Where does Ikea build a plant when it wants to offshore work to pay poverty wages, bust unions, force mandatory overtime, and generally slave-drive their workers?
The quote of the day goes to Bill Street, a union organizer in Danville, Virginia, on that:
“It’s ironic that Ikea looks on the U.S. and Danville the way that most people in the U.S. look at Mexico,” Street said.
The Los Angeles Times has a great piece by Nathaniel Popper looking at how the Swedish giant treats its American workers like dirt (emphasis mine) at its Swedwood manufacturing subsidiary:
Laborers in Swedwood plants in Sweden produce bookcases and tables similar to those manufactured in Danville. The big difference is that the Europeans enjoy a minimum wage of about $19 an hour and a government-mandated five weeks of paid vacation. Full-time employees in Danville start at $8 an hour with 12 vacation days — eight of them on dates determined by the company.What’s more, as many as one-third of the workers at the Danville plant have been drawn from local temporary-staffing agencies. These workers receive even lower wages and no benefits, employees said.
Swedwood’s Steen said the company is reducing the number of temps, but she acknowledged the pay gap between factories in Europe and the U.S. “That is related to the standard of living and general conditions in the different countries,” Steen said.
True! I believe Virginia is what you call a “pro-business state.” It’s so pro-business that it’s paying Ikea $12 million in incentives to give it those 335 crappy, low-paying jobs. I don’t know what the average wage is at the Danville Ikea plant, but just as an exercise, that $12 million is more than twice what the entire labor force there earns in a year on an average wage of $8 an hour.
Hey, silver lining: American business will be able to keep all those jobs they offshore closer to home, as the gap between labor costs here and in China narrows sharply.
There also seems to be a racial discrimination problem at the plant, and Popper and the LAT throw in the media angle, too:
The dust-up has garnered little attention in the U.S. But it’s front-page news in Sweden, where much of the labor force is unionized and Ikea is a cherished institution.
You know things are probably not good when workers in the South try to organize:
Some of the Virginia plant’s 335 workers are trying to form a union. The International Assn. of Machinists and Aerospace Workers said a majority of eligible employees had signed cards expressing interest.
In response, the factory — part of Ikea’s manufacturing subsidiary, Swedwood — hired the law firm Jackson Lewis, which has made its reputation keeping unions out of companies. Workers said Swedwood officials required employees to attend meetings at which management discouraged union membership.
Things are so different from how Ikea treats its Swedish employees that the head of its Swedish union is baffled by how bad it’s acting in the U.S.
“Ikea is a very strong brand and they lean on some kind of good Swedishness in their business profile. That becomes a complication when they act like they do in the United States,” said Sjoo. “For us, it’s a huge problem.”
This is terrific labor reporting by the LA Times.

I agree that IKEA comes off really bad in this article. But there are still some questions that weren't answered. It asserts that the plant employs 335 workers and pay starts at $8 an hour. That leaves the impression that no one there is paid more. What is the top end of the wage scale? How many of the plant's 335 workers are paid $8 an hour? And in which departments? Are there performance bonuses offered? What kind of health benefits are provided? And how long does it take to move up the wage scale? (The article also said the company took away regular wage increases, as if that is somehow unheard of. Absurd. The only people that I know who are receiving guaranteed regular wage increases in this economy work for governments.)
A starting wage of $8 an hour sounds despicably low for factory work, but these questions should be asked before necessarily casting aspersions on IKEA.
Also, with regards to the $19/hr starting wage in Sweden, I believe we should know a little more before assigning a moral judgment to the difference between what the company pays its American and Swedish workers. For instance, how much would it cost in Sweden to maintain a typical American middle class life? Details like that would lend context to the story.
#1 Posted by JB, CJR on Tue 12 Apr 2011 at 04:52 PM
JB, I have to agree that $8 an hour does sound low. I think a cashier at an Ikea retail outlet makes more than that. I would would want to see where exactly that figure came from.
#2 Posted by Mike H, CJR on Tue 12 Apr 2011 at 05:36 PM
Based on 2010 Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) figures, a $19/hr starting wage in Sweden would be equivalent (in PPP terms) to approx. $15/hr in the US. Conversely an $8/hr starting wage in the US would be equivalent (in PPP terms) to approx. $10/hr starting wage in Sweden. So in PPP terms, the Swedish starting wage at IKEA is 90% hirer than the starting wage in Virginia.
#3 Posted by Anthony Miller, CJR on Thu 14 Apr 2011 at 08:25 AM
IKEA will have no trouble getting as many people as it wants in Danville.
Unemployment is over 10% and the area is filled with low-skilled former furniture factory workers.
It's a great place to open a plant - and a great business decision.
The shame here is that 50 years of liberal "Great Society" failure has