Several weeks ago, New York Times reporter Michael S. Schmidt, a foreign correspondent in the newspaper’s Baghdad bureau, went looking for US military trailers in a local junkyard. Schmidt was trying to find a new way to tell the story of American withdrawal from Iraq—and he found one when he stumbled upon a binder of classified military documents that included testimony from Marines about the 2005 Haditha massacre, an episode in which American Marines killed 26 Iraqi civilians. Schmidt told the incredible story behind the story at the Times’s At War blog. CJR caught up with him last week to learn a little bit more about his junkyard scoop.
How long have you been in Iraq?
I started coming to Iraq with the Times in January. Before that I was a sports reporter.
Why did you go looking for these trailers? What did you expect to find?
We were trying to find a different way to tell the story of American withdrawal by seeing what stuff had turned up from American bases in Iraq and what kind of physical legacy the military left behind.
We just knew there were trailers from American bases, that they were at this junkyard and a guy was trying to sell them.
How did this lead to the documents?
We went out to find the trailers at this junkyard and we couldn’t find it. We got really lost and I was basically saying ‘Let’s turn back.’ My security team said no. The next thing I know they’ve figured it out and we’re there.
When we got to the junkyard, there was an Iraqi man who let us in and walked us through the trailers—there was interesting stuff, but nothing incredibly revealing about the war. On the way out, I was walking past this fire pit that had trash around it and I saw a piece of paper that said “testimony” on it and I thought, ‘Woah, what is this?’
I picked it up and started going through all this trash. I found a binder with lots of pages in it and classified maps from the military. The guy let us take them and he told us he’d been burning dozens and dozens of these binders over the past few weeks to make his masgouf, which is this Iraqi delicacy, smoked carp.
Why was the attendant burning the documents? Did he have orders to do so?
The guy was just a junkyard attendant. He didn’t have orders to do that at all. The military didn’t know the documents were there, he had just figured out these were documents from the Americans and the best thing to do would be to burn them. At same time he let me take the documents.
I just think that he was concerned about being identified, because he thought the Americans would come after him if they knew he had given us this.
What were you thinking at the time?
It was really weird. We put the documents in the trunk and I was just trying to think what could be in there. I know the military creates a lot of paperwork, so I thought it was likely just bureaucratic stuff. But then again, who knows?
We came back to the office and spread it out on the table and started going through it with my colleagues here and realized it was stuff about Haditha. It was just weird, shocking, that of all the things that you could find in the trash in a junkyard in Baghdad, it would be classified military documents about this incident in which all these civilians were killed by Marines.
What about the documents was most striking to you?
The candor of the Marines in describing the atmosphere in Anbar province at the height of the insurgency was particularly revealing—hearing it from them, in their own words, and knowing that they thought what they were saying was confidential makes their candor particularly interesting.
What is new about these documents? What do they add to what we already knew about Haditha?