamin Hiller, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 06:40 AM
I like you Francesca, we are both Italians, but you are completely wrong:
You and many other wild freelancers are destroying the market by going to war zones for 70$ a day, with no security measurements whatsoever.
Do you realize that it won't get any better if you keep on doing so?
We do work in hostile environments, but we get paid paid hundreds bucks a day, sometimes more, we hire former special forces as security advisors.
If you and your fellow freelancers start demanding for the same, we will all benefit and you won't put your life in danger this much.
#20 Posted by Gabriele, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 07:31 AM
Thank you Francesca
#21 Posted by Kelley, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 07:33 AM
Thank you Francesca Borri for your penetrating words about the reality of a freelancer these days.
"They are criminals" was the reaction of a Swedish journalist when he heard about what I was payed from a photo agency for a picture that ran on a front page of NYT and couple of other publications about two weeks ago.
It is sad to see what happens to journalism and photojournalism.
Wish you all the best.
#22 Posted by R. Rozenberg, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 07:40 AM
Sono senza parole, spero solo che l'amore che metti nel tuo lavoro non lasci ferite irrecuperabili...e parlo per esperienza
buona fortuna, ciao
#23 Posted by felicia violi, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 08:17 AM
Thank you. For your honesty amd your crazy courage. As a former Latin America-based freelancer, your words ring true. As a recovering journalist, I want to say to you that when you are older you may realize that despite one's deep desire to educate and inform (to therefore change the world), the best most of us can do is to change our own tiny place in the world, and find peace (and hopefully love and some measure of fulfilment) in our lives. Take care please. And get the fuck out of Syria.
#24 Posted by John Enders, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 08:21 AM
Thank you for such an honest account.
So, how to make editors (and media) think differently?
#25 Posted by Rodrigo Ordonez, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 08:21 AM
Thank you. For your honesty amd your crazy courage. As a former Latin America-based freelancer, your words ring true. As a recovering journalist, I want to say to you that when you are older you may realize that despite one's deep desire to educate and inform (to therefore change the world), the best most of us can do is to change our own tiny place in the world, and find peace (and hopefully love and some measure of fulfilment) in our lives. Take care please. And get the fuck out of Syria.
#26 Posted by John Enders, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 08:23 AM
What an incredibly powerful piece. Reminds me of a book by Susan Sontag 'Regarding the Pain of others'. A word where gore sells but our seeing it doesn't change the reality.
stay strong
#27 Posted by Bob, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 08:27 AM
An excellent piece. You will no doubt be depressed when you read the comments, but as you mentioned in your piece, there are people who appreciate what you are doing, and the appalling price you are paid to risk your life to the stories. Bravo.
#28 Posted by Carl Pilkington, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 08:27 AM
Just...thank you!
Oh yeah: stay safe!
#29 Posted by Jean-Guy, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 08:55 AM
Great and moving piece, thank you very much, be safe.
#30 Posted by laurence, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 08:57 AM
I hope the author is reading this. This is one of the most important pieces I have read. I wish I knew Italian, so I could read everything else you ever wrote. Although I live in Israel/Palestine and study/visit Kosovo, I can only imagine how much richer my knowledge would be from reading your books - which I hope to find in English. But no matter - this alone is a profound contribution to your field and ultimately to the human beings you care enough about to risk your life covering them. And it's an enormous gift to any human being who reads this as well. I wish there were better words to be said about the realities you describe...but I have none. In the meantime, stay safe.
#31 Posted by Dahlia Scheindlin, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 09:09 AM
"A voice for the voiceless." Thank you for writing this. Thank you for staying in Syria.
#32 Posted by Libby, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 09:27 AM
$70 per article! The problem is your editors know you love your work so much, you'd do it for free. And now you essentially are.
#33 Posted by Harry Lew, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 09:34 AM
quite a stirring piece. hard to know what to do about the economics of freelancing. a friend is preparing to go to syria to freelance. if it doesn't literally kill him, it will financially. reminds me of adlai stevenson's admonition about central america: the american people will do anything for central america - except read about it. i sort of disagree that there are more people who want to read more about these conflicts. i mean i do, but i think most people are not interested.
#34 Posted by joe lamport, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 09:35 AM
Thank you. For dealing with so many issues in one piece. Keep your stories. I hope we see your books in translation soon.
#35 Posted by 411bee, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 09:44 AM
My ex husband sent this article to me with the words 'read this'. I have, and am now in tears with my first cup of coffee. In your words, I am feeling the frustration, angst and fear with overwhelming empathy. I used to say that if I could touch just one person with my photographs to make them want to know more, then I've done my job. Now, at those dinner parties, having limped in feeling every old injury, I usually, by the end, tell someone I don't know why I bothered, they could give a damn.
#36 Posted by Carlee Keppler-Carson, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 09:49 AM
Very moving piece. Working with young women from the "frontlines of violence" this week in Chicago teaching them citizen journalism, we are inspired by Francesca and her take on covering conflict. It's not just the wars that are reported on--if badly--these girls see gunfire almost every day.
@globalgirlmedia, www.globalgirlmedia.com. Teaching the future generation of Francesca's!
#37 Posted by Amie Williams, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 09:51 AM
New is sound bites. That's all it is. We are trained by TV to absorb 2 minute sound bites. We are trained to accept sound bites as fact. Twitter is another weapon of mass miss-communication all because it misses one key component. Nearly every article written or reported misses this one fundamental aspect that underlines or undermines its veracity.
Context.
Both sides have a story when you knit both together you are nearer to the clues that give you context. All news reporting is dangerous because not only does it omit context it adds its own bias.
You all know this is true. We are doomed to run around in circles because one side has one readership and the other side has theirs and never the twain shall meet.
#38 Posted by Syricide, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 09:53 AM
Fascinating piece. I admire your courage and your will to tell what is happening, but, as a freelancer myself, I object to the notion that
"the only job opportunity I have today is staying in Syria, where nobody else wants to stay. And it’s not even Aleppo, to be precise; it’s the frontline." I mean, I could probably sell articles from there as well, but I won't, because I am not brave like you and do not feel like going to the Syrian frontline.
I am truly appalled at the stories about your editors and colleague-rivals on assignment. That is absolutely disgusting. Not to mention your "friend" looking for the spa card. If you can, please change editors, or tell them to go f... themselves.
#39 Posted by Albertine , CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 10:07 AM
Francesca, this is a hard world we are living in. Unfortunately, you are seeing the worst of it. Please don't lose your hope on Mankind, there are beautiful people all over the world and amazing, positive, stories to write.
You already gave a very good contribute about what is happening in Syria, maybe you should leave and surch your deserved peace and happiness.
That good things and people find their way to you :)
#40 Posted by Lina, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 10:11 AM
Thank you. For your work, for this fabulous piece, for your courage and honesty.
#41 Posted by mariana groba gomes, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 10:16 AM
A very good piece. Freelancing is a perilous business, obviously so in war and just as financially so in peace (hence I was happy in my relative youth to go on staff after starting as a freelancer in Lebanon). What might help would be lobbying by journalists' trade unions for compulsory insurance (for injury, death, medivac, etc) to be provided by any publication/media outlet that accredits a journalist. I won't hold my breath waiting, and in the meantime I hope Francesca stays safe.
#42 Posted by John Andrews, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 10:42 AM
@Abu & Adam: The woman is risking her life to get the story out, and you guys are bitching about whether the bad guys are the Israelis or the Palestinians?! A plague on both your houses!
#43 Posted by Frank, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 10:44 AM
Amazing piece...please write a book on the Syria war. I sympathize with u as a journalist too. take care there and remember that there are people who are also praying for ur safety for u to tell the world what really happen there.
#44 Posted by ruby yap, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 10:50 AM
"Because really the only story to tell in war is how to live without fear. It all could be over in an instant. If I knew that, then I wouldn’t have been so afraid to love, to dare, in my life; instead of being here, now, hugging myself in this dark, rancid corner, desperately regretting all I didn’t do, all I didn’t say. You who tomorrow are still alive, what are you waiting for? Why don’t you love enough? You who have everything, why you are so afraid?"
This is an article about more than war. About more than being a woman correspondent in a war zone. It's an article about living with integrity and compromise. And the battles we fight every day. Thank you Francesca Borri.
#45 Posted by Dean Hutton, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 10:51 AM
Amazing article Francesca. You've done your share now. Come back to a safe place and write a book or blog on all that you saw and felt. There must be an easier way to earn those $70 and you will do the world a huge service by explaining what is going on in Syria. You are a gifted writer, your piece is attractive because it came from the heart. I am sure many will want to read your book.
#46 Posted by Najla Drooby, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 10:52 AM
bravo, Francesca. and thank you.
#47 Posted by Casey L Coombs, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 11:01 AM
Find a new market. Your English is good enough to sell to a news syndicate or Australian press which pay close to 1$ per word still. 70€ is standard for Italy, but other places pay much more.
#48 Posted by nicola w., CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 11:02 AM
Yes! She got the guts! Pretty edifying article!
In her words: “Actually, I should have realized it that time my editor asked me for a piece on Gaza,“…. I got this email: “You know Gaza by heart,” he wrote. “Who cares if you are in Aleppo?”..........” With new communication technologies there is this temptation to believe that speed is information. But it is based on a self-destructive logic: The content is now standardized, and your newspaper, your magazine, no longer has any distinctiveness, and so there is no reason to pay for the reporter”
Few points:
- Readers receive millions of information… they quite often select, capture, integrate what they already deeply believe or what they have been conditioned to believe or would be more comfortable to hear. People can be smart but when affect is involved: logic, justifications and rationality of people can be quite surprising. Even smart and educated people should be trained to have critical thinking; this involves comparing sources of information, checking the veracity of the information, look behind the intention of the info spread out, avoiding bias; take also the time to connect thousand of elements and manage to relate them to each other in order to have a wider understanding of a situation; and avoid burning time in proving solutions to false problem; its create explosive situation at the end.
- In most cases journalists are sent in a location upon their known political points of views on a situation; and their articles are selected only if what they expose fit the conditioned readers expectations… it needs to sale…
- Who has ever said that the job of journalist is to inform about the complexity and the reality of a situation???? Indeed smart but naïve people believe it…. The game is won! I am nicely thinking of a British journalist I met 13 years ago that was covering the Intifada (like most of the journalists at that time); he mentioned to me that each time his articles damaging enough the image of Israel they simply were not taken by the newspapers. This is just an example about dozens I could mentioned.
- We are from the beginning orientated to believe what is good or bad and to think upon the politically correct.
- Journalists are also often conditioned to look at reality in certain way and trained in their school to have a pre conceived idea of what they want to talk about and select on the field what fit those pre conceived ideas. This is called: design! You project your inner vision of the world out and bring it to become tangible and a reality!!! I am a designer and creative leadership trainer and expert in decrypting processes… let say that designs based on truly meaningful intentions can be creative and constructive. But when Media’s designs are targeting only money no surprise if it can result in destruction, wars and deaths.
- What is behind that? Francesca said it very well: the articles need to sales. Otherwise editors pick up the one of someone else. I am far to be anti capitalist thu I try to stay lucid, with some discernment and critical and constructive thinking. Remembering that I am a human being and yet my prejudices and emotions can always be a bit involved.
- So chief editors pick up articles that can sale; people select news, and articles, magazines that they feel comfortable with or have been preconditioned to believe in. If I look at the two main French Media groups those are Lagardere and Dassaut…. And weird coincidence or not they are also the two big weapon manufacturers and exporters TRUST of the country….. I might make an easy short cut but: the deliberate orientation of the information from the media conditions the stream of conflicts and often enflames situations and provoke wars. But without the money of those weapon industries provided by the sale of all those weapons themselves generates by those war, provoked by the media our countries would simply fall apart! Big media grou
#49 Posted by Laetitia, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 11:09 AM
Thank you, Francesca. I'm disheartened I read it for free. There must be a way for readers to pay writers directly.
#50 Posted by Patricia , CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 11:18 AM
There are so many truths in this piece, but it's the first one that jumps out at me the most: It's not just Aleppo that's all gunpowder and testosterone, it's the newsrooms. It's the casual arrogance of men who get off on reading war stories but think that real human stories somehow don't matter. It's what happens when media, business, and policy are shaped entirely by men, as if men are the only audience that matters. We're all still playing in their sandbox, and it's one in which the destruction of the castles is more important than their creation.
You're a brave woman, Francesca, not only for what you do but for daring to speak up about it. Here's to the day when you're the editor. I hope it comes soon.
#51 Posted by Candace, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 11:27 AM
OK, let's parse this out.
A. The journalist is a whore.A fame whore. A $70 fame whore.
But in this case, at least sympathetic in his/her introspection.
B. All the parties in this exchange are dissatisfied. The reporter who
"can't make a difference", the warring sides who each feel misrepresented
and the end user who who receives only empty tittilation.
C. "Hey everybody, smile on your brother, everybody get together and
love one another...right now".
#52 Posted by Do Not Resuscitate, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 11:34 AM
Pity and sympathy doesn't help you (pay you anything). Why don't you try something like creating a website where you can publish your pieces that want to explain things and restrict the acess to paying suscribers? I know this will not help upsetting the public as a whole or serve as a way to five you a full income - but it might give you a fixed income and a relief for your thoughts.
#53 Posted by rosamunde, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 11:50 AM
Dear Francesca, I have no words, you have words and facts enough and your work is great. Please take care of you, I'm sure you do. Thank you for your intense and wonderful work. I hope to read more of you I don't know where. I hope you'll find a more interesting editor.
Fulvio Colangelo
#54 Posted by Fulvio Colangelo, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 12:03 PM
freelance reporters photographers kill the business. and they go to on place for the first time and think they are jezus . take a ,,,,Ronny Rosenberg,,,,.. is a wedding photographer in Holland ,,,go to turkey to make pix of the demonstrations over there what you have to there on the first place , leave it for the real photographers NOT the wanna be photographers , who like to be cool and put the pix on face book so pappa and mom can be proud of there son . and than complaining about the payment >> of a non focus pix in the n,y,t ???.
you @#$ss you kill the business by your self .stay in your wedding work . and controll the focus on your pix over there in Holland .
