Aside from the general advice of networking and putting yourself out there, how do I break into freelancing? What makes a good query letter? Can you really still make a living off freelancing, and how? —Melissa
Quick! Off the top of your head, name five editors you know will recognize your name and open your pitch emails. If you can’t, it’s too soon to go full-time freelance. Every profession is about connections, and journalism is no exception. And those connections are the lifeblood of a freelancer. How do you get editors to know your name? Have friends introduce you to them via email. (Yeah, “networking.” Sorry.) Write regularly on your personal site and on sites that don’t pay you, and then disseminate those links as widely as you can. Cold pitching can work, too, but it’s tougher.
A good query email is one that’s sent directly to the assigning editor for the specific section you’re pitching. The email features a compelling subject line (think of it as a proto-headline) and a tight paragraph explaining the piece you want to write, why it’s timely, and why this outlet is the perfect place to publish it. A second short paragraph in the email explains who you are and why you’re the best writer for the job. It also includes a link to your personal site, which has an easily navigable archive of your work. It ends with a note about when you’ll be following up. Depending on how timely the piece is, that follow-up date can be anywhere from 24 hours to several weeks away. Basically, it’s just to help you set a timeline and enable you to pitch the piece elsewhere before the time hook expires, rather than twiddling your thumbs for weeks waiting for a reply that may never come.
I’m in the midst of my own freelance experiment. Admittedly, I started with the advantage of several years of experience as an editor, so I know a lot of the people to whom I’m pitching, and I know how editors think. I’ve made some freelance rules for myself: 1) Set up a few recurring gigs (like this column) to add structure to my week and my finances. 2) Send at least two additional pitches per week. 3) Meticulously track each assignment through six stages: pitched, assigned, published, promoted, invoiced, paid. The lag time between publication and payment is usually significant. So prepare to harass your employers to cut the check.

As for whether you can make a living… I know some writers and editors who certainly do. Most make it work by supplementing their writing assignments with speaking gigs, fellowships, or consulting work. It’s not easy. Before you make the freelance leap, make sure you have a plush financial cushion.
What are the ethics involved if the editor of a local magazine wants to pitch to a national publication? I have stories that I’ve written that would work well for a wider, national audience. I wouldn’t pitch exactly the same story, of course, but I would want to pitch a different angle with the same subject. Okay or not? —Brandon
Give it a shot. You should try to get as much mileage as possible out of every story—stopping short of self-plagiarism, of course. (More about that in a minute.) Be sure to disclose that you’ve already written about the subject for a local publication. My only note of caution is that the bar might be higher than you think when it comes to convincing an editor that your local idea is nationally relevant.

In other words, do your homework before you start pitching.
Like every ascending writer these days, I’m terrified of ending up like Jonah Lehrer by accidentally using previously published quotes and similar background info in multiple stories. Any advice? —Melody Wilson
- 1
- 2
The only place you should ever write for free is your own site, never for anyone else.
I am extremely disappointed that CJR would promote such an idea, and while Ms. Friedman is a fine journalist, I am equally disappointed that CJR has someone in the "midst of her own freelance experiment" offering advice to freelancers. No veteran freelancer would ever tell someone to write for free.
Freelancing is not a game. It's a business. It should be treated as such, which means getting paid for your work, not giving it away.
#1 Posted by Jen A. Miller, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 10:56 AM
Jen, I'd have to respectfully disagree. Getting into freelancing can be tough, especially if you're brand new and don't have a lot of contacts. Sometimes writing a few pieces pro bono is the way to get your name out there. Obviously, it would be ideal to always be paid, but Friedman states that "Before you make the freelance leap, make sure you have a plush financial cushion." Having other ways to make money when starting out is important. I agree with you in that freelancing should be treated as a business...but many businesses also start out slow, by giving products away for free and promoting with no financial gain right out of the gate.
#2 Posted by Gina Goodman (@CisionNavigator), CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 11:11 AM
Gina, and I respectfully disagree with you.
You can write on your own site; you can wow an editor with a solid pitch. But a freelancer should never give away work for free. It devalues what that freelancer does. It devalues what we all do.
I've been doing this for 10 years, and some outlets still have the expectation that I will work for them for free, or for "exposure." Exposure doesn't pay my mortgage or buy groceries.
I stopped taking no and low paying work a long time ago. My bottom line has only improved. The more that freelancers at any level keep giving away work for free or nothing, the worse off we all are. It's time to stop perpetuating the free idea, and get paid what we deserve for our work.
#3 Posted by Jen A. Miller, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 11:19 AM
*Edit: Should say I stopped taking "no paying work." I never wrote for free.
