Yesterday, columnist Richard Cohen wrote a piece for the Washington Post entitled “Digital Lynch Mob,” about the venomous response he has received from readers after an earlier column criticizing comedian Stephen Colbert’s performance at the White House correspondents’ dinner.
“Kapow!” writes Cohen. “Within a day, I got more than 2,000 e-mails. A day later, I got 1,000 more. … The Colbert messages began with Patrick Manley (‘You wouldn’t know funny if it slapped you in the face’) and ended with Ron (‘Colbert ROCKS, you MURDER’) who was so proud of his thought that he copied countless others. Ron, you’re a genius.”
“The e-mails pulse in my queue, emanating raw hatred,” adds Cohen. “This spells trouble — not for Bush or, in 2008, the next GOP presidential candidate, but for Democrats. The anger festering on the Democratic left will be taken out on the Democratic middle. (Watch out, Hillary!) I have seen this anger before — back in the Vietnam War era. That’s when the antiwar wing of the Democratic Party helped elect Richard Nixon. In this way, they managed to prolong the very war they so hated.”
“The hatred,” writes Cohen, “is back.”
To which bloggers have since responded en masse. Some sized up Cohen’s complaints and essentially noted: liberal hatred? Digital lynch mob? No kidding.
The headline from Michelle Malkin: “Welcome to Our World.”
“Newsflash, Richard: They’re still throwing rocks,” writes Malkin. “And hurling paint. And Molotov cocktails. And lucky for you, they save their worst invective not for squishy elite liberals, but for minority conservatives.”
“Yes, well, he ought to try posting something not-left-of-center over at the Huffington Post — because, by comparison, his email sounds downright friendly,” writes Carol Platt Liebau. “Sounds to me like the wrong-but-rational left is starting to become a wee bit afraid of the beast that’s been created — that is, the far-left Netizens.”
“The American left is where the American far right was in the 1950s — besotted with anger, boiling in conspiracy theories,” writes Austin Bay. “There is a difference, however. ‘Opinion leaders’ like Cohen have let the hard left take a large bite out of their own liberal ‘mainstream.’ Cohen has just now discovered it, because his email box got jammed with garbage. It is a step toward enlightenment, however hesitant a step.
“But read Cohen’s entire essay for yourself,” adds Bay. “Don’t snicker too harshly.”
But apparently much of the blogosphere didn’t get the don’t-snicker-too-harshly memo.
“Here’s my deep analysis about Cohen: GOTCHA!!!!,” writes Echidne of the Snakes. “Never show that you bleed, Richard. Never reveal the soft white underbelly to the ravening hordes of pulsing rocks of hate. I thought all the tough guy journalists and politicos know this stuff.”
“Poor Richard Cohen,” writes You Are Dumb. “He wrote a very stupid article about how Colbert wasn’t funny. For the Washington Post, by the way — widely known as the nation’s premier comedy experts. Anyway, the article got passed around the Net, and Cohen got a few thousand nasty e-mails about it. Cue collective shock and horror, I know. It’s only the way the Internet has worked since the day Al Gore thought it up. …
“If you’re that bothered by random strangers despising your opinion, quit writing for a newspaper and go to work someplace safer and less bruising,” adds You Are Dumb. “Something in, say, marshmallow tensile strength quality control. Clock in at 8, gently squeeze marshmallows for eight hours, and go home, never once fearing that someone on the Internet will write you a nastygram.”

Tempest in a Tea Pot
You certainly have slanted the sample of blogs to make it look like there might be something to Cohen's lament. Why not point that poor ultra-elite Cohen is upset that people would send anonymous emails but that he is neither the center of the Universe or a the stand in for the Mainstream Democratic party his assertion seems to assume. Pardon me if I dont accept Michelle Malkin as a reliable authority on liberals given her career choice to depict virtually anything she doesnt like as unhinged and manic. She even wrote her own book on the alleged problem. As for angry and unhinged you should try reading the comments to sites like right wing sites like Malkin's.
"The e-mails pulse in my queue, emanating raw hatred," adds Cohen.
What standard is Cohen using to make this claim? No one knows, since he himself says he only read a smattering of the emails he received but apparently he has some special pyschic power.
Since when did the sending of anonymous emails critical of a pompous self-important commentator become the barrometer for poplitical reality?
Your sample of blog commentary is heavy from the right wing and light from the left. The first one is certain a liberal site, but the link is clearly satirical. I have never heard of "You are dumb" although that might just be me, but the title is interesting and the post opens with a criticism of the "Lefty Blogosphere".
Here are some of the comments you overlook that dont fit your theme quite as well that only took a couple minutes to find.
Richard Cohen got 2,000 mean e-mails and this signals the end of the Democratic party. I'll leave you to figure out why that should follow. In case Cohen hasn't noticed nobody on the fucking planet likes squishy faux liberal courtiers. There's no political downside to hating Richard Cohen. http://digbysblog.blogspot.com/2006_05_01_digbysblog_archive.html#114716173036525261http://daoureport.salon.com/synopsis.aspx?synopsisId=191cf555-60ce-453c-a573-77f73f56e580#
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2006/5/9/10610/03617
http://digbysblog.blogspot.com/2006_05_01_digbysblog_archive.html#114721375335953160
http://www.tinyrevolution.com/mt/archives/000916.html
http://atrios.blogspot.com/2006_05_07_atrios_archive.html#114719309790006056
http://atrios.blogspot.com/2006_05_07_atrios_archive.html#114719142414180702
Posted by Catch22 on Wed 10 May 2006 at 01:52 PM
TO CATCH22, RE: BLOG PICKING
It ain't you. Take comfort in the spectrum analysis I did Felix’s May 8 article,“Kos Pummels Hillary; Left & Right Pummel Kos” which you can here on site.
When I saw your concern, I ran a CJR Daily pattern analysis and discovered on October 5, 2005: “From the Left, From the Right, Bloggers Whack Bush Around” by Felix Gillette.
There you’ll find cited one Left site (Red Dog Bites) balanced by bloggers David Frum, Andrew Sullivan, and the Industrial Blog. This is from the latter: “To many on the Left, we on the Right are stupid, we are dupes, we are in denial, we refuse to think, we have severe psychological disturbances, we're desperate to prop up a worldview with fantasies, and we're uneducated. …”
Tally-wise on "Left-Right Wack Bush" (not counting the dormant entertainment blog “Into Your Tent I Will Silently Creep”) our final score is Left 1, Right 3. – closer than this week’s Left-Right Blog game which is Left 0 , Right 3 (maybe 4).
Seems like we might need more competitive match-ups. What do you think? Maybe Don King is available.
Posted by CliffsVoice on Wed 10 May 2006 at 05:21 PM