#55 Posted by c press, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 12:08 PM
You are just fantastic! you really moved me. I wish you all the best.
#56 Posted by Zeid, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 12:17 PM
God bless and protect you Francesca as you work under fire. Appreciate your call of duty, courage of conviction and reprimand your naivete. Many editors, publishers and fellow journalists are cunning and devious. At least you are not dealing with one who replaces 'By Francesca Borri from Homs' with his/her byline. As some readers commented, nobody compelled you to report from this 'hell'. So you cannot complain. You could have discreetly woven your professional and survival travails in Syria into your reports and features. Nevertheless, I have become your fan. I have had similar experiences in my journalistic career. May the living God heal you from typhoid and revive your spirit to write a report that brings you awards as well a 'few dollars more'. Sudeep Sonawane, Doha, Qatar.
#57 Posted by Sudeep Sonawane, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 12:19 PM
a with all that self proclaimed heroism in the face of those who are foreced to live and work there silently without making the journalistic fuss - what difference do you make dear????
#58 Posted by Arthur, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 12:20 PM
Strong and true words, Francesca. Thank you as always for writing exactly as you do.
#59 Posted by Alice Martins, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 12:20 PM
Hello there,
I know exactly what you mean. I Know how it feels to be there on your own trying to say something or do something only to be faced with indifference. If you need to retain one thing from my comment I want it to be this one: you matter, your work matters, your stories matter. Congratulations on your wonderful job. Keep going, it will all make sense to you...
Take care and God bless you.
Zeina
#60 Posted by Zeina Gabriel, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 12:29 PM
I can't tell you how powerful this piece was for me. I'm sharing it with everyone I can. Thank you for all that you do. You represent the best and most courageous of humanity.
#61 Posted by Aaron, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 12:43 PM
Thanks for enlightening me on your personal experience of being a journalist in a war zone .The Real story of what happens on the front line.I often wondered how a human being can ever get accustomed to the constant death and injuries and being surrounded by pain and bombings and bullets .You must have a strong backbone.Informing others of whats happening is extremely important .Try and find a quiet place for yourself to reflect.You have much courage.Come home soon.
#62 Posted by George Gallant, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 01:01 PM
Moving words Francesca. You must spend sometime at home, marketing yourself and your work through other channels so that you can be properly paid, insured and taken care of when things go bad. I'm a freelance filmmaker but I take nothing like your risks. You shame me in my passivity. There are millions of readers around the world who would be happy to pay for your insight. Remember yourself.
#63 Posted by Sasha Snow, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 01:01 PM
Good article but pointless. All news is dissonance because it has to be formulated with scene, incident, explanation and the explanation is nearly always guess work.
We are pathetic consumers pretending to care from the comfort of our homes.
Funny how a female reporter will always find time to put on some make-up even in a war zone. pathetic.
#64 Posted by tylerdurden, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 01:03 PM
You don't feel like a survivor, but you are. You don't behave like a hero, but you are. You know this. It uplifts you and inspires us all. Contact me for help and support, it's yours if I can summon it.
#65 Posted by chris slatter, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 01:13 PM
Brilliant article. However one needs to wonder if she isn't a little like the crazies who chose to visit the "nuthouse," after all should she really still be there?
As for Gaza and Sderot Hamas is to blame, anyone who thinks otherwise is not looking at the situation objectively.
#66 Posted by Local, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 01:25 PM
It's surprising how often people we call heroes end their days broke. As for staying in Syria, well as you know the Syrians live there everyday. Keep your head down! And if you decide it isn't worth your life, don't stay.
#67 Posted by Chris Mark, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 01:44 PM
Thank you. This is an amazing article, and thank you so much for the work you do.
#68 Posted by Diane Silver, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 01:49 PM
Thank you for your refreshing words... I still have fond memories of Syria and miss how it was and my family every day. Thank you for giving such a different approach to writing about the war. I needed this.
#69 Posted by Nadia D., CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 01:54 PM
This is real journalism. It's the best article I've read in years and I'm a news-junkie.
#70 Posted by Doug, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 01:56 PM
Absolutely breathtaking. My fiancé is a writer and his dream is to publish good honest work; simple not simplified because he to believes that's what readers seek.
Thank you for this piece.
#71 Posted by Tali Jenkins, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 01:57 PM
Dear Francesca,
Your words burn; they are so powerful. I am so angry at your editors, at the men who treat you like you shouldn't be there, at the nastiness of the other journalists, at the stupidity of the war tourists. Thank you for telling it like it is. Give the UN hell, give all of us hell. How dare we stand by while Syria implodes? I was in Bosnia, too and my heart just breaks. There is no excuse. I am an atheist, but I pray to the universe for your safety. I am thankful for you and for the truth you tell. You are doing what so many others fail to do. Write about what is really happening.
Please keep explaining what you can about the war and the conditions of children for us and about what is real and what is not.
A friend in human rights,
Diane Paul
#72 Posted by Diane Paul, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 02:06 PM
I think what she is trying to say is the story that needs to be told, the real story of pain an suffering, an understanding of misery and hopelessness is being glossed over by editors trying to sale papers and ads.
#73 Posted by C.R, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 02:14 PM
You should send your stories to the NY Times or IHT ... I've seen them publish such articles. I don't think they're biased and they pay well.
#74 Posted by honorablehuman, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 02:19 PM
Thank you, Francesca. This is excellent and I deeply appreciate your candid thoughts - especially on the madness of the war and of pretending that it's not (mad). It's deeply tragic that even your colleagues try to deceive you.
I try my best to understand the situation in Syria but that is hard from a distance. Work like yours is essential.
#75 Posted by Bruno Braak, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 02:30 PM
If such an honest and hearfelt article doesnt get you a Pulitzer then the Pulitzer doesn't deserve you. By far the most honest articles I have read. Thank you for sharing this with us. And I am sure you will have your moment when all this feels like it was worth it...when the clasp of your conscience is eased.. all the very best...
#76 Posted by Priya, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 02:45 PM
For the record: Sderot is located less than a mile from Gaza (the closest point is 840 m).[2] Rocket attacks on the city have killed 13 Israelis, wounded dozens, caused millions of dollars in damage and profoundly disrupted daily life.[3] Studies have found that air raid sirens and explosions have caused severe psychological trauma in some residents.[4] From mid-June 2007 to mid-February 2008, 771 rockets and 857 mortar bombs were fired at Sderot and the western Negev, an average of three or four each a day.
#77 Posted by Chaz4Jazz, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 02:47 PM
Your piece catches not only the tragic narrative of Syria's ever rumbling bloody war, and the obstacles you face in reporting on war thorn countries. But most of all it catches the tragic narrative of how news, and thus people's perception on daily developments, are being deformed by editors sitting in their glass houses while living in a time where 'informative' information should be ever present. Moreover, a time where history should be created, while just unfolding, but instead money and commercialization has happened to decide otherwise.
Your voice catches a rare, honest reading on a tragic narrative that embraces us all, though only few seem to notice or care. You're voice will last as a perpetual source of inspiration.
Many thanks, keep safe and keep up the good work.
#78 Posted by Johann, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 02:58 PM
Cara Francesca,
be proud, you have not become desensitized to suffering and in the circumstances from which you write this only proves to your readers that your humanity is a gift to yourself and to us.
May you continue to remain safe!
in gratitude,
Adele
#79 Posted by adele, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 03:08 PM
I am moved, enfuriated by what I recognise about the media in your words and by you articulate vivid justifiable fury. I've read nothing anywhere else like it. And if I'm like anyone else were all hungry for your kind of truth. Please keep writing and fighting to get it seen for as long as you have heart for it.
#80 Posted by Louise Wardlr, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 03:12 PM
what happened between July 2nd (2 comments) and the 10th, the date when the rest of us stumbled/commented on this article? Has this anything to do with journalism or with the internet?
#81 Posted by hotmeel, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 03:44 PM
This is pathetic journalism. Journalism is INFORMATION, NOT glamorising your narratives to show off about your bravery. It is exactly for people that want to pass for heroes like you with their way of writing - and as though they were gifted with humanitarianism unlike the others that do not leave for hell and simply lead a normal life - that wars turn into cash producers and market machine. Greetings from Gaza, where you would have so much to show off to your western companions.
#82 Posted by Najwan, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 03:45 PM
Francesca Borri, you are possessed of a brilliant gift. Your writerly professionalism is breathtaking, your outrage against humanity well taken. Your graphic descriptions of human failure overwhelmingly shameful. The greed of news media to focus on what brings their readers to snap attention is pitiful. You are where you are because of your humane conscience and because of your human ambition. Michael Petrou's "Is This Your First War? travels through the post 9-11 Islamic World" describe similarities to your own frustrating experiences to a degree. May you somehow prevail despite the odds you place yourself within.
#83 Posted by Rita Rosenfeld, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 04:17 PM
Vous n'êtes pas la première... Lisez le livre de Jules Roy "Retour de l'enfer" sur son engagement dans la 2ème guerre mondiale, ou plus récemment "Valse avec Bachir"... Les personnes qui engagent leurs vies pour sauver celles des autres ne sont que rarement récompensées par ceux-ci... Mais le faites-vous pour les autres ou pour un idéal qui vous est cher? Votre mérite n'est pas moindre, mais ne vous attendez pas à une reconnaissance, trop rarement au rendez-vous! Merci quand-même et tous mes encouragements pour les risques que vous encourez.
#84 Posted by hanne teissier, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 04:32 PM
Cara Francesca,
Inizialmente il tuo pezzo mi è piaciuto, ma riflettendoci con più attenzione, ho visto in esso molto egocentrismo e voglia di creare del sensazionalismo mischiato a del vittimismo.
E' molto duro il tuo lavoro, e questo senza ombra di dubbio.
Tuttavia, come conferma anche un altro freelance, non penso fosse la tua unica possibilità di lavoro.
Anche perchè in un altra intervista dichiari di 'seguire le storie che ti incuriosiscono'..
E' ammirevole che tu abbia scelto questa strada per cercare giustizia e dare voce a chi non ce l'ha.
E per questo ti stimo molto.
Tuttavia mi pongo una domanda sull'etica. Tu, come Alessio Romenzi, che menzioni, in un certo senso 'usate' la sofferenza estrema di altre persone come opportunità di carriera. Perchè è poi a voi che va la notorietà.
Esempio Romenzi: che ha pubblicato tante fotografie sul time e vinto il world press photo con le fotografie sulla Siria; e tu: che stai partecipando al 2013 kurt schork award, grazie anche alla notorietà di Stanley Greene.
Non so, nelle tue parole mi sembra ci sia un'ostentazione di una purezza e di un vittimismo opinabili.
Nel senso che il tuo lavoro è una scelta, di una donna occidentale istruita, che ha avuto la possibilità di studiare e ha scelto un lavoro piuttosto che altro. Con condizioni difficili, certamente.
E poi l'ultima frase: 'voi che avete tutto, vivete la vita senza paura'- un pò banale. La sofferenza la prova anche chi 'ha tutto'; come te ad esempio, che hai tutto e scegli di stare in Siria.
#85 Posted by simona preti, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 04:34 PM
Dear Francesca,
Initially I liked your piece, but in reflecting on it more carefully, I saw in it much egotism and desire to create sensationalism mixed with the victim.
It 's very hard your job, and that without a shadow of a doubt.
However, as also confirmed by another freelancer, I do not think it was your only chance to work.
Also because in another interview claims to 'follow stories that will intrigue' ..
And 'admirable that you have chosen this path to seek justice and to give voice to those who did not have it.
And for that I respect you very much.
However, I pose a question on ethics. You, as Alessio Romenzi, (who you mentioned), in a sense 'used' the extreme suffering of other people as a career opportunity. Why is it then that you must be the fame.
Romenzi example: who has published many photographs on the Time newspaper and won the world press photo with photographs on Syria, and you: that you're participating to 2013 Kurt Schork award, thanks also to the reputation of Stanley Greene.
I do not know, in your words I think there is an affectation of a purity and a victim questionable.
In the sense that your work is a choice, a Western-educated woman, who had the opportunity to study and chose a job rather than anything else. With difficult conditions, of course.
And then the last sentence: 'you who have everything, live life without a little paura'-trivial. The suffering of the test even those who 'has everything', like you for example, you have everything and you choose to stay in Syria.
#86 Posted by simona preti, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 04:42 PM
You have my admiration and appreciation. Your truth telling is refreshing. Your editors are a-holes. And that money is the bottom line, is an apt reflection of what is wrong with this whole world. Bill Gates has 72 billion dollars and people worship him like he were the 2d coming of Christ.
#87 Posted by Rocky Fjord, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 04:47 PM
amazing writing Francesca....you are a role model for journalism today...stay safe and come home and write that Pulitzer when its ready....we need people like you in this world who tell the story others fear to hear...
#88 Posted by Aaron Maree, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 04:50 PM
Thank you for your commitment to the Syrian people, and their revolution for freedom, dignity and justice.
#89 Posted by Marcus Weber, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 04:54 PM
Absolutely fantastic piece, your words moved me to a point beyond belief and I hope you find strength in the praise your readers have shared with you above. I will be sure to share this with as many people as possible - complimenti cara e buona fortuna x
#90 Posted by Jessica R, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 04:56 PM
Great, Francesca. Thank you for the US$ 70's piece.
#91 Posted by Irineu Masiero, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 04:56 PM
Where can I get an subscription to you and your journalism? I want to read all your stories, especially the ones your editors are not interested in.
#92 Posted by Ginette Lavell, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 05:09 PM
'Till victory Francesca. I mean the victory of the truth you recognise and try to let us see. The victory of empathy for the struggle that may move us to act in peace. Thank you. As for the Editors, I'm lost for words!!