#4 Posted by Jen A. Miller, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 11:21 AM
Gina, there is no reason. Zero. Why any writer or freelance professional of any kind should do work for free solely to get their name out there. Any veteran, successful freelancer will back that statement up. Shame on CJR for promoting this practice. I agree with Ms. Miller, the author maybe a fine journalist but she is admittedly not yet an expert on freelancing. Surely CJR could have found someone with more experience to write this post.
#5 Posted by Colin Lenton, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 11:21 AM
Jennifer is right on. When we undersell ourselves, the marketplace does, too. I've been a freelancer for 12 years, and with the exception of my own blog (which promotes my book and my other work) and carefully selected volunteer work, I have never, ever worked for free. You don't need to, and you should have to.
Freelancing is as much about running a business as it is about writing. I meet new freelancers frequently, and I can spot the ones who will succeed in heartbeat. They have solid writing/reporting skills, and they know how to run a business. They recognize that they are providing a service that is so valuable, they deserve to be paid for it. Too bad CJR is promoting this really terrible advice.
#6 Posted by Laura Laing, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 11:46 AM
Aside from writing for your own website or blog, there's one other situation where I can see some value in writing for free, and that is writing guest posts on popular blogs or someplace like HuffPost to promote a book or some other new venture. I run guest posts on my blog every week from journalists and authors who are doing just that.
Otherwise, there's no reason to write for free. Even if you're just starting out.
As Harlan Ellison says in this now widely circulated nterview: "Pay the writer."
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mj5IV23g-fE
#7 Posted by Michelle Rafter, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 12:21 PM
While I don't know Ann Friedman, I do know a LOT of extremely successful freelancers. Perhaps asking them to write a column on how to freelance would have been a wiser choice.
There is much flawed with this advice. First, as Jen Miller noted, that is no reason to write for free. Writing for free and sending out those links is basically going to get you nowhere. No editors worth their salt are impressed that you posted an item on your blog or wrote something for a content mill for $10.
Second, you don't need to know editors to be successful in freelancing. My best client at the moment is one I sent a letter of introduction to out of the blue. They alone give me enough work to constitute a full-time job, and I have several other clients - none of whom I knew before I sent them queries or LOIs, or met them at a conference.
Third, I know very few freelancers who rely on consulting, speaking gigs, etc., to supplement their income. There is plenty of freelance editing and writing work out there that pays a decent rate. It's all a matter of wanting to learn how to do this job right.
The successful freelancers who truly know the ropes and earn a respectable wage are really the ones who should be dispensing advice.
#8 Posted by Susan Ladika, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 01:00 PM
Another full-time freelancer chiming in to say what a huge mistake it is to write for free - for someone else. A couple people who've stated this here blog on their own sites, as do I. Building a self-publishing platform by writing your own content is a different ballgame, assuming you do it with a plan.
But if you're expecting to grow a business and be treated like a professional, putting your byline on sites known for profiting on unpaid content devalues you in the marketplace. Offering to work on spec for editors spells "amateur." More to the point, it's not necessary! Yes, have a financial cushion when you go out on your own. Better yet, have a few paid assignments under your belt and the kind of clips that say: "I work for pay and I'm worth it."
Please find freelance journalists who are beyond "experimenting" to hand out advice. Those of us still managing to thrive out here do not need any more help with the devaluation of our marketplace - and putting it under the CJR brand is particularly damaging.
#9 Posted by Cathleen McCarthy, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 01:14 PM
I find this whole article a little weird, frankly. "Can you make a living freelancing?" Of course! Many people do it, myself included. And, sorry CJR, you don't have to be a J-school grad or former editor to do it. I'm not.
Regarding writing for free, the answer is NO. For me, the only exception to this rule is when you're first starting out and you provide pro-bono content to a non-profit you support. Get some clips by writing for your local animal shelter or Alzheimer's association. That's just plain community service.
But do NOT write for free for any other outlets. Writing for "exposure" is one of the biggest scams perpetuated on new freelancers. Memorize this: Money flows TOWARD the writer. Tack that up on the wall over your monitor.
Frankly, I'm skeptical (as Jen said) of anyone giving advice who states she is "experimenting" with freelancing. In fact, that phrasing makes it sound like freelance writing is a dangerous, exotic activity only to be attempted by the very bold or very foolish. What rubbish! Want to be a freelance writer? Start typing.
#10 Posted by Elizabeth Hanes, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 01:15 PM
I am going to join the chorus of long-time,fulltime freelancers who say no, no, no on free writing. It's a bad trap, and if you think it's just a step on the ladder, you're mistaken -- very accomplished writers get asked ALL. THE. TIME to work for free/exposure/links. There's this idea that because what writers have to sell is a creative product, we just want to see it "out there," as though each piece we write is our child going off to kindergarten. Not so: I sell something very specific, and if I don't get paid for what I sell, I devalue the product and myself (not to mention my profession).
The writer here also talks about the importance of connections -- which is true to a point. She mentions starting her "freelance experiment" coming from years as an editor. I did it the same way -- I was a magazine editor for 16 years before going freelance, and of course I relied on my established connections. But I made more of them, and broke out of the idea that I could only pitch people I "knew." That said, the networking advice and the advice here on query crafting is solid.
Best starting out advice: Don't sell yourself short. And don't think of it as an experiment, or even an art. It's a business.
#11 Posted by Denise Schipani, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 01:27 PM
Freelancing is a business -- and like any business, you need experience before you can expect someone to hire you. For freelance writers, that means you need to write something that will be published by someone other than yourself. In the very beginning, that might be unpaid, just like an internship or apprenticeship in another field. Journalists need clips. Most reputable publications are not going to publish the work of someone who has zero previously-published pieces. Hence, many newbie journalists will need to write a few pieces for free to build up their portfolio. I did it, I'm sure Ann's done it, and every writer I know did it at the beginning of their career.
As for the advice that all it takes to be a freelance writer is to start typing, and that there are plenty of freelance writers who make excellent livings without side hustles, well... that sounds nice, but I don't know any of them who are my age (late 20s), single, living in big cities like NY or LA, and doing the kind of freelancing that Ann is talking about here (which I think is writing about ideas for widely-read newspapers, magazines and websites, and not writing copy for corporate clients). I know writers who live in dual-income households and make it work that way, but paying $1800 a month in rent and another $1200 a month in student loans, and another $2000 just for living expenses in a place like NY? No, not a lot of freelancers make that kind of cash on their own, writing for magazines or big-name websites.
I get the sense that Ann is talking about a particular type of freelancer, and a freelancer of a particular generation; the commenters are talking about a totally different freelance world.
From my own experience as someone who left a career as a lawyer to pursue full-time freelancing (again in the vein of "ideas"-writing, and not corporate copy): It is tough. It is attempted only by the very bold or the very foolish. It does require a financial cushion, and solid connections, and often multiple side projects to pay the bills. Ann's advice here is excellent. I could have used it in j-school.
#12 Posted by Jill Filipovic, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 01:41 PM
There is nothing wrong with choosing to write for free if you're a rookie who is looking to get clips from various outlets. Too bad and boo hoo if some of you more experienced freelancers do not agree or feel like it will hurt the industry. It's not of your business. You act like you're a mob or the presidents of some bullying union. Guess what? You're not. You're mainly people who couldn't get a real job so you are forced to beg for work on a daily basis.
A good number of people in various industries work for free when they are getting started: it's called unpaid internship. Sure, there are paid internships, too, and there might be some of you who refused unpaid internships. That's your choice.
Keep the "free" in freelance!
#13 Posted by Thomas K. Jacobs, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 01:47 PM
Thomas Jacobs, to say some of these commenters are "mainly people who couldn't get a real job" is utterly ridiculous. Let's google some of these commenters for a moment:
Jen Miller - regular clients NYTimes, Runner's World, Marketplace
Cathleen McCarthy - Country Living, Elle Decor, Four Seasons, Marie Claire, Town and Country
Denise Schipani - Redbook, Washington Post, Parents, Real Simple
Susan Ladika - Wall Street Journal, The San Francisco Chronicle, Town and Country
And those are just the first four I googled. Look these people are successul writers and business people who likely earn a better living working for themselves than working for someone else. Those who succeed in freelancing give it their ALL, and to say that they're just hacks who fell backwards into freelancing because they failed to get a "real" job is ridiculously insulting.
#14 Posted by Colin Lenton, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 02:00 PM
I echo what Jill says. Do I wish even very inexperienced writers could get paid for every single thing they write that's not on their personal website? Yes. But this column isn't called #hopesanddreamstalk, it's called #realtalk.
#15 Posted by Ann Friedman, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 02:12 PM
Thomas - Colin nailed it. I've been offered many jobs and didn't take them because I enjoy freelancing and, quite frankly, I make more working for myself than a magazine could pay me.
Jill - I think you're assuming too much in saying that we're from a different generation because I am in that age range you talk about. I am single and rely only on my income. I had student loans (undergrad and grad) but paid them off. I don't live in NYC, but my mortgage payment is certainly in line with the numbers you shared (I live in the Philadelphia area and chose to do so because of lower housing costs - I considered it a business decision that would give me more capital for my business). I have retirement accounts, emergency savings, health insurance. How did this all happen? Because I run my business like a business. I refused to take work that did not pay me what my work was worth. And I refused to write for free.