#93 Posted by Tim Fleming, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 05:33 PM
So you find another job. Simple.
#94 Posted by David Ball, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 05:37 PM
Thank you very much for taking the time to write this eloquent and informative piece. I told all my colleagues about it. I will never forget it. Stay safe, and don't let the ignorant get to you.
#95 Posted by David L. Wheeler, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 05:44 PM
I've no idea who you are writing for at $100 a piece. Nobody in the mainstream media world pays that little... Maybe its different in Italian...and I know things in the journalism world are bad...but as far as English languages goes...its not the case.
#96 Posted by Joe, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 06:23 PM
First of all: please, do not get hurt.
Secondly: it is a great piece and like many others I regret I don't know Italian to read your reports.
Thirdly: I would also love to understand more about Syrian conflict. I despise this flashy bloodcount "journalism". In Poland we call it "trupokilometry" - in lousy media the importance of a piece = number of deaths / distance from the event.
And finally: have you thought about a different way of raising money? 70 USD is not worth it - maybe if you could sell it to other media (like a Polish magazine to translate it and publish), use kickstarter, donations or some NGO to pay for it and publish freely under a free licence...
Heck, you need only 700 people to pay 10 cents to get that $70. This is not that many, really.
Hugs, please make it loud if you happen to come to Warsaw. It would be nice to meet you on some author's meeting or sth.
#97 Posted by Michał Buczyński, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 06:38 PM
I'm a freelance journalist too, three years between Syria, Lebanon, Kurdistan Iraq and Turkey so far. Currently based in Syria (Hasakeh province).
Thanks for sharing this Francesca, I'm fully aware of the hardships of a freelancers, especially when dealing with editors, but l'd like to comment on some passages:
"But we aren’t free at all; it’s just the opposite. The truth is that the only job opportunity I have today is staying in Syria, where nobody else wants to stay. And it’s not even Aleppo, to be precise; it’s the frontline. Because the editors back in Italy only ask us for the blood, the bang-bang."
Sorry, but you have plenty of other options rather than staying in Aleppo: I'm based in Syria, I'm not on the front line and I get paid decently for covering other kind of stories. I would never accept to be paid 70$ in Aleppo, when dealing with editors I state clearly my demands on the basis of where I'm located and my experience/background of knowledge of this region. I respect whoever is covering the big-bang, if the aim is not pure celebrity, but Syria is not only about this, there is much else going: I'm in a marginalized region with scarce water and electricity, where you can travel across cities controlled by the regime, the opposition and the Syrian Pkk and I do all of this without anyone escorting me and showing me what he wants me to see. Based on my conversation with locals, I strongly believe in the importance of covering also non-violent contexts to improve the stereotyped vision of the Middle East widespread in Western media. I happened to cover conflicts and violence, but I don't necessarily look for it, regardless of the demands of corporate news agencies.
"those eyes, staring at me; the eyes of people being killed by Assad’s army, one by one, and nobody had even heard of a place called Homs."... "Not only can you not afford insurance—it’s almost $1,000 a month—but you cannot afford a fixer or a translator."
As someone who have studied the Middle East and Arabic for years, like many others, we all knew about Homs before the beautiful pictures of Romenzi. I guess in order to cover a conflict one should also being driven by a knowledge of the context where he is working, not only by heroism. You mentioned that you cannot afford a fixer or a translator, so i guess you don't speak Arabic, then what kind of in-depth knowledge of the context you can provide? This is not personal at all, it's my personal belief on most of those journalists without any background in Middle Eastern languages and studies: what are you doing in Syria? Covering another conflict? War is war, whether in Syria or Kosovo? I strongly disagree with this approach and I think each freelancer should know in advance the specific area he is willing to cover and this will help 'shaping' informed readers rather than blood alcoholics.
#98 Posted by andrea glioti, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 06:40 PM
"My youth, for what it’s worth, vanished when bits of brain splattered on me in Bosnia, when I was 23."
This is quite pathetic, you are there to narrate the pain of others not to explain how your youth vanished because, by the way, you didn't need to go to Bosnia for this. In Italy is full of people who saw their youth vanished, but maybe it sounds less pulp and exotic.
"How can I justify that my staff writer wasn’t able to enter and you were?” I got this email from an editor about that story: “I’ll buy it, but I will publish it under my staff writer’s name.”
This is shameful and you got all my support on this. I had similar experiences, when they tell you that "officially" they don't accept freelancers, but they're willing to do it on condition signing pieces with the names of their staff writers.
Overall, I understand and fully support what you are saying on the readers not grasping what's going on in Syria and editors completely unwilling to go deeper, but if you accept to write a piece for that amount on the front-line, just to tell blood stories, then you're just part of this system. Cheap labor for cheap journalism
best of luck
#99 Posted by andrea glioti, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 07:09 PM
Dear author, thank you for writing a piece with so much soul. I admit, I was thrown off by your last words: "You for whom tomorrow lives...". It must've been my poor comprehension or something! but at first reading, I thought you were speaking to yourself! You went there willingly, your choice, not because you had no alternative. You have your tomorrow but you put yourself in a place with none willingly. I guess when you are used to gunshots from 23, an easy life back home might not fit into your idea of 'reality' anymore. I work in development, in places where water without dirt and salt is worth gold sometimes. I also have a home in the city and the opportunity for working at a 'normal job', but I don't because it's just not me...anymore. Don't complain about the poor pay or stupid bosses. You accepted the work, you therefore are contributing to your poor job market. You're doing this for yourself, not for humanity or education of the well-off masses. You can make your fame in other ways than putting yourself though such dire conditions to hope maybe one day someone great will see your work, hardship and 'pick you up' or best case, you'll get a Pultzier. You're just making it hard for your fellow journatists to work in better conditions because you accepted it so low. Set your standards higher, please. You'll make a greater difference that way. But all in all, I guess some people have to do the work no one else wants to. Just don't make it tough for your colleagues. Good luck in your career.
#100 Posted by Sumaiya, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 07:18 PM
Wow - Francesca I'm awed by your writing, your bravery, your determination, spirit and intelligence. Your fellow journalists salute you.
#101 Posted by Jinah, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 07:22 PM
Well-written article, and good job. Hopefully, you will be free soon ...
Stay safe Francesca ...
#102 Posted by khalil, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 07:52 PM
BRILLIANT article Francesca, your writing, your character, your belief takes my breath away, please stay safe, and THANK YOU!
#103 Posted by Penny-Ann Singer, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 08:07 PM
Frankly sdpeaking I feel like saying that it might be admirable BUT does it make sense? your presence and suffer there does NOT make people more interested in what's happening in Syria believe me, so why risking your life and hoping not to survive a shooting because you don't have money to live when injured... does it really make sense? people don't give a shit about Syria, you are not makin g money, you are not becoming famous or sort of career, your "boss" doesn't give a shit of where you are or what you really do, WHY staying there then? get yr things and get back home and relocate to where your job might be really conisdered not just but the few people who commented on this page...
#104 Posted by Marco, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 08:27 PM
Your editor is a Moron! Thank you for your insightful account of how it is, I learnt a lot.
#105 Posted by Perspective, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 08:32 PM
PS. Should you seek assistance for individuals you might like to approach ICRC and NGOs .
#106 Posted by Perspective, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 08:38 PM
The suggestion given by someone of having your own page is not that bad...
Many find your writings terrific...I don't see anything special in what you wrote a part for the immense frustration in what you are trying to do and in the no consideration of friends and colleagues... I'd like to read more of your job, real sensation and feelings and not about a friend of yours who is looking for the SPA subscription card... Tell us something of a day of yours...
#107 Posted by Marco, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 08:39 PM
There was a plaque in a gift shop that read "The Two Biggest Lies Ever Told: Natural Childbirth and Owning Your Own Business" - I would add a third being a freelancer. As a freelancer a person's talents are exploited in this case a journalist by her editor but it is often the case for designers and other artistic professions in which people are exploited by wealthy corporations to strengthen the bottom line at the expense of the freelancer. No benefits, no health insurance, no retirement, etc. for the freelancer but yet Francesca risks her life to expose the truth instead of mocking her and telling her to BLOG or leave people should acknowledge her respect for humanity and courage. Oh, I don't think she was writing about her concern for her friend's inability to find her SPA card, but using it as an example of how self absorbed people are that someone would send 8 URGENT emails about something so trivial when her friend is in Aleppo at this time. It is shameful. I wish there were more people with Franscesa's character and concern for people and I hope her editor reads not just the article but also the comments so that he knows he lacks the courage and character of his "freelancer"!
#108 Posted by Maureen Kelly, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 10:03 PM
Take care, Francesca.
Love!
#109 Posted by Kairam Ahmed Hamdan, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 10:25 PM
Francesca: What you have produced here is perhaps the most powerful piece of journalism I have ever read. Please come home. You have done your part now.
#110 Posted by Peter, CJR on Wed 10 Jul 2013 at 10:33 PM
If an editor is unwilling to publish a piece that she has written that truly analyzes and explains what is going on, she should take that piece and publish it herself on a personal blog. That is the power of the internet. I realize that she would not be paid, but if the piece is already written, and the editor has rejected it, what does she have to lose?
#111 Posted by bj, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 12:26 AM
You are an excellent writer. I visualized and understood everything you wrote in this article. Fascinating. You are brave, courageous, and tenacious. I admire you. I could never do what you do. I salute you. I would not know any of this had I not read this article. Thank you.
#112 Posted by Lynn Clark, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 01:35 AM
Francesca, I understand and can relate as I'm a freelancer too. Lately, I've come to learn that most editors don't want news, just sensation and scandal with an angle. It has to be infotainment and they pay next to nothing for hard news.
#113 Posted by D, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 02:33 AM
A 80s Columbia graduate - I launched a website VOICES OF WOMEN WORLDWIDE & VOWW-TV at http://voicesofwomenworldwide-vowwtv.ning.com and on 4th of July celebrated a successful 2nd anniversary with over 2,000+ members (women, young girls/boys and men who believe in gender equality and female empowerment. Today VOWW is already spreading across 82 countries, giving the "voiceless" voices to tell their fascinating stories ... grassroots women and young girls ...
Thanks for Francesca Borri artice and background ... I will search out her two books on Kosovo and Israel/Palestine,. Like most women, she turned to journalism when she realized that power players were more upset by what she wrote... Bravo ! B
ilissimo !
#114 Posted by Vinanti Castellarin, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 02:36 AM
Well, done No mean task. No easy jb doing what you are doing. As a journalist, I appreciate you.
#115 Posted by Ruth Aine , CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 03:47 AM
Grazie mille, Francesca. Great article. Best of luck to you.
#116 Posted by Petteri Numminen, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 03:58 AM
Great article. However, I dont' think it is the evil editors. I think it is us, the people. I was together with a journalist in early 1999 in Kosovo and we were interviewing a father whose whole family had dissipated the previous evening. He found his wife shot and his brother shot as well but he couldn't locate his two sons and little daughter. While we interviewed him, in his most difficult moments of his entire life, my French journalist colleague noticed a group of stray puppies. She left the poor old man answering and went to express her love to the puppies and asked me to translate to the old man "what has happened to the mother of the puppies." In spite of my love for the animals, I told her that I'm not going to translate that question and that it was a stupid question to make at this time. Compassion is something a lot of people just don't have. And there are those that have it for the public.
#117 Posted by miscellan, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 04:01 AM
Credo che ci siano vari punti da considerare.
Prima di tutto la giornalista francesca, scrive, qui, soprattutto per un disagio personale. Umanamente comprensibile. La sindrome post traumatica da stress è un disagio che molte persone che tornano da zone di guerra provano. Proprio per la disumanità che vedono e di cui hanno esperienza.
Tuttavia, il problema mi pare sia a monte: sul perchè si sceglie questo lavoro?
Io ho letto molti pezzi di Francesca, e anche i suoi due libri.
Quel che critico è la supponenza.
Sembra quasi che vada in zone con problematiche per dimostrare al mondo che lei è diversa. Lei non è come tutti noi che non sappiamo nulla di homs..
Questo mi sembra arrogante, e nemmeno troppo intelligente.
Molte persone, invece sono informate, e sottovalutare gli altri mi sembra un punto di partenza sbagliato che un giornalista può avere.
E poi, c'è tristemente, quasi la ricerca di un vissuto esotico.
E' il sentirsi diversa dagli altri, per non dire superiore, che mi disturba.
E questo l'ho colto in molti articoli di francesca che ho letto; dove il sottotesto dice: guardate che vita al di là dei limiti vivo. Perchè lei, nei suoi scritti mette molto sè stessa, e da un lato è molto bella come scelta, però la supponenza che trapela a me non piace.
Altri giornalisti non mi danno questa sensazione. Andrea Bernardi ad esempio: anche lui copre la Siria, e non ha per niente questo atteggiamento.
E' estremmente chiaro nelle sue spiegazioni, e, sembra almeno, essere lì per informare i lettori. Non per dimostrare qualcosa a sè stesso.
#118 Posted by ginevra, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 04:07 AM
I went through several wars, as a journalist and as an humanitarian worker for many years. Your story rang such a strong bell. I do blame the press also for their manipulation.But I believe that testimonies like yours will one day (hopefully not to far away) provoke some changes in the media. Bon courage!
Danielle Maillefer
#119 Posted by Danielle Maillefer, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 04:08 AM
Great article. I hope to read more from Francesca Borri, are some of her articles and books translated in English?
#120 Posted by Waldemar , CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 04:22 AM
Dear Francesca,
For a bloody bang bang frontline piece, you earn 70 dollars. This piece, however, doesn't make you a living. It makes you very much alive instead. You made me rethink and reconsider my opinion. Which is priceless.
As soon as you stepped out of the 70 dollar a piece structure, your influence skyrocketed.
My utmost respect and gratitude.
#121 Posted by Bart van der Griendt, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 04:37 AM
Author has made some valid points.
Problems is things are determined by the market forces.
Pepsi Coke sell a drink which costs few cents for a dollor is decided by the markets.
Artisans here in India find it difficult to make few cents on their items worth few dollors which took them months to make.
What fucking low payouts are you talking here???
As a financial consultants people want all free advise for their financial planning.
People want free advise on their stock trading, i dont get even 70 dollors for my advise and its all good and all for free.
You cant change the world. Either accept your profession the way it is or move on to another one.
Dont Crib. It helps u get your emotions out but thats about it.
#122 Posted by Amit, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 04:39 AM
"People have this romantic image of the freelancer as a journalist..."
Yeah, maybe back in the 1940's. Nowadays, the only people with that notion are the journalists themselves.
Your writing reeks of narcissism.
#123 Posted by Matt, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 04:43 AM
Thank you, Francesca!
#124 Posted by Maggy Ritz, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 05:37 AM
I'm sorry but $70 is shit. Is your life worth $70? Will the world be a better place for you risking your life? I have been a journalist for 3 decades but this sort of cheap shit devalues everyone and their endeavours. Get out or get paid properly.
#125 Posted by Margot, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 06:00 AM
Dear Francessca, thank you for your amazing, brave and truthful account of your experience as a journalist. As a fellow journalist, who comfortably sits in a office most days, I applaud your guts and willingness to be there under the circumstances. It is shocking that you are being treated this way by editors driven by profit and the insatiable need for sensation. Be safe.
#126 Posted by emma, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 06:50 AM
Sderot is being bombed daily? Do you mean those home made flying drainpipes? I have already volunteered to take a vacation in Sderot. You should try living in Liverpool UK for a while. By the way; Sderot is Palestinian.
#127 Posted by Joe Kelsall, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 06:53 AM
"Ok, go, but make sure to write us an e-mail where you state that we had nothing to do with your trip." My editor's support note a couple of days before I was going to Mogadishu for Xmas 2010. I'm sorry, I am to blame: I still find my "job" very romantic and I wouldn't want to do anything else in life, no matter the costs.
#128 Posted by Matteo Fraschini Koffi, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 06:57 AM
thank you for sharing this and for your intentions.
#129 Posted by ludo, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 07:13 AM
Francesca! Don't listen to people who say all this is "just how things are", "just how journalism is"! Everything you describe is happening in other fields and in other workplaces too, even in education. We are living in extreme neoliberal times and you have just described the neoliberal workplace and its extremes. There are plenty of ways to put out your work and other alternative outlets which reach even more readers and which challenge everything you describe. You're already working almost for free---join them.
#130 Posted by Lily, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 07:49 AM
Please Francesca, read what Mother Agnes Mariam has written about this war for Syria's freedom - from invading mercenaries and Islamic fundamentalists; you will find many many people in Syria, now in the areas protected by the Syrian army, who will show you their dedication to the sorts of values you are expressing here, which are values of secular socialism and freedom and equality.
As your editors call only for blood stories , realise that this is because it is they who are cutting the veins of the Syrian people by supporting this criminal insurgency with their propaganda and their business interests and allegiances to the Gulf dictatorships and Imperial partners.
And please don't risk to shed your own blood for this dreadful cause - it is not for the Syrian people that you would do it.
#131 Posted by David M, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 07:49 AM
It's very sad: journalists as well as photojournalists (I am one of them) are going to the place that is "the mediatic news of the moment" (now is Siria but it happened also with Palestine, Haiti, ecc...) in mass with the result that in those places they are so many that you will see people pinting the wrong direction of a demostration, people who fight for the best spot to take pictures to a dead body, people who pay a fixer 250 $ and then accept to publish for 70$, people who fake situations with the purpouse to sell the picture and so on... and there are dozens of wars and other situations who will deserve a spotlight that are totaly undercovered because they are not "on fashion". And this why? Of course not for money because this freelances are spending more that what they are making, not to give voice to anyone because if there are alredy a lot people in the same place one more or one less it does not make any difference... they are doing it just because they hopo to win an award or to have thier minute of celebrity.
Dear Francesca, I have a suggestion for you: you worked in the human rights field, you are not anymore a young kid in search of adrenaline and you write very well... why you don't leave this "media circus" and try to give voice to someone about noone cares... it can be a small ethnic group as well as a small group of disciminated woman maybe in your own country... it may not be such a "fashionable subject" but you will be the only one who report it and so you will have more chance to see it published or awarded that you have in Siria that is "the hottest topic of the moment" but from where there are so many people doing exately your same things. Best of luck! A
#132 Posted by Annette, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 08:32 AM
Wonderful piece.
Many interesting commentaries, some trying to ascertain what is right or wrong about piece. For me, it was above all a statement from a person, in a particular place and time, about what she was feeling. Fascinating and moving.
#133 Posted by Timothy, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 09:08 AM
Yep, it's an important story, Yep it's dangerous, Yep the pay sucks. This is one of the most self-absorbed, self-indulgent pity parties I've ever read. It's a poorly written, rambling and generally a piece of crap from a writing perspective. Sorry, I know it's from the heart but it's poorly written , seemingly endless and horribly edited.
#134 Posted by Bob, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 09:10 AM
quitting your job to do something that you believe is more meaningful, though you know beforehand that the pay is ridiculous, that it will be extremely dangerous and probably still not make much of a difference in this world... all my respect. but then complain about how dangerous it is, how badly paid it is and that nobody really cares? hmmm, talk about self-inflicted misery. and the special 'treatment' she would receive from time to time for being a woman: what do you expect in the masculine dominated societies of the middle east and a war situation in which probably 99% of the fighting participants are male and the air completely overloaded with testosteron? as a frontline freelancer, I guess you either get enough satisfaction out of the job to endure all of the above - or you should really just do something else.
#135 Posted by Niko, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 10:17 AM
I can understand her situation. I have and still dabble as a freelance journalist (but not the war journo). I know what we have to go through besides being a woman. The demands of editors, low pay and risks and lots more. Heh, i'm with you...
#136 Posted by Dhara, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 10:24 AM
Up yours, Bob. You wouldn't know good writing if it crashed your party with an AK47 in one hand and a bottle of champagne in the other.
Francesca,I wish you joy, some day soon. Thank you for this.
#137 Posted by Ngwenya, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 10:25 AM
Many levels to consider here, not least of which is the notion that editors know what readers really want to read and understand.
#138 Posted by Patrick Bennett, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 10:38 AM
I wouldn't classify you as a journalist. I'd call you a Palestinian propagandist and terrorist enabler.
#139 Posted by Carl, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 10:50 AM
I will try to love and remain fearless like you asked. It's been a while since I have read something that reminds me how cruel and greedy we all are and what we allow to happen in our names.
#140 Posted by steph, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 10:55 AM
I absolutely loved this piece, especially as an aspiring female journalist myself. (I have the degree, but I'm just starting out and can't even begin to compare myself to you.) I hate that some people in the comments here seem to think you're just complaining about your job. Those readers obviously missed the point. I recognize the amazing risks you're taking and find you to be inspiring, Your understanding of war is really all there is to it, and yet you're there for some reason, and I think it's more than a prize that's never coming. I think it's because you're a writer. And I hope you one day are compensated for your skill appropriately, both financially and emotionally.
#141 Posted by Rachel, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 10:59 AM
I'm so glad I read the entire piece. I forwarded it as soon as I was compelled by the opening paragraphs. But truly, you can not end a piece like this is in any other way. So Human, so desperate, so beautiful. Simply brilliant.
#142 Posted by Loz in Transit, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 11:01 AM
$70 a piece. Honey, you need to find another occupation or better publications.
#143 Posted by Jimmy Hoffa, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 11:11 AM
I am so proud of you. I think back to those two journalists that died in the beginning of this insane conflict and say, "Why can't this end?" I understand your reaction when someone says this isn't a place for a woman. However, there is a sense relieve that this person who said this still has a shred of human dignity and chivelry.
#144 Posted by Heather , CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 11:14 AM
It's a pleasure to meet you, Francesca, in that corner. I'd like to take your hand and said to you, don't be afraid. Your words are very strong as to see a sirian man, blooding in the street . I can imagine your're disappointed, you're forced to see , what someone else want , putting the light there and not where your heart beats. But your words live now in freedom, without editorial or war rules.You're yourself and I'm proud that you're Italian and woman too.
All the best to you.
P.s. I beg your pardon if my english is not understandable..
Antonia Leonardis
#145 Posted by Antonia Leonardis , CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 11:20 AM
I would love to read what you would prefer to write about, your insight and writing is wonderful. Do you publish the deeper stuff elsewhere?
#146 Posted by Kyle, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 11:28 AM
Francesca, brava for your courage and conviction, but if we journalists and photographers continue to accept such low fees, news organizations will never increase rates or working conditions. Let's try to strategize for fair working conditions and pay.
#147 Posted by Jodi Hilton , CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 11:30 AM
Well the two negative comments around should understand. That es notable just about bombs, murder and deads. The whole message it's about hummanity... the kind of hummanity that we normaly forgot just because of we are too busy thinking about how kool it's tour little point of View. She's giving a truly meaning oficial every article. Thank you francessca. We hace The article in spanish now. And must be transmite into antes language. All The energy and support from colombian. Bless.
#148 Posted by luisa ramos sobrino, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 11:30 AM
Humbled by you and those alongside you, who are the sane voices and the voices of possible change.
#149 Posted by Karin Petersen, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 11:37 AM
This is one of the most moving pieces I've read. The perils of journalism, freelancing in wartime, and trying to work with editors who refuse to believe we the readers DO want analysis and insight not hyperbolic infotainment, you cover them all in such a painfully vivid way. Journalism is a public service, it is a particular form of speech that is abolutely essential to democracy and an educated populous, yet the pay is pathetic and unsustainable (much like that of teachers, who also provide an undervalued public service#. I hope you are aware of the Rory Peck Trust, the Committee to Protect Journalists and the Doha Centre for Media Freedom, all of which provide security trainings, support, equipment and help with insurance. After reading your piece I am glad I didn't take an #unamed here# newspaper's offer to let me go to Iraq for them as a freelancer back in 2004; I rejected the 'offer' after the editor explained that they would not cover security costs. Unacceptable. This risks you are taking are worth so much more than $70, and shame on those who would take your work under another's name. I only hope that you know there are people around the world who are profoundly grateful for your sacrifice. Maybe you could start Kickstarter campaign to at least raise some money to keep covering what is turning #has turned?# into an intractable and incredibly messy war. From one journalist to another, thank you and I hope you remain safe.
#150 Posted by Courtney Radsch, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 12:21 PM
Dear Francesca,
Thank you a thousand times for your commitment, your bravery and your heart. I absolutely never comment on the news articles I read, but today I break with that tradition and send you love, blessings and the knowledge that you are never, ever truly alone.
The treatment by your superiors is to be expected in the decaying and dying world that pretends to be journalism. However, rest assured that the paradigm is changing, how we receive our news and information is changing, and you, brave young lady, are part of the amazing future of that change.
We will figure out a way for you and your like minded colleagues to receive proper and just compensation for your tremendous efforts. I will be in Rome in September, as i am often, and I expect to see you at your book signing when I purchase your title from you in person.
Many Blessings and Safe Travels back!
#151 Posted by Garón Peterson, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 12:21 PM
amazing - journalism with feeling.
#152 Posted by Ben Moody, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 12:22 PM
Next Steps
1.Get the fuck out.You've earned your stripes!
2.Relize that you have become an authority on War Reporting and reconsider your Options.
3.You may remain a frelancer but by all means do some extra media work on the side like media training, freelance editing,public speaking.
4.Get a website and market your skills.Please find out what other journalists in the mainstream media charge a d insist on being paid for what you are worth!
.
#153 Posted by Chima Nwankwo, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 01:34 PM
I am in the same profession and I can't believe how badly the Italian media pays and how your editor would publish your stories under a different writer's name. Some of my freelance colleagues in Syria are getting $500 a story as I did in Libya and Egypt. That is high pay but the average is generally around $250. The lowest I ever got paid was $150 and that was for the smaller publications and the easier stories. I will also point out I don't expose myself to danger to the same degree you do.
#154 Posted by tucking_fwit, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 01:46 PM
I truly don't know what is more depressing to read, the conditions that Francesca has had to endure during her time in Syria or the ignorance of some of the comments that have been posted as a result of this article.
This is not some poor woman whining about being sent to Syria, this is a qualified seasoned professional who has been busting her ass day in and day out trying to report news to a readership more interested in the new AC Milan player and Berlusconi's indiscretions.
I am also a female journalist and although I have never covered a war zone, I have covered conflict zones in Latin America where where I risked my life because they were important stories to tell and where I had to endure harassment in a male-dominated field.
The situation of low wages for the work we do is outrageous, in both staff and freelance positions. Media moguls and editors in air-conditioned offices are so obsessed with clicks and attracting readers with headlines, they don't even care if people get past the fold. The same value is given to a tweet than a well-written 5,000-word story. It is a situation that needs to change from the top down.
Should Francesca be risking her life and filing stories for just $70? of course not. The problem is someone is probably willing to do it for $50. And what is the alternative for a woman of her qualifications, to leave Syria and open up a nice PR agency in Rome? The problem is the industry's disrespect for our work and the lack of value given to journalism as an industry (as opposed to law, finance, etc).
To those of you who have the audacity to call this woman a whore, I hope you enjoy criticizing her from the comforts of your own homes and listening to your top 40 radio station during your daily commute to work. I'm sure any one of you wouldn't have survived a day in her shoes.
Francesca, stay safe and thank you for sharing your experience. I know it must have been a difficult article to write. I hope things get better before they get worse and that you are able to find companionship rather than competition along the way.
#155 Posted by Cecilia, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 01:52 PM
I hope that CJR paid more than $70 for this beautiful piece. Stay safe.