#16 Posted by Jen A. Miller, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 02:15 PM
I think both choices and flexibility make a big difference in any career - freelance writing or not.
#17 Posted by Joanne Mason, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 02:19 PM
Ann, that's why we're sharing: it's #realtalk. I hope you'll listen to those of us who are making it work, and learn something from us.
Good luck with everything.
#18 Posted by Jen A. Miller, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 02:22 PM
Ann, realtalk - those who succeed at this don't work for free.
This is what veteran experts are saying.
It isn't impossible to pay your sky high NYC rent.
It isn't impossible to pay all your bills and save for a retirement.
And it isn't impossible to pay your own healthcare.
What is the key? Value your work, charge for it and don't work for free.
This isn't some pie in the sky dream. This is a bunch of experts, telling you how they did it and how you could do it.
#19 Posted by Colin Lenton, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 02:22 PM
Many of the pro freelances speaking here are members of the American Society of Journalists and Authors (ASJA, http://www.asja.org), the professional association of independent writers, of which I am executive director. Their stand is our stand: writing for free is ill-advised in most situations and devalues the work for everyone. Good writing is worth paying for and worth being paid for, and the way to build your rep and gain experience is by doing a great job for all your clients and projects. It's not easy, but that's why not everyone is doing it.
#20 Posted by Alexandra Owens, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 02:32 PM
I agree with Jen. When I started freelancing, I was paid for my very first article and all of the hundreds of subsequent ones I've written, other than a few articles I specifically wrote on a pro bono basis over the past several years to help a charity that I support, the Writers Emergency Assistance Fund, which helps professional writers of nonfiction who are unable to work due to an illness, disability or extraordinary professional crisis.
After writing 5 paid articles for a newspaper syndicate, I was able to break into dozens of big circulation national markets, including Harper's Magazine, Glamour, Cosmopolitan, and dozens of others, and also landed the first of my six book contracts. Additionally the argument that "most" people start any career by working for free is patently absurd, since the vast majority of employees do NOT start with an unpaid internship--they get jobs that pay from the start, albeit at lower salaries than they typically earn once they gain experience and improve their skills.
Unfortunately, there's a lot of bad advice for freelancers out there, and I think the recommendation that they give away their work, coming from someone who advices that she doesn't know much about the topic, is a prime example. Speaking as the author of 2 books on freelance writing, and one of the contributors to the ASJA Guide to Freelance Writing, I would have preferred to see advice from a seasoned freelancer with success strategies to share, rather than a novice who is "experimenting" with methods to break into freelancing after having a salaried job as an editor.
#21 Posted by Lisa Collier Cool, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 02:36 PM
Colin, I notice you chose to address only minutiae instead of responding to my points about unpaid internships or the obvious mob and bullying mentality or the fact that this is a choice that anyone should be able to make without feeling shame for allegedly harming the industry.
What worked for this person or that person doesn't necessarily work for every person. Nobody follows the exact same path to success and I don't think any of you have a right to criticize or belittle someone for deciding to try something just to create a spark in their future career. For centuries, people have been participating in unpaid or very low-paying tasks, jobs, internships, apprenticeships as the way to begin their work lives. In an ideal world, sure, all people would get paid top dollar from day one. But that's not reality.
I congratulate myself on making these excellent points.
#22 Posted by Thomas K. Jacobs, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 02:37 PM
Thomas, the people commenting here are commenting to try and help other freelancers succeed. As someone who has found success freelancing, I cringe when I see bad advice given to other people just starting out. I really cringe when it is done under the brand of a well respected trade magazine. This advice isn't coming from a bully pulpit, this advice is coming from hard working people who are taking their time to help out other potential freelancers.
#23 Posted by Colin Lenton, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 02:43 PM
Colin, you make a fair point. I support people offering advice or trying to help. This seems to go beyond that. And again, I return to my previous point: there is more than one way to achieve success. Perhaps purposely not taking unpaid assignments worked for some people. Great for them. Perhaps taking unpaid assignments worked or will work for some other people. Great for them, too.
This discussion is now over since you can all agree that my points are accurate. Thank you.
#24 Posted by Thomas K. Jacobs, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 02:50 PM
Thomas, I did get a good chuckle (and I mean that in a good-humored way, not sarcastically) from your statement that some of us commenters are "mainly people who couldn't get a real job so you are forced to beg for work on a daily basis."
Actually, I'm a Registered Nurse. I choose to freelance full-time instead of nursing because, for one thing, I make better money. But, believe me, I have multiple offers a DAY to go back to nursing. I certainly don't freelance because I can't get a real job.