#156 Posted by Shinobi, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 01:53 PM
When I worked as a freelancer correspondent from Latin America for a number of Italian newspapers and magazines, twenty years ago or so, they used to pay $120-150 per story. Calculating inflation, this must be three or four times more what they're paying now to Francesca -- and I was not covering any war...
Print journalism industry is in deep, maybe terminal crisis in Europe and North America (although newspapers sales are up in Asia, North Africa, Latin America, and the Middle East); quality print journalism in Italy is practically dead, especially when it comes to international affairs coverage. My two cents of wisdom for Francesca and all the courageous, young idealistic colleagues like her: stay safe, avoid stupid risks (no story is worth your life or your leg or your arm); find another market, writing in another language; explain in graphic details to your multiple editors what they can do with their $70 (or $150); don't suppose that staff writer are happier than you, they're frustrated, too (although they're paid more and have insurance and a pension fund); start thinking what you would like to do after moving on from journalism.
This is what I did, many years ago. Now I choose carefully what to read to keep informed -- and I never, ever read bang-bang stories.
#157 Posted by Giancarlo Summa, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 02:01 PM
I could have never put it in words the way u did. I could feel every beat of your heart that beat while u wrote this. Insane u may say, but that's how deep u wrote. I wonder were humanity went? And where are the ppl of earth? How can we live in 2013 and still allow war to take over; We who have made so much in this world, We who came so far in almost everything. Yet we are weak, weak to not achieve what we really dream for.
#158 Posted by Rima, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 02:24 PM
Fantastic, lyrical, brutal, honest article.
#159 Posted by Farah, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 03:08 PM
I used to work for the Financial Times, the Christian Science Monitor and the New York Times.
I stopped. The FT and CSM pay $50 for a 400-word blog piece and the NYT pays $150 a day as its rate.
It was so unfair to pay such pittances, while the bosses get six-figure salaries, that I just refused to accept it any more.
If everyone just says No, they'll be forced to pay more.
#160 Posted by James, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 04:35 PM
Life is horrible there I am sure. I can never get my mind around civilized countries warring in this day and age. War should not even be an option towards a resolution. We have the UN and other groups that can aid in solving problems in nations that are struggling internally. If they would only implement wisdom and some common sense, peace would be such an easy thing to obtain.
Ms. Borri. If you are to die today it will happen today. Press on and be smart and careful. Fear will have a negative effect on your safety so don't let it overwhelm you. You look like a brave young woman so keep in mind that not everyone in the world is crazy and you are an exceptional person because you aren't sitting on your hands but are 'doing it'.
#161 Posted by George Saikaley, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 05:04 PM
And what about the Christian families (men, women, and children) who wished to stay out of the conflict, but were murdered by the rebel army? Do their eyes stare at you too?
http://moderntokyotimes.com/2013/06/29/christian-priest-beheaded-in-syria-gulf-and-western-powers-support-takfiri-and-fsa-barbarity/
http://digitaljournal.com/article/353346
#162 Posted by James Anderson, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 05:22 PM
Francesca,
your article is breathtaking...It seems everything so honest and true...I'm really chocked of what you are going through. I think that you are an idealist, still, and that you thing that your job will make a difference in the world. I'm sure it makes, of course, and it makes sense..."to give voice to the voiceless"...thank you.
your words are a hymn to peace and a testimony to the humanity that is going lost everyday, piece by piece..... The way how the editors treat you, the way how the colleagues look at you and consider you, the way how the UN deals with children, etc etc....it's just that the humans are loosing their humanity.....
In war the humanity gets lost.....but there is no excuse on the others that live elsewhere (editors, friends etc)...
I thing that you have overcome your fear, hence you are writing this article and published it. But you should take care also of your life, because it makes a difference for somebody: for your family. Please, take care of yourself and come back home safe.
P.s. I'll try to find your books on Kosova and Israel/Palestina and read it. Thank you.
#163 Posted by Oriana, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 05:23 PM
This is a brilliant piece, and I just wish more about the life of freelancers, and the conditions they have to endure, was published. I was a freelancer in west Africa for 12 years, and only one publication ever worried about me when I was stuck in the middle of a coup and couldn't get out. The last time I visited Mali, I slept on a mattress on a roof for a week, because I couldn't afford a hotel, and then the fee for my radio pieces was cut almost in half, meaning I couldn't make a profit on my three weeks' work, or even break even. When it came to recording the pieces, I was asked "for more energy and enthusiasm" in my voice from editors in London. We want this kind of reporting, but we don't want to pay for it, and in the end it is the reporter on the ground, the one in danger or discomfort, who pays for it.
#164 Posted by Rose Skelton, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 05:26 PM
I think her comments about depth of analysis lacking in mainstream press are spot on. And it is important that there are those willing to take risks to let the world know of atrocities and other abuses being perpetrated. However in terms of her reflections on her job, just like anyone else who is dissatisfied with their pay and conditions, you can choose to change your situation. She's clearly well qualified and should be able to find alternative work.
#165 Posted by Kitty, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 05:55 PM
You're absolutely right - and I sympathize with your situation - but it's time that you left these horrendous war zones and found a career that is satisfying - before you completely lose your soul and faith in everything and everyone. Good luck.
#166 Posted by Louise, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 06:02 PM
Dear Francesca, I have nothing to add to what has been said above, and admire your courage, including the "courage" to have fear.
Please keep on this track, and look for deepening the real understanding of a conflict. There is this Dutch journalist, Joris Luijendijk, whom you should meet/read about, he does just that, trying to understand and communicate complicated issues to common people like myself - maybe sharing these thoughts with like minded would help? unfortunately I do not work in the media, but can promise to be a reader.
#167 Posted by Wendeline van der Feltz, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 06:12 PM
Thank you for this piece, which opened my eyes to an injustice I knew little about. Media really is in a crisis if the front-liners compete with each other, and intelligent articles aren't wanted. I for one have searched (briefly) for more depth about Syria. Good luck.
#168 Posted by Su, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 06:30 PM
This woman is writing about what the world should know, and yet we only see what the editor's want us to see, if only there was a way to put out the real story and get this journalist the pay she deserves. Hell I'd be willing to pay out of my own pocket to stop this bullshit from going on, any ideas out there?
#169 Posted by mitch fears, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 07:24 PM
Onestly, Francesca, if editors pay 70$ a piece, without covering travel and living expences and insurance is because people like you and your collegues/competitors accept so. Normaly clients send a proferssional journalist into a place, pay for all the expences and pay 10 times what you get... Wonder why if there are dozen of people who accept to pay their own expences and publish almost for free the market is becameing what it is. I tell you the truth... editors do buy your 70$ piece because they are forced to but they will respect you more if you will refuse this conditions. I am not here to blame you and your "friends" for taking away the work to other journos that need to feed themself and so will never affort to spend all that money just to "experience Syria" and publish some pieces that will not even pay your expences back but please do not complain for something that you choose and for a sistem that you are contibruting to screw...
#170 Posted by NF, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 07:33 PM
Francesca, you are a hero. Period. You are doing what I got into to journalism to do, but ultimately gave up on because I knew it would likely mean living my life alone. Thank you for doing your best to illuminate the chaos.
#171 Posted by SharonNYC, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 09:24 PM
great work. It is hard to understand the war, the people through the media, but with you and all the freelance, the people who really care get a better understanding of the war , this is amazing things, it change your way of living-though not everybody, not your press boss.
#172 Posted by Hui f, CJR on Thu 11 Jul 2013 at 11:14 PM
When you finally have space to breathe, and a safe place, please take a look at this website http://marianne-elliott.com/about/. Marianne worked on human rights in Afghanistan and came to realize that she had to take care of herself if she was to help others. Do find time to take care of yourself. In compassion.
#173 Posted by Janice Smart, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 12:24 AM
This was a pretty powerful read, to be sure. But I can't help but wonder about it...hope you'll forgive the lengthy rant.
Parts of it seem way overwritten, such as:
"..the American musicians with bin Laden-style beards who insist this helps them blend in, even though they are blonde and six-feet, five-inches tall. (They brought malaria drugs, even if there’s no malaria here, and want to deliver them while playing violin.)"
This is my hangup: I know A LOT of musicians — none of which are 6'5", and very few that have crazy bin Laden-style beards and/or misguided humanitarian streaks. Of those musicians I personally know who are smart, brave, and so adventurous as to potentially seek enlightenment on such perilous frontlines — not to mention have the financial means to do so — how likely is it that they'd also be ignorant and superficial enough to do what she describes?
Not likely at all, in my estimation.
At best, it seems like a very rare person she must have met and described — and therefore not worthy of writing about as if it was the norm.
More cynically, she is over-dramatizing her experience. And even more cynically: this piece seeks to increase her own personal stock in the same way she decries newspaper editors for wanting more of "the blood, the bang-bang."
That is, this piece is 'powerful' thanks to the same elements that she criticizes her editors for demanding in her reporting.
Her basic point resonates, though. Journalism as we've known it is falling off fast in favor of other bottom-line means to a seemingly similar end: freelancers of all stripes are taking the place of trained professionals. And freelancers are indeed very much treated like second-class journalists, whether they are or not (fwiw: most, not all, freelancers I know are former salaried journalists).
As an editor myself, I wanted to — and sometimes did, I'm sure — apologize when I cut the checks for $125 to cover-story writers for the weekly arts/culture rag I oversaw for a spell (circa 2002-2007). $125 for any story that takes more than a few hours to report and then write is way way way lower than minimum wage — accounting for the doubled income tax freelancers pay as non-employees.
And so, the constant reference by this article's writer to $70 as a per piece income is another element that rouses my skepticism (even 70 Euro is still less than 100 U.S. dollars). How many thoroughly skilled and experienced journalists — as she would seem to be, by her own description — would do that? Even writing from their couch in the U.S. about inane topics? To say nothing of travel to any frontline war?? Maybe she's got a per diem and/or other compensation that she doesn't mention...and if that's the case, the premise of her piece is distorted, at best.
Even so, so many parts of this resonated thoroughly. Most so:
"...contrary to what many editors believe, they are bright readers who ask for simplicity without simplification. They want to understand, not simply to know."
#174 Posted by Phil Cauthon, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 12:27 AM
Amazing story. You should be the one to write Dispatches (Herr) from Syria!
#175 Posted by kendrick, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 12:35 AM
A very moving and thought-provoking piece. without journalists like you, we can never know the truth of what happens in warzones. I completely admire you and your work,
#176 Posted by ALISON FINCH, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 03:00 AM
Mah...
non capisco, francesca ultimamente copre la guerra di siria.
Non c'è stata nessuna indignazione per tutto ciò che ha scritto sulla siria, e ora la gente è disgustata per le condizioni di lavoro di una giornalista occidentale.
Incredibile il provincialismo e la massificazione, che vengono fuori da episodi così.
Ora c'è il delirio su twitter della gente che si complimenta con lei per l'articolo.
Praticamente quasi tutti commenti uguali, senza una critica, e senza che qualcuno tiri fuori qualche angolatura diversa.
Questo è fastidioso, e succede spesso in italia. Qualcuno solleva un polverone e diventa subito eroe.
Che i giornalisti facciano sentire la loro voce, se le condizioni sono queste, e le diffondano.
#177 Posted by giorgio, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 03:35 AM
Phil, I think it's incredibly disrespectful for you to sit there and call her a liar. Oh, you know musicians and none of them are like that? And you know for a fact she is getting paid more than the $70 she says huh? Especially interesting after you just said you have underpaid journalists for their work before. Some pretty good sleuthing there chief, you caught her big lies!
Maybe you and the other morons complaining about her "over-dramatizing" could keep your condescending comments to yourselves since most of us are appreciative of the work she is doing and would rather offer words of encouragement.
Honestly, what do you gain by trashing a well written and clearly heartfelt account of her experiences as a freelance journalist?
It's funny that you're an editor because you sound just like the ones she described who don't really give a crap about her.
#178 Posted by Lydia, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 03:35 AM
Awesome article, I for one applaud you for what you do. Stay safe and keep writing. I will definitely keep and eye out for your pieces.
#179 Posted by Yusuf Suleman, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 03:44 AM
Grazie Francesca, un bacio e un abbraccio. Sono impressionato dal tuo coraggio e dal tuo amore per la verità e per le persone. Sono contento di aver letto il tuo articolo sulla Stampa di Torino perchè altrimenti avrei perso un raro pezzo di umantità e di profonda consapevolezza. Per non capendo bene l'inglese vedo sugli altri commenti critiche agli editor che condivido ma ciò che voglio dirti è che ti apprezzo tanto com e giornalista e come donna.
#180 Posted by claudio audrito, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 03:45 AM
amazing article. well done
#181 Posted by mel, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 04:40 AM
Francesca stay strong and safe. it is difficult to be sane in an insane world. conflict zones have turned into a lucrative business for media houses. resist!! you are not alone..
#182 Posted by Asfandyar wazir, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 04:49 AM
Ciao Francesca,
ti scrivo perchè, dopo aver letto questo tuo articolo, ho riflettuto su diverse cose.
Conosco abbastanza i tuoi lavori: ho letto entrambi i tuoi libri e molti dei tuoi articoli (sia quelli su peacelink sulla palestina e sul libano) sia il tuo reportage sull'ilva, sia molti degli articoli che hai scritto sulla siria.
Trovo da un lato interessante il tuo modo di scrivere; tuttavia sono un pò sorpreso dalla poca stima che sembri avere negli 'altri'.
Dico così perchè mi sembra che tu ti ponga spesso al di sopra, e questo lo trovo, sinceramente, poco rispettoso.
In questo tuo ultimo articolo, tu denunci alcune cose, e fai bene; non sono un giornalista freelance, ma se le condizioni sono queste fai bene a denunciarle.
Tuttavia, quando parli di chi è intorno a te (dalla tua amica che cerca il badge per la spa, ai giornalisti intorno a te) non c'è n'è uno che si salva.
(Ma questo non per mettere in dubbio che ciò sia successo davvero, ma perchè mi pare che tu metta l'accendo quasi sempre sul negativo degli altri).
E questo è un pò il leit motiv di molti dei tuoi scritti: tutto intorno a me è disprezzabile, e io no: io sono diversa.
Io ti stimo per il tuo lavoro. Penso sia necessario che ci siano persone che raccontino la sira.
Tuttavia mi mette un pò a disagio questa supponenza, che ti assicuro trapela.
Anche quando dici: 'nessuno conosceva homs prima che alessio romenzi pubblicasse le sue fotografie sulla siria. Permettimi di dissentire: chi conosce la siria, conosce homs; e c'è tanta gente che la conosce e che si informa. E questo te lo fa notare anche Andrea Glioti (nei vari commenti del sito del CJR), lui, che conosce il medioriente e lavora anch'egli in siria.
E infine nella tua ultima frase, vedo un pò di paternalismo. Sembra quasi che tu dai dei consigli sempre a questi altri', (che poi: altri chi? chi ha tutto?? tutto in che senso??).
Non lo so, questa idea un pò arcaica: divisiva, che chi (è ricco immagino, o è libero.. non so..)
non ha in realtà 'veri' problemi e può vivere senza paure..
Mi sembra molto semplicistico, e (mi dispiace dirtelo) ma ancora, 'giudicato' dall'alto del tuo punto di vista.
Sembra quasi che perchè hai visto una guerra (esperienza tremenda, e su questo non oserei mai metterlo in discussione) allora ti permetti di generallizzare su chi non l'ha vissuta.
Beh, mi viene da dire: ma tu le persone comuni le conosci? Intimamente intendo.
Intendo i tuoi amici, i tuoi cari..
In quante diverse forme si può esprimere il dolore e la paura?
Ma questo al di là delle guerre, e gli strati sociali..
Ripeto, nell'intimità.
Credo, con tutto il rispetto per te, che le persone meritino più rispetto.
Anche su twitter, tanta gente ti ha mostrato solidarietà (poi percarità, spesso la gente dice banalità, e non va molto oltre - però non tutta: guarda tutti i commenti su CJR: vari commenti si critici che solidali sono molto apprezzabili); e tu sembri essere sempre più pronta a lamentarti che a mostrare umiltà e gratitudine.
Non so, dopo aver letto tanto di te, mi è venuto spontaneo dirti questo.
Tanti saluti
#183 Posted by giorgio, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 05:18 AM
Hello Francesca,
I write because, after reading this your article, I reflected on several things.
I know enough of your work: I read both of your books and many of your articles (both on PeaceLink on Palestine and Lebanon) and your reportage on Ilva, whether many of the articles you have written on Syria.
On the one hand I find interesting the way you write, but I'm a bit surprised by the low esteem that seem to have on the 'other'.
I say this because it seems to me that you often put on top yourself, and this I find, frankly, disrespectful.
This your last article, you denounce some things, and do good;'m not a freelance journalist, but if the conditions are such you are right to denounce them.
However, when you talk about those around you ( your friend looking for the badge to the spa, reporters around you) there is one that you save .
(But this is not to doubt that this really happened, but because it seems to me that you note, almost always, the negative of the other).
And this is something of a leitmotif of many of your writings: everything around me is despicable, and I do not: I'm different.
I respect you for your work. I think it is necessary that there are people who write about sira.
However, makes me a little uncomfortable you arrogance, I assure you that this is evident in your work.
Even when you say 'no one knew homs before alessio romenzi publish his photographs on Syria'. Allow me to disagree: who knows syria, knows Homs; and there are many people who know her and that it informs. And this makes you also notice Andrea Glioti (in the various comments from the site of the CJR), he, who knows the Middle East and works in Syria too.
And finally, in your last sentence, I see a bit of paternalism. It almost seems that you give advice always to these other ', (which: others? Those who have everything? Everything in what sense?).
I do not know, this idea a bit archaic divisive, that whoever (I guess it is rich, or is it free .. I do not know ..)
did not actually 'real' problems and can live without fear ..
It seems very simplistic, and (I'm sorry to tell) but still, 'judged' from your point of view.
It seems that because you saw a war (awful experience, and on this I would never dare to question it) then you allow yourself to generallizzare of those who have not experienced it.
Well, I have to say, but you know the common people? Intimately mean.
I mean your friends, your loved ones ..
In how many different forms it can express the pain and fear?
But this is beyond the wars, and social strata ..
Again, the intimacy.
I think, with all due respect to you, that people deserve more respect.
Even on twitter, so many people showed solidarity with you (later Percival, often people say trivial, and does not go very well - but not all: see all the comments on CJR: various comments that are critical solidarity are highly valued), and you seems to be more and more ready to complain that to show humility and gratitude.
I do not know, after reading so much about you, I was tempted to tell you this.
Greetings
#184 Posted by giorgio, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 05:28 AM
Francesca, forgive me. All freelancers are gamblers. Writers who are wordsmiths and who can craft a piece to satisfy their particular interpretation may hit on a Big Story, make headlines, find a just cause etc. and hit the jackpot but they are gamblers. Gamblers have a rough time and only very few indeed hit the Big Time. Most ruin themselves and the people who love them most. And most gamblers just keep on going knowing the rush is better than reality. So please stop complaining, understand your life better.. perhaps that elusive story is just around the corner, you will make your contribution to civilisation and will be handsomely rewarded. In the mean time, I would be happier if you simply left the Syrians to sort themselves out, let the Israeli / Palestinian people sort their problems. If journalists stopped looking for a story perhaps these dreadful situations would be resolved more quickly. Aye. Geoffrey Brinton
#185 Posted by Geoffrey Brinton, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 05:38 AM
Photojournalism is not different from what Francesca describe: a lot of freelancers run to wars and disasters without any assigments, insurance and paying their own expences with the hope of winning an award, ending up in a frontpage or simply beacuse they want to be able to say "I was there".
There is nothing new in this articol: every one in the business knows that there is nothing romantic in the life of this people, every one knows that they are not doing it for justice, in fact to bring to light a situation there is no need of hundreds of journalists all in the same place and every one knows that who is working like this is not making any income from this job but is living of something else, usually they can do this thanks to rich families. Instead of be paid to publish, they pay to be published.
The only new thing is : Francesca is admitting that! Usually there is a kind of agreement between this kind of freelancer... they are all pretending that yes, they are on assigment, that yes they are paid and that yes they survive economically thanks to this job. But let's not be too generic, not all freelancers are like this: many are still well paid and respected and will never accept to publish for 70£. In photojournalism things are changing after what happened in Syria, some newspapers are not accepting anymore submission from who is there on his own. All respected editors should stop accepting submissions from freelancers who go on their own in places like Syria, this will stop of this silly race "to the tragedy", we have to come back to the times in which just people "on assigment" were going. It's better to have a publication an year but well paid than 100 publications in which you had to pay for them. As someone said before me, if all this freelancer will stop to give away their work for 70£ editors will be forced to pay to have the material, it's so simple.
#186 Posted by Terri, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 06:20 AM
The situation in Italy as described by Francesca depends on the fact that there is no real market and editors have never competed with each other on the basis of their news "products."
In Italy, there are no independent media and until recently, all media could count on generous state subsidies. Editors use their media to promote the interests of their political sponsors or to promote their own economic interests.
Similarly, most Italian journalists have betrayed their mission of informing the public and sold out in exchange for huge salaries and all sorts of privileges. Everyone in Italy knows that only the "figli di," the children of journalists, politicians or very wealthy businessmen have a chance of getting hired by a newspaper . Journalists who work for a newscast of one of the major TV companies - state-owned Rai with 3 national networks and Silvio Berlusconi's Mediaset with 3 other national networks - are hired on the basis of their recognized political affiliation and not according to merit.
Recently, Italy's economic woes have spread to the media business as well, and young journalists work for very little money and as "precari," in an "unstable and insecure" situation with or mostly without even a temporary contract and no hope of ever being regularly employed. The majority of these journalists are payed anywhere between 2 euro and 7 euro ($2.60 and $9.13) per article.
In these conditions, accepting to be blackmailed by her editor and accepting to work for in a war zone for 70 euro a day - as Francesca has - only strengthens the hand of the editors who know that other journalist are willing to work for even less.
Unfortunately, young Italian journalists have accepted the system instead of rebelling against it so at present - and this is well known - the only possibility for Italian journalists to be hired on merit is to seek employment with other international (especially European) media and many of the best and brightest have taken advantage of this opportunity.
#187 Posted by Wolfgang Achtner, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 06:39 AM
Very Good on the writing part.
Now...Since these same "Believers" have been murdering each other
since 609 A.D.? Over varying interpretations of the same book?
"Written" by Muhammad, who could neither read nor write?
From where I comfortably sit, they are their own problems.
P.S. There are more sane ways to earn $70.
#188 Posted by Professor Marty, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 07:42 AM
this piece is amazing. i always ask myself how do people survive/organize in such disruptive situations. i also get puzzled by the fact, that being a woman, do you feel less safe among men than if you'd also be a man?
Please do write about the human side of this experience, what you've seen, how people deal with it and between them. I'm sure I'm not the ony eager to read it written by you.
Keep up your courage and showing us the other side!
#189 Posted by Andreia Veiga, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 07:51 AM
Dear Francesca, did you ever thought that if editors and colleagues do not respect you is because you are accepting to pay your trips, lodging, 250 US$ a day for a car and to publish almost for free? This is not a job for you and this is not fair competition as it is obvious that who has to make his/her living from journalism cannot compete with you. You are complaining about people like Beatriz who are not fair competitors but are you a fair competitor to them? To accept to travel to Syria on your own expenses and to be paid for a piece 5 times less that what you are spending a day it's not fair competion! If for you can stay in Syria spending more money than for a luxury vacation and working almost for free, lucky you, but it will be more fair to write for a personal blog (so you can also write what you really want to) ... do you understand that if professinal journalism is almost dead it's because of people like you?
#190 Posted by ASavic, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 08:30 AM
All the best for a very brave person. Follow your spirit, it's the best what you do.
#191 Posted by Fabio, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 08:51 AM
Maybe all the advice-givers should turn their chastisements to the publishers who abuse their freelancers in this gross manner. Readers and viewers have to demand fair treatment of the writers and shooters who risk their lives to let the world know what is going on and the circumstances that brought such violence to bear. Thank YOU for YOUR service.
#192 Posted by Robin Kemp, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 08:59 AM
It is true that Italian editors are mostly focused on gossip and sensational topics, and that Italian journalism is decadent. But it is also true that if you go to war they publish your articles. Sometimes it's braver to write about other deeper subjects, whether you are in conflict areas or not.
Francesca Lancini
Foreign affairs independent journalist
#193 Posted by Francesca Lancini, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 10:03 AM
I loved the article. But allow me just a recommendation: I work in the humanitarian sector, I am in a extremely diffucult context, but we should never feel ourselves 'better' or more 'brave' than others..and the reason why people in Europe they do not know about Aleppo is simply because they struggle to survive with 1000 EUR per month...we should never forget it..take care
#194 Posted by elis, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 10:22 AM
To anyone that feels compelled to criticize this woman's work, you are clearly living in your own personal fantasy and have not the experience to even begin to understand the depths of this person's convictions nor have you heard a word she's really said. You might want to find somewhere else to vent your feelings of inadequacy which is a lot easier than following your passion. "I took the road less traveled, and that has made all the difference."
#195 Posted by Edgar, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 11:10 AM
Luv that. Simply brilliant
#196 Posted by Giancarlo Narciso, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 11:11 AM
Bravo, Francesca.
Man's inhumanity to man has no bounds. The complexity that is the civil war you find yourself in cannot take away from the humanity in your voice. However much you are being payed pails in comparison. Many more will go to their graves before man finally changes course. Unfortunately, we are not there yet. The real force behind this tragedy remains hidden. Until such time as it is exposed, people like you will always be caught in the middle. Francesca never lose your humanity, it will be missed back home in Italy.
Good luck
#197 Posted by Nick Adornato, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 11:37 AM
As far as I know, Homs is the third largest city in Syria. The fact that "nobody was yet aware of the existence of Homs" is a quite big problem for you and for everybody you referred to.
Aleppo-Homs-Hama-Damascus. Back to basics, then be a journalist.
#198 Posted by Fabio, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 11:52 AM
I will try to write in english... First: in those comments there are a lot of generalizing of -freelance journalists -italian press and -woman journalists. Not all the freelance work in this conditions and are considered "serie B", not all the media underpay and do not provide insurance and refound of expences. I know many people who went to Siria with all the expences paid, the insurance and with a good salary, I know magazines that pay even 1000£ for a reportage (and the photos double) if it's done in a difficult area and takes many pages, I know woman who went to all the wars, are tall, blond use make up and do not hide themselfes but no male will ever say a world to them (look at Stella Pende for example). Then yes there are many people like Francesca who are accepting this conditions, for different reasons. And some media take advantage of them so they can have difficolt reports without spending money. Why they do that? Many are just starting and they hope that going to Syria is the shortest way to get some spotlight and beginning a career, others for the adrenaline, and so on... I don't know Francesca but from her worlds I think she is splitted between beeing an activist and a professional journalist, nothing wrong with it but if I can give her a suggestion is to be drastic in separating her "2 sides": when you are doing something because you belive in it and you are ready to pay all by yourself, to risk for it, ecc... why to adapt it to the request of an editor for such little money that will not even make difference compare to what you spent? just write 100% what you think and publish it in Human Rights media, in a blog, ecc... as you did in the care of this page; when you are doing something because an editor asked you to do it, then ask for money, insurance, expences, ecc... if they don't give it to you, just turn off the job. It has to sense to do something you do not belive in and is risky if it does not pay you. Others journalists are getting those things, why should you do the same things and do not getting them? If everyone will do like this the editors will be forced to pay everyone and to choose who to assign depending on the quality and not according to who will do it for less. There shoud be a "journalists sindacate" a "minimum salary" and some rules so that all the media will be forced to pay insurance and expences if they want to use writings and pictures from someone in a dangerous area.