Also, I don't "beg for work." I suppose that's one way of looking at it, especially when a person is first starting out. But I went full-time as freelancer in April of this year (having done it part-time since January) and already a substantial percentage of my work comes to me, rather than vice-versa. That said, this can be a real feast/famine lifestyle. I don't expect my current cycle of ongoing, well-paying work to continue ad infinitum.
Lastly, Ms. Friedman: I hope you don't feel bullied. I do understand you're giving what you consider to be sound advice to people interested in becoming a freelance journalist. I hope those who read your column here will also read this comment thread for some different viewpoints.
#25 Posted by Elizabeth Hanes, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 03:28 PM
Unless and until you have a closed, win-win sale, you *are* working for free! So network, prospect, qualify, handle objections, and close just like any other sales professional, because that's what it takes to get paid.
#26 Posted by M. Edward (Ed) Borasky (@znmeb), CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 03:33 PM
Perhaps more personal experiences will help illustrate how a freelance writer can make a living -- right out of the gate. I started out writing for much smaller markets, with assignments from my daily newspaper's real estate section, regional parenting magazines, a start-up national parenting publication and a local military publication. All of these outlets paid, not a lot but they did pay. My very first pitch to a national consumer publication was to Parents magazine. (I did not know the editor.) Five minutes after my query hit the editor's desk, she called me. I got the assignment on the spot.
I don't say this to brag about my experience. Some of it was sheer luck. Some of it was because I'm good at what I do. I did my homework, researching the publication and writing a query that fit what they needed. I say this because honestly, if I can do that, any good writer can.
The first eight years of my freelance career, I wrote primarily "idea" pieces (if I'm understanding that term correctly), some for major publications and some for smaller outlets. Later, I found that my business model required that I write for less glamorous outlets, like trade or custom publications and yes, gasp!, corporations and non-profits. And these days, I'm doing a lot of curriculum development work and writing books.
Still, I know many six-figure freelance writers who earn their living from the big glossies. Take a look at any table of contents in the grocery-store magazine rack -- you'll see their names.
My point is that this can be done -- and is being done every single day. There aren't any secret codes for developing a freelance career. There are dozens of books and websites by reputable and successful freelance writers who are telling folks exactly what to do. In my experience, freelance writers are generally a very generous lot. Many of those six-figure freelancers were incredible helpful to me at the beginning of my career, and still are.
Being in this business requires flexibility and an agile business mind. That means moving past the ideas that you must know the editors and must work for free.
#27 Posted by Laura Laing, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 03:41 PM
These are all great points, and by no means did I intend to devalue freelancing! I've freelanced before, but never as a profession, and I am not an expert on this topic by any means. I was thinking more from a rookie perspective...write something for a friend's site that you respect, write something for a non-profit...More along the lines of gathering clips that are not just from your own self-made blog. At least that's what editors used to look for...maybe that is not the case anymore.
#28 Posted by Gina Goodman (@CisionNavigator), CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 03:45 PM
Thomas,
The comment that we couldn't get real jobs is nothing short of hysterical. Just speaking for myself, I've worked for a major wire service and four newspapers - including two major papers in one of the largest states in the country. I have no desire to work full-time for a publication again. Freelancing is far more lucrative. I can work from home, during the hours I choose, and don't have an editor watching my every move.
As for begging for work - one word. No. We have steady clients. We've proven we can deliver what editors want, when they want it. That gains us repeat work.
If you want to champion writing for "free," go for it. It certainly won't pay the bills.
#29 Posted by Susan Ladika, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 04:17 PM
There are all sorts of freelance writers:
Writers who write for the big glossies/websites and write glowing essays about how they partied their butts off in whatever big city they were in while living like paupers (the romantic ideal, I guess),
Writers who fly into war zones without an assignment, flirting with danger in order to get the story they need to sell to newspapers and magazines,
Writers who started out writing on blogs for nothing or maybe $5 per post to get a foot into the full-time door (that's kinda how I did it, though my first paid piece was for Salon... and that's while I was still working my IT job),
Writers who like the steadiness of places like Demand or other content mills because they have bills to pay,
Writers who write nothing but corporate copy or marketing copy and make a good living at it,
And writers who do any combination of the above, because they are good business people and know they need to diversify.
To say that there's one way of doing it -- either in the case of "never work for free" or "you have to work for free to get your foot in the door" -- is really the wrong way to go about this issue.
The key is to teach the right business skills to freelancers first, like how to set yourself up financially as Jen mentioned, and then let them decide how to go about building that business. Everything else really shouldn't be any of our concern.