#199 Posted by Laura, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 12:24 PM
The topic of this story reflects the fate of Karen Fischer. She was a freelancer for Deutsche Welle Radio in 2006. Deutsche Welle wouldn't 'officially' send her to Afghanistan, and therefore not pay for any part of her costs, but they loaned her equipment and bought her reports.
She was murdered.
http://www.dw.de/memorial-service-held-for-deutsche-welle-journalists/a-2199746
#200 Posted by Dennise, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 01:28 PM
Retorico, sembra un Hemingway fuori tempo massimo.Pieno di luoghi comuni: litaliano inseguito dalla mamma, il giapponese annoiato... non vale i 70 dollari.
#201 Posted by mommo mimmo, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 02:07 PM
Sometime in the narcissistic 80s, reporters started to write everything from the first person perspective--their perspective. They started to translate their emotion into the story. They no longer reported news, they started writing prose and became actors in the multicultural soup. In the 90s they started getting agents and commanded large salaries. In the 00s they became independents and their narrative strove to both define the situation and produce change. To be very honest, I don't give a sh*t. If it's so bad, go home; but quit complaining. There are a lot fo folks who can't walk away from the nightmare of war for many reasons. If you choose to be a reporter, than do your damn job without complaining. Sheesh.
#202 Posted by AJ, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 02:51 PM
Don't like your job - don't do your job. Why to complain and "frighten" us, "bastards" in warm and safe places, with all these smashed brains stories? You are not victim of the war. You are one of those professionals at war. What to expect then? And even more confusing is "woman's work" point - do you expect some special attitude toward you because of your gender? Sorry, but Syria is not fancy Stockholm district.
#203 Posted by Artur, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 03:36 PM
As a reader, not a freelancer, let me say I'm starving for the kind of pieces you describe you would like to write - ones that get beyond the boom and bang of spectacle-driven journalism. Reading the news I feel like I'm trapped in a fun house of mirrors only showing me warped images of what it thinks I want (or wants me to want), providing no real substance. No history. No detailed account of the complexity of things. I hunt for the articles you describe everyday. Sometimes something turns up in an editorial. Sometimes I find them on a random blog. It's rare. I don't know if it's any consolation, but here is a readership of one that wishes and hopes and hunts for the world of journalism you describe. I like to think I'm not alone. From the comments here, it seems I'm not. I imagine as a writer you realize at some point you can only write for those who will "hear" what it is you have to say. There will always be those who won't because they simply can't. I've seen many comments up here of the latter, but more of the former.
Please take care. We're listening.
#204 Posted by S. Callaghan, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 04:02 PM
Globally we are seven million human beings. Most of us have no voice. Journalists speak for us. When done with clear honesty, "one voice, one book, one piece of paper, can change the world." And makes hearts smile in unison.
#205 Posted by Suzanne Majo De kuyper, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 04:53 PM
This is a good read. Thanks for this article Francesca.
#206 Posted by Anika, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 06:16 PM
Francesca,
There is one statement in your article that I would like you to clarify for me.
You wrote: "(...) And it would so please me to reply that I cannot submit an analysis piece, because the editors would simply spike it and tell me, “Who do you think you are, kid?”—even though I have three degrees, have written two books, and spent 10 years in various wars, first as a human-rights officer and now as a journalist. My youth, for what it’s worth, vanished when bits of brain splattered on me in Bosnia, when I was 23."
Your last sentence has me really puzzled and wondering if you aren't a phoney.
You were born in 1980 and at present you are 33 years old. Therefore you were 23-years-old in 2003. Now, I'm very curious to find out just whose brains were "splattered" on you at that time, since the Bosnian War had ended in 1995, i.e. 8 years earlier then the date of your alleged mishap. The incident you describe couldn't have been during the Kosovo War either, because that conflict took place from 28 February 1998 until 11 June 1999.
I'd be very grateful to read your reply
Sincerely,
Wolfgang Achtner,
I am a Rome-based international correspondent and producer, documentary filmmaker, author and journalism educator.
According to Wikipedia, "The Bosnian War, sometimes referred to as the War in Bosnia and Herzegovina and the Bosnian Civil War,[a] was an international armed conflict that took place in Bosnia and Herzegovina between 1 March 1992 and 14 December 1995."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bosnian_War
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kosovo_War
#207 Posted by Wolfgang Achtner, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 08:04 PM
Can someone set up some crowd- sourced funding for longer form entries to be posted here or on a blog?
I'm sure we could get many more than 50 people paying $20 each...
#208 Posted by S Graham, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 09:02 PM
Dear Francesca Borri,
I am posting this in English (my native) and Google-translated Italian. Please forgive the ensuing deformities. Yours is a beautiful piece: nuanced, complex, empathetic. Please ignore all those who've posted in the negative. They've become bogged down in minutea or completely missed the point. I encourage you to take heart. At my reckoning, excluding a brief period for your words to find purchase in the greased-glass wall that is the internet and waiting for people to wake up, the longest gap between comments has been 12 minutes. That's amazing. Take heart. Even the morons prove your work has struck a chord.
I wish you peace and strength, hope and inspiration. And I will add my voice to the growing contingency: may you do all of this in a place with less bullets and more antibiotics.
Thank You,
jen carter
---------
Cara Francesca Borri,
Sto inviando questo in inglese (mia madre) e Google-tradotto italiano. Si prega di perdonare le deformità conseguenti. Il vostro è un bel pezzo: sfumata, complessa, empatico. Si prega di ignorare tutti quelli che hanno postato in senso negativo. Sono diventati impantanati in minutea o completamente perso il punto. Vi incoraggio a prendere il cuore. Alla mia resa dei conti, escluso un breve periodo per le vostre parole di trovare acquisto nel muro unta di vetro che è internet e in attesa di persone a svegliarsi, il gap più lungo tra i commenti è stato 12 minuti. Questo è incredibile. Prendere il cuore. Anche gli idioti dimostrare il tuo lavoro sia colpito una corda.
Vi auguro la pace e la forza, la speranza e l'ispirazione. E vorrei aggiungere la mia voce alla contingenza crescente: si può fare tutto questo in un posto con meno pallottole e di più antibiotici.
Grazie,
jen Carter
#209 Posted by jen carter, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 11:25 PM
Great piece Francesca, love the way you spot the frustation and the wildness of you life as Freelancer. The ugly truth of what is happening in the war zones has to be reported with the same simplicity you have showed us to better reach simple men and women as we are. Go for it, do your job and be safe. I am proud of you.
@mommo mimmo: you're good man, you know who Hemingway is. Did you watch the movie?
#210 Posted by Marcello, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 11:33 PM
I find this journalist to be brave and inspiring. Even if it was her choice to work $70 a day, she is sticking to her principles--something that's not easy to do as journalist these days. I've also found that freelancers are doing some of the best work out there --the freedom they have is precious commodity in a world where large scale media organizations have avoided putting the resources into stories or if they do, it serves a purpose that isn't always aligned with the true public interest. I hope freelancers can band together and start more non-profit journalism organizations.
#211 Posted by meredith, CJR on Fri 12 Jul 2013 at 11:51 PM
As an American I am embarrassed by my well-meaning yet woefully ignorant countrymen... but that's still not as bad as the UN officials who only deal with "childhood"?
If so many journalists are already there, competing for the stories, then what difference are you making by piling in with them and trying to sell the same bloody thriller pieces? I think this piece, the one you're not getting paid for, is the most important, and at this point, I would agree with your editor; who cares if you're in Syria? You've been there, you've seen it, now go home, take a bubble bath and write what you really have to say. You might not get $70 for it but at least you'll be safe.
I think a very significant part of your story is that even amongst the few outsiders there, people who under mortar fire you would expect to drop their differences and band together, are still participating in petty backstabbing (that might actually get you killed) and sexism. What do you think it is about the situation you're all in that allows people to still think that way? Is it because the war is petty? Is it because you all, in an effort to make a positive difference, are the victims of profiteering and can only take out your frustrations on each other? How, in the face of death and disaster, are journalists still jockeying for position like high school students?
#212 Posted by Mercury, CJR on Sat 13 Jul 2013 at 02:45 AM
More power to you. Hopefully, you will write a book about your years in Syria. At least, then we will know the complete truth.
Thank you for this article.
#213 Posted by Saburi Pandit, CJR on Sat 13 Jul 2013 at 02:57 AM
A tragic condemnation of the life of the freelancer ..and yet still you continue. Why? Because you are doing what your conscience dictates and your personal strength of character clearly will not and cannot let you do otherwise.
Editors fail you, readers fail you, colleagues fail you ..but, despite it all, you do not fail yourself - and, in the final reckoning, that is what really matters most
Brilliant work from a fabulous example of a how good a human being can be
#214 Posted by Ivor Harper, CJR on Sat 13 Jul 2013 at 11:38 AM
Thank you for this brave, difficult article. Your writing is excellent, the examples are powerful and the closing was a strong, unexpected yet heartfelt kick in the teeth. Thank you again for your bravery and honesty.
#215 Posted by T. McGrath, CJR on Sat 13 Jul 2013 at 01:26 PM
Thank you for your service. Your writing style is alive and real. I felt like i was living your experience. Your are indeed a very brave writer. My hat's off to you for your drive to live in the realities of life.
#216 Posted by Anonymous, CJR on Sat 13 Jul 2013 at 02:18 PM
A fine piece that I appreciate, but it also sounds as if you're loosing the power of your voice by staying with one conflict for too long. Be well.
#217 Posted by Andrew J, CJR on Sat 13 Jul 2013 at 10:54 PM
@marcello: ma vaffanculo!
#218 Posted by mimmo mommo, CJR on Sun 14 Jul 2013 at 03:28 AM
A great piece of writing-appaling to see how only blood and sensation gets our attention. Your last sentences hit me to the bone.
#219 Posted by Barbara, CJR on Sun 14 Jul 2013 at 04:12 AM
Dea Francesca
You are not a journalist. You are a human rights activis doing your job by another means. This is the reason why you don`t understand the newsroom priorities. Neither the less money you ask the less respected you are. Working almost for free doesn`t make you a good journalist. You are brave and passionate with your goal. But try to wonder why are you doing this. Because your journalistic vocation? I don't think so.
#220 Posted by George, CJR on Sun 14 Jul 2013 at 04:47 AM
Dea Francesca
You are not a journalist. You are a human rights activist doing your job by another means. This is the reason why you don`t understand the newsroom's priorities. Neither the less money you ask the less respected you are. Working almost for free doesn`t make you a good journalist. You are brave and passionate with your goal. But try to wonder why are you doing this. Because your journalistic vocation? I don't think so.
#221 Posted by George, CJR on Sun 14 Jul 2013 at 04:53 AM
Brilliant article. A genuine journalist's story, and a great article. Thanks Francesca for your valor and human heart.
Unfortunately the current News Service buy and sell controversy, bloody stories, body count, disasters, revolutions and other catastrophes on Earth. Editors want what it sells .
Good luck, do what you love, it's the best part of your work.
#222 Posted by Marivel Guzman, CJR on Sun 14 Jul 2013 at 06:53 AM
Kudos,
It's no secret that journalism in today's world is heavily controlled by corporations and governments. I had become quite cynical and pessimistic about anything I read/watched/heard in mainstream media but reading your piece has been not only refreshing but inspiring.
However, I am afraid that you don't quite understand the concept of war. I won't get into the details but I can assure you, your life isn't worth it!!
#223 Posted by Mugeni Mukanga, CJR on Sun 14 Jul 2013 at 07:50 AM
Wolfgang:
I would think that an "educator" such as yourself who has mastered Wikipedia as you have -- if he were actually interested in the answers to the questions he asks -- might know how to use Google, especially as you've cut-and-pasted the very sources you could use to find out -- namely that Ms. Borri has published two books. I can use Google, and found the titles easily enough. The WorldCat library website even helpfully provides subject lines, so I'll give you a head start "Non aprire mai" (2008).
Since you live in Rome -- or so you say -- it should be simplicity itself to find the book and search it for the answer you're supposed to be so interested in. We eagerly await your report.
#224 Posted by Calton, CJR on Sun 14 Jul 2013 at 08:27 AM
A few questions raised by an Italian freelance in Aleppo:
"My youth, for what it’s worth, vanished when bits of brain splattered on me in Bosnia, when I was 23." What war was in Bosnia in 2004???
"You get an exclusive story, like the one I wrote last September on Aleppo’s old city [...] I was the first foreign reporter to enter": Cristiano Tinazzi says he entered the city on the 10th of August and she wasn't there.
"I contracted typhoid fever and was shot in the knee": she was shot in the knee by an AK47 7.62 bullet? And she can still walk?
here the link to the original article:
http://ildottorgonzo.wordpress.com/2013/07/14/cara-francesca/
#225 Posted by Cesare, CJR on Sun 14 Jul 2013 at 08:58 AM
If the truth is going to be told like this, how many of us will stop to listen. We see the emotions, the characters, the facts in the story but do we get the message? Nice piece, a revolutionary journalist I must add.
#226 Posted by kamara Bature, CJR on Sun 14 Jul 2013 at 11:13 AM
Thank you for the words.
Keep your head down.
That is all.
#227 Posted by Ben Fassett, CJR on Mon 15 Jul 2013 at 12:38 AM
I have been an ecopeace activist since 1991 and I have been active (for free) against the Western wars (or western-baked wars): Iraq, Libya, Jugoslavia, Afghanistan, and Syria. I went to those war-thorne areas with peace groups or as an investigator against the war lies, not as a war correspondant. In Iraq like in Libya, I saw many war journalists and they were well paid, by Italian or foreign media. it depends on the periods or on the "concurrence", I guess.