#30 Posted by Joel Keller, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 04:32 PM
Painters don't work for free to show you that they can paint your house for you. A plumber won't say, "hey, I'll fix your toilet for free so if you like my work, you can hire me for something else." Writers are no different. For the most part, writers should not write for free.
I didn't start my life as a writer. I began writing as I worked in another profession. When the time was right, I jumped into full time freelancing. I didn't have any connections. I didn't have any networks. My first long-time client was found by cold calling. My current anchor client, who has been with me for two and a half years happened because I answered their CraigsList ad.
Now that I am established, yes, I do have contacts and I use them. I help others as they help me.
#31 Posted by Marijke, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 04:51 PM
I agree with the other writers here who've eloquently stated why writing for free is generally a bad idea. Another point: if you want to impress an editor, it's not going to happen just because you have a fistful of clips from non-paying sites they've never heard of ... or worse, from content mills, which many new writers are attracted to. When you're starting out, you want clips that sell you, not sink you. I think it's far better to spend your time writing outstanding pitch letters to the markets you genuinely want to write for so you can get the clip that moves you to the next job. BTW, I'll also admit I think clips are overrated and newer writers worry far too much about them when they should be worrying more about craft, developing and targeting ideas correctly, and behaving like a professional. I tell writers: you want to write for free? Start a blog while you're busy pitching editors. It's a great way to explore a subject that's important to you -- unicycling, sock knitting, Italian culture, whatever. A blog is you, unedited, and if you're a very, very good writer, editors will take notice.
#32 Posted by Diana Burrell, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 05:13 PM
I've been a freelancer for 14 years, and I make decent money. If you were on staff at a publication before you started freelancing, then bingo - clips! In my case, I had done research reports, newsletter articles, and trade magazine articles when I worked as a financial analyst, so I started with plenty of clips. I didn't need to write for free. Every one of these clips was better than anything I see on eHow or whatever content mill you might be considering.
To get more clips, I did work for different non-profit organizations, writing web copy or newsletter articles. This way, I built up my portfolio and earned great references while giving back to the community.
Another way I showed off my writing skills was to write good letters of introduction. An editor who would rather see bad content-mill links than a good letter of introduction is an editor I don't want to work with.
I write for free under three circumstances now: 1) to write about politics and culture for a site run by some friends from college, and only when I have some downtown; 2) when I know I can promote one of my books (putting my blog in this category); and 3) as a volunteer for a non-profit organization.
#33 Posted by Annie Logue, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 05:25 PM
As a professional freelance journalist for the past 12 years, I have never written for free. Instead, I've built a writing, reporting and editing business that has a steady income stream and is based on solid reporting. Freelancing takes both entrepreneurial skills and reporting skills. Sadly some new freelancers may have the latter but not the former, and they fail as a result.
Reading through this comment thread, I now realize it has become the "how-to" freelance story CJR should have published.
#34 Posted by Lisa Palmer, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 05:28 PM
I much prefer the freelance lifestyle to a real job, which I have had. I am making more money now as a freelance writer than I did working for Associated Press full time including holidays and weekends. I work about 1/2 to 2/3 time and I also have time to teach 20 private piano students a week. I have had recent offers for a so-called real job. No thank you. When I quit thinking of my story ideas as my children heading to kindergarten and approached writing as a business, my career and income took off. I have not written for free since I was in my late teens/early 20s and still in J school. I don't teach piano for free either. Nor, would I ask my painter to give me a free try out on the bathroom and then see if he was good enough to paint the living room. He would wet his paints laughing! Google me or go to my website for my credits.
#35 Posted by Karen Haywood Queen, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 05:45 PM
Thanks for a fabulous, informative discussion, all. I hope it continues. I just want to dip in for a sec to point out that, for those saying this is a generational difference in approach, CJR ran a piece in a recent issue broaching the subject of how young freelancers "piece" it together.
#36 Posted by Kira Goldenberg, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 05:55 PM
Begging for work? Huh?
I regularly turn down writing jobs. I have PLENTY of corporate, custom-publishing, editorial and blogging gigs to keep me busy as a part-time freelance writer (I work when my kids are in school; about 35 hours/week).
There are a few times I would advocate writing for free:
1. During college (for the school paper or literary magazine) or during an internship (i.e. I interned at Parents and Boston magazine while in school, earning valuable clips).
2. When changing genres. For example, I wrote for free even after I was well established in local-market and parenting publications because I decided I wanted to be a travel writer. For a year, I wrote weekly for free on a honeymoon site so then i could have some travel related clips to show editors. I made invaluable contacts in travel PR. Well worth my time and energy, for sure.