I write as a journalist in my normal life but concerning the wars I do everything it for free, as an activist, squeezing the expenses (even in Syria, it is possible to survive with a very small amount...but the war correspondants embedded with the "rebels", I guess, must pay them, that is why for them it is costly).
#228 Posted by marinella correggia, CJR on Mon 15 Jul 2013 at 04:48 AM
Wonderful article, thanks so much for having the courage to write it! - Not only is it dangerous to report from the heart of a war - but it is also hazardous to raise the questions you ask about the moral of the editor and the media in general, including the work conditions of (freelance) journalists..! Do take care out there and please continue your coverage of both scenes – the one of the ongoing conflicts and the issue of how the news content is produced!
#229 Posted by Ulla Hauer, CJR on Mon 15 Jul 2013 at 05:50 AM
Damn, so true...
#230 Posted by Silky, CJR on Mon 15 Jul 2013 at 05:56 AM
Sorry to say that, Francesca, but you are the master of your own demise. And you even acknowledged that in the article. You are there on your own volition, risking your life for 70 bucks a piece. For what? For the urge to "make people understand reality"? To me, that just sounds pretty presumptuous and hypocrite. The truth is you are there for yourself, to justify all you have been and have done up to this point. And that the only reality you can hope to convey is the one you perceive through your own, personal set of values and ideological convictions. I appreciate the "introspective" parts of this article, as they speak about the limits and oddity shared by all human beings. A pity all that is ruined by a naive form of social complaint that has no actual reason to be.
#231 Posted by Claudio, CJR on Mon 15 Jul 2013 at 06:48 AM
Impressive how superficial are the readers. looks like most of them do not notice the fake things written here even if they are remarked in some comments:
-Francesca lies or on her age on on that sentence :"My youth, for what it’s worth, vanished when bits of brain splattered on me in Bosnia, when I was 23."
-Francesca was not the first to enter the "old city".
-Francesca could not be shot in a knee in syria if she went on staying there.
-Francesca is not a professional journalist.
Dear Francesca, I don't know why you are spreding this piece in the net... if your goal was to have some popularity on social networks ok maybe you are getting some but if your goal was to gain some respect from editors and colleagues you are for sure getting the opposite result.
I have a lot of respect for activists who are spending their money an time to make the world aware of what is happening in certain areas but those people do post their reports in peacereporters, in blogs, in social networks ecc... for free, not on regolar press changing them for 70 dollars. Risking your life in Syria for writing pieces to please the press but accepting to do it more than for free (if you ask just 70$ but pay all the expences it means you are there not only for free but spending a lot of your money) means that you are not an activist nor a journalist. So... why are you in Syria? If it was for the Syrians you wuold never accept to write to please the media and if it was because it's your profession you wuold never accept doing it for free...
Sorry to say that but really I do not understand the meaning of this piece!
#232 Posted by CP, CJR on Mon 15 Jul 2013 at 07:22 AM
Thank you Francesca for this piece about WOMEN Freelancers second-class journalists. I hope that it will be a contribution for change in the way of thninking in media
#233 Posted by Xavier Cazard, CJR on Mon 15 Jul 2013 at 07:45 AM
Wants to send you that hug, albeit late.
I knew a man who worked for Doctors without Borders in the former Yugoslav region. Whenever he was in Amsterdam, he tried to help some of the addicted girls who were working behind Central Station. He ended up joining them as a drug addict.
#234 Posted by Petra van Goor, CJR on Mon 15 Jul 2013 at 08:46 AM
I respect what you have to say and what you're trying to do. You're fantastic and an inspiration, and it's because people like you exist - brave, principled people who suffer for what they believe in even though they don't have to - that I still believe there's some good in this world. I know it's easy for me to say, I don't know you, but don't regret what you've done. You're a better person than most of us will ever be.
#235 Posted by Tabitha, CJR on Mon 15 Jul 2013 at 06:01 PM
Please do not give up. Reading your article, you made me proud that there women out there at the frontiers. You made me weep for the humanitarian disaster you are witnessing every day. You made me angry because the rest of the world cannot seem to decide what to do to stop the bloodshed. I have been reading a lot on Syria these days and I admit that your insight was the best I came across yet: it is a bloody chaos that only gets worse as time goes by because, simply put, blood will demand blood. There is no magical way to make the violence be forgotten, the wounded grow back limbs, the missing to be found and their families find piece. The violence creates a vicious circle of violence and goes on and on and on...
Stay as safe as you can and write another book on what YOU want to write about concerning Syria. I will look up your books, you write beuatifully! And if you ever find yourself in Cyprus please look me up. xefi@cyprusgreens.org
#236 Posted by Efi Xanthou,Cyprus, CJR on Tue 16 Jul 2013 at 05:00 AM
Francesca, you are a tough woman. I did not know you, now I do and have lots of respect for you. What you said is EXACTLY what I feel about some desk-only journalists who are in charge in main dailies/agencies/TVs.
Yours is life. The rest is bullshit.
Supporting you, Carlo
#237 Posted by curlywurly, CJR on Tue 16 Jul 2013 at 06:07 AM
Thanks for not being afraid to be fully honest with us. Stay safe!
#238 Posted by Natalya, CJR on Tue 16 Jul 2013 at 07:05 PM
As always this courageous journalist writes from the heart. The comments those comfortable in their own space make and judgments they throw, show that all Francesca describes has bled from these insensitive, ignorants any vestige of empathy, comprehension and intelligence.
Thank God for Journalism with a Heart, Soul and Truth intact. Bless you and your work from one, a photojournalist who has seen and experienced similar.
#239 Posted by Jonathan, CJR on Wed 17 Jul 2013 at 05:34 AM
>I wouldn't classify you as a journalist. I'd call you a Palestinian propagandist and terrorist enabler.
I double that.
#240 Posted by Anonymous, CJR on Wed 17 Jul 2013 at 10:10 AM
Wow, Francesca I truly admire your work and coming from a Middle Eastern country, I can understand what you are feeling and saying under my skin. All I can say is to repeat your own words and try to remember them myself as well: "because really the only story to tell in war is how to live without fear. It all could be over in an instant. If I knew that, then I wouldn’t have been so afraid to love, to dare, in my life; instead of being here, now, hugging myself in this dark, rancid corner, desperately regretting all I didn’t do, all I didn’t say. You who tomorrow are still alive, what are you waiting for? Why don’t you love enough? You who have everything, why you are so afraid?"
Keep it up andbe safe....
#241 Posted by Bebe, CJR on Wed 17 Jul 2013 at 10:36 AM
Francesca, you have brought me to tears with your candour and bravery. You raise the stakes on what it means to be a good human being today. Thank you for what you have made us see, that we wouldn't have seen without you.
Danijela
#242 Posted by Danijela Kambaskovic-Sawers, CJR on Thu 18 Jul 2013 at 01:59 AM
Stunning reporting. Stunning writing.
But, get out. Get out of Syria. Get out of journalism, if need be. You've learned all you have to learn.
#243 Posted by dave, CJR on Thu 18 Jul 2013 at 04:30 AM
Cara Francesca, grazie e complimenti per il coraggio e la costanza. Tieni duro ancora un po', ma poi torna a casa: ti vogliamo sana e distesa. Vedi tu cosa vuoi e puoi fare. Intanto: un abbraccio.
#244 Posted by Andrea Malaguti, CJR on Thu 18 Jul 2013 at 12:23 PM
Francesca, you are an amazing person and I thank you for sharing these important thoughts. Best of luck.
#245 Posted by Pablo, CJR on Thu 18 Jul 2013 at 12:39 PM
money money money... It is not about Francesca, it is about her editor, her newspaper, mass media and the driving forces of capitalism in general
#246 Posted by Rem, CJR on Fri 19 Jul 2013 at 01:46 AM
I couldn't take it anymore when I read more comments like "Nobody is forcing you to do the job for a pittance". To all of you, sitting comfortably, while reading this:
We journalists do what we do, as freelancers, because deep in our hearts, we want to believe that our work matters. That you, the reader, will use your comfort and power thereof to protest when wars are being funded, rather than admonish us. We are fucking dreamers. We at least got that courage.
I am just so angry reading those comments. Francesca, fellow freelance writer (and sufferer).... I really dunno what more to say after you have said it all.
#247 Posted by Priyanka Borpujari, CJR on Sat 20 Jul 2013 at 08:54 AM
Francesca,
I hope you read this? I'm really impressed by this piece. And I can't help but think 'I really hope that after these insights she got the hell out of there!' I can understand your need to 'tell the world' about Syria, about war, about suffering and pain. And I think not all readers will forget where Damascus or Aleppo etc. are. But you're right no-one really understand what's going on. And the question is: so you? There's great suffering in the world, and there is love. Why don't you chose love instead? Write something about love! And your readers will remember that it was you who reminded them what is really important! We cannot overcome suffering by knowing about it... we need more people who love!
With love Nina
#248 Posted by Nina, CJR on Sat 20 Jul 2013 at 05:36 PM
Francesca,
I just want to thank you for what you are doing and wish you happiness and health. If you can take a break to rest and recharge, I will be greatfull if you will agree to give a few presentation to tell your side while you are staying here.
Best Regards
#249 Posted by Rami, CJR on Sun 21 Jul 2013 at 02:53 PM
Thanks for shedding light on the situation of Italian freelancers. What I appreciated is the fact that you could open a public debate on journalism and I really hope that you and your colleagues will fight together to improve the conditions of freelancers in Italy. What you are saying, of freelancers who cannot sign articles with their names, is a sad and well-known reality here.
On the other hand, I totally agree on what Andrea Glioti wrote. First of all, the added value of a journalist covering a specific context is made by his/her experience of this place and by the knowledge of its language. This make him/her also more independent and able to read beyond lines. Then, as you write stories from the front line for 70$, you are accepting to be paid this fee; you write the “bang-bang” stories editors asked you and therefore you are part of the system that you criticize. Maybe editors want just the blood but who told you that readers are not interested about other issues, like how civilian are coping with food shortage and high prices or how local peaceful activists are struggling for a revolution of dignity against any sort of extremism? Don’t think readers are all a bunch of ignorant people not knowing where Syria is and thinking Syrians are “barbarians” and extremists. Unfortunately, these clichés are promoted by journalists and editors with no previous or very little knowledge about Syria, thinking that any war is like the other and Muslims are the same in Chechnya, Afghanistan, Syria or Morocco. As you feel different from them and you criticize this kind of works and the fact that editors don’t want you to write analysis, then do something! Create your own blog/website where you could finally write what you want and be finally “free”. Maybe you could do it for free but at the end it could be better that writing cheap blood stories you are not interested in! Become an expert of Syria if you want and if you can: write your analysis, essays, and books. In Italy there are many young authors who studied Middle Eastern studies, who know Arabic and who write about Syria giving a valuable contribution to understand what’s going on there (Lorenzo Trombetta with sirialibano.com for example). Nevertheless, they are less famous than others because they don’t write from the front line and prefer to give voice to the Syrians then tell about themselves. In Italy there are also many activists: Italians (ex. Father Paolo dall’Oglio), Syrians (ex. Eva Ziedan), Italo-Syrians (ex. Shady Hamadi). They know quite well the situation in Syria and the majority of them are in contact with activists IN Syria and they inform readers and people through Internet, meetings and also public demonstrations. Off course this doesn’t mean that ALL Italians are perfectly aware of what’s going on in Syria, but these people are struggling for this. Humbly.
So please, instead of complaining about a situation you chose, try to react with concrete actions and above all, don’t generalize and judge the others (which others??) because you don’t know them. Don’t think you are a hero because you went to Syria and OTHERS stay at home because “they have everything”. At least you can choose where to go: many Syrians can’t!
Good luck.
#250 Posted by Sara, CJR on Mon 22 Jul 2013 at 11:25 AM
First of all, thank you for being there and recording what's happening. I am sure you are at least depressed, as who wouldn't be but you need to find a way to leave. Your life is still ahead of you. There's still time for some semblance of a normal life. Your life matters too. Leave that place and return to the rest of us.
#251 Posted by Jo, CJR on Sat 27 Jul 2013 at 02:57 PM
Thank you Francesca for sharing this poignant article. It is certainly your choice to cover wars around the world, but we should be grateful to journalists like you that keep us informed and help us to understand.
Concerning your free lance activity, it is the confirmation of the insecurity so typical in the italian job market, especially for young people. It is bleak and it sounds an enormous wastage of energy and motivation, it is unacceptable, but the italians seem resigned. This is terrible for the future of the country.
Cynical editors are only exploiting the situation, as many other managers in different sectors. I hope they feel shame reading your article.
Thank you also for helping us to think about our comfortable lives, and the importance of living every moment as if it was the last one.
#252 Posted by Daniel, CJR on Sun 28 Jul 2013 at 07:12 AM
Amazing article! It has been a long time since I last read such a well written article. Keep it up!
#253 Posted by Marc, CJR on Mon 29 Jul 2013 at 02:50 PM
Yes, great article. Somebody had to say it! If we want up-to-date, well-researched journalism we need to pay for it. Journalism in conflict situations fulfills an important complementary role to monitoring of compliance with international humanitarian law, even if it is not the sole purpose of a war correspondent.
It has become increasingly acceptable to hire qualified people on freelance basis, in temporary arrangements, as interns or volunteers for as long as possible - this is specifically true for jobs with a relation to human rights protection. Isn't that ironic?
Thank you for your work in Syria and for doing it in accordance with professional standards. If the Italian media think that it is important for them to have Syria covered, they should pay for the result they wish to have and secure their journalists to the extend that enables them to do their work. The argument that it is your choice to be there is misplaced in this context. Of course, we all make our own choiced and have to live with the consequences but it does not matter who chooses this job - it should not exist under these conditions. Stay safe.
#254 Posted by Kristina, CJR on Thu 1 Aug 2013 at 06:23 AM