3. To promote your own blog or platform. For example, a guest post of mine was just published on ProBlogger.net last week, and the links from his site to my travel blog... again, invaluable. My blog traffic spiked when the post went live. Totally worth my time.
Let me know, CJR or Ann Friedman, when you'd like to interview a successful freelance writer for a future column! I also happily lend my time to Q&As about the craft and business of freelance writing. Surely other smart freelancers who have commented would also participate.
#37 Posted by Kara Williams, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 06:18 PM
Oh, and the animated gifs? Distracting and annoying.
#38 Posted by Kara Williams, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 06:21 PM
"The lag time between publication and payment is usually significant. So prepare to harass your employers to cut the check."
This is a telling statement, because these are not "employers." When you write freelance, you are self employed. Running your business means that you've vetted your clients as well as you can so that you won't have to add "harass to cut check" to your routine except rarely.
What separates success from failure as a freelancer is knowing how to run a business. Those "employers"? They're customers. You identify them, market to them, serve them a quality product, and request repeat business from them. You know your rights and the expectations as stated in the contract you agree to with them, and you keep good records for tax time. You also connect with other freelancers -- not the whiny kind, but the kind who do what you aspire to do where you aspire to do it and who earn the kind of income you want to make and seem to do it with no hassle.
The short answers to the letter writer: You are correct that what you do to find a job (networking) doesn't work so well when it isn't yourself you're selling. So pitch what editors are buying, pitch well, empower yourself with entrepreneurial knowledge, learn from mentors (even if they don't know they're mentors) and, yes, you can make a sweeter living from freelancing than you ever could make on staff and still have a real life, too.
#39 Posted by Holly Ocasio Rizzo, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 07:59 PM
Why is it so hard to post on this site? I had to try 6 times before my previous comment posted and a friend says he gave up after 10 tries. Also, what's with the animation of what appears to be a deranged, ranting woman that's stuck in the middle of the post? Very distracting!
Now on my fifth try to post this comment--hope 5 times is the charm.
#40 Posted by Lisa Collier Cool, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 08:10 PM
For some more real talk and real advice, prospective freelancers might want to check out http://www.freelancesuccess.com. You can gain insight and expertise from some of the most successful freelance writers in the country so that you don't have to accept no- or low-paying writing gigs.
#41 Posted by Lisa Jaffe Hubbell, CJR on Thu 6 Sep 2012 at 08:55 PM
"Why is it so hard to post on this site? I had to try 6 times before my previous comment posted and a friend says he gave up after 10 tries."
The captcha text engine is annoying and I find you have to refresh it a few times to get readable input (click the circular arrow button by the reCAPTCHA logo).
Furthermore, you can be denied by putting more than two links in a post.
Cheers.
#42 Posted by Thimbles, CJR on Fri 7 Sep 2012 at 12:03 AM
I agree that the captcha text on this site is THE hardest to read that I've ever seen. I had to refresh it a number of times to find anything that was even remotely readable, but even then I've found it very hard to post, even though there were no links at all in my comments. Not sure what the issue is.
#43 Posted by Lisa Collier Cool, CJR on Fri 7 Sep 2012 at 12:11 AM
I tend to find if you're on the move and flicking between networks and 3G, the captcha craps out, which might have to do with the way captcha uses your connecting ip to create the session-id associated with the challenge.
It really depends on the error message the vqs389.pair.com cgi program puts up. If it's not putting up a message and just taking a long time to update, realize that the cgi takes a really long time to redirect your page to the refreshed page containing your comment, much longer than the cgi program needs to post the update to the page.
And yeah, if you don't use the link below to set your cookies:
http://www.cjr.org/?nomobile=1
You can forget about using mobile devices to interact with the site.
Share the error you're getting and maybe I (or someone authorized) can help.
#44 Posted by Thimbles, CJR on Fri 7 Sep 2012 at 01:49 AM
I have one more comment on the money and the idea that this is not realistic for a single person in an expensive city. I live in one of Chicago's more expensive neighborhoods. And, my husband was unemployed for several months a few years ago. I made the mortgage and supported our family as a freelancer.
Is it easy? No. If I had to make all of the mortgage every month, we would move to a cheaper house. But is it possible? Absolutely. You have to hustle.
But there is no way you can pay the mortgage working for free. Chase Home Finance doesn't accept "exposure".
#45 Posted by Annie Logue, CJR on Fri 7 Sep 2012 at 08:43 AM
I want to chime in that I have been self employed (by choice) for 19 years as a freelance writer. I started freelancing, while working full time, when I was 22. My first professional piece was for New York magazine, and I got $500 for it. Did I mention I was 22? And I had no other clips. What I had was a good idea, and professional way of pitching it.
Also, I was living in New York City at the time. When I went freelance, I will admit that I supplemented my income with temp work, but I never once wrote for free.
Additionally, I made a choice to move OUT of New York City because of the aforementioned expense of living there. It is not easy being self employed as a writer but you can do it if you are willing to make other sacrifices in your life, such as where you live or how often you eat out. But you do not have to accept work for free.
Leah
#46 Posted by Leah Ingram, CJR on Fri 7 Sep 2012 at 08:52 AM
It seems there's a generation gap here, one that all of us could learn from. I'll humbly admit that I am in the older gap. I don't care to reveal my age, but I've been working as some sort of a writer or editor for 20 years, the last 12 of which have been freelance. I make a good living. I support my entire family. I do not supplement my income with a part time job or side gigs. My husband makes almost nothing. It definitely can be done. There are lots of us doing it. There's hope, folks. Freelancing doesn't equal starving. All of that said I do see the 20 something generation struggling in this economy. They are not just struggling as freelancers--but in nearly every single career. They are trying new strategies. For that, I think there's something for us older folks to admire. That said, I've worked as a magazine editor, so I'd like to offer that not all clips are the same. If someone sent me clips from Huffington Post, as just one example, my first thought would have been, "This person has no experience." Those sorts of clips hurt you more than they help. As an editor, I gave lots of breaks to young writers with little experience who sent me brilliant pitches. It would be nice for this column to address that: how to write a pitch that an editor will buy, even if you have no clips. That could be very useful.
#47 Posted by Alisa Bowman, CJR on Fri 7 Sep 2012 at 04:50 PM
I'm a part-time freelancer, and I've written for free. There are great publications with very talented editors who can't afford to pay me right now, and I'm fine with that. I enjoy working with publications that can't pay when they offer me something in return--a spectacular editor from whom I can learn something is sometimes payment in itself.
#48 Posted by Melody Wilson, CJR on Mon 10 Sep 2012 at 11:22 AM
Count me among those who has been making a good living as a freelance writer for years now. I had full-time jobs in the past, and I'm still offered full-time jobs now on a regular basis. I don't want them! I prefer the freelance life, which allows me to take my goddaughter to the beach on a Wednesday during the summer or take a trip without having to ask anyone's permission, not to mention the short commute from the bedroom to my office in the morning (whenever I want to start the morning). That doesn't mean I don't have to be disciplined. Freelancing requires more of that than full-time work, but I think the problem for a lot of people is that freelancing also requires ingenuity, an entrepreneurial spirit, and hefty organizational skills. You can't sit at home waiting for jobs to fall out of the sky. You have to go for them. Once you've established yourself, you still have to market yourself frequently (even if you have some regular clients), but you certainly don't have to BEG. That's ridiculous. You also don't have to write for free unless you REALLY want to for some personal reason that makes sense to you. Treat yourself like a professional, and others will, too. If you treat yourself like someone who has to beg to write for $0, no one is ever going to value what you do because you clearly don't value yourself.
#49 Posted by Melanie Votaw, CJR on Sat 15 Sep 2012 at 09:59 PM
I am just breaking into freelance writing. The prospect of building a list of writing credits is indeed daunting. I spent some months writing for a content mill and justified it by telling myself I was learning to work to deadline and getting the creative juices flowing. The real issue is I was scared of rejection and never sent out any pitches during that time. After I finally buckled down and started sending them, the third one was accepted. A well-researched, well-written query landed the assignment. I do not believe my experience writing for a content mill is worth anything. By working for little or nothing, we only show editors we are willing to work for little or nothing. It is a waste of time and looks unprofessional. I agree with Michelle's position that guest blogging is worthwhile. It helped me network with other freelancers and ultimately that was what gave me the confidence to seek my first "real assignment."
#50 Posted by Van Waffle, CJR on Mon 17 Sep 2012 at 11:10 AM
Top 10 Reasons NOT to Freelance (trust me, been there)
#10 You are subsidising mainstream media
#09 You become part of the problem, not the solution
#08 Freelancing weakens journalism, linking professionalism with pennies
#07 Freelance cheques takes weeks, months to arrive
#06 The more freelancers that appear, the fewer full-time journos employed
#05 You write lots, get paid for few
#04 Even when paid, your bills mount up and you end up accepting assignments that your ethics tell you are wrong
#03 Freelancing outsources weakens the responsibility of news media to inform the people as the 4th Estate
#02 Freelancing and notions of "entrepreneurial" journalism will suck the life out of your soul.
#01 Freelancing = business as usual
#51 Posted by Jason Brown, CJR on Tue 25 Sep 2012 at 06:24 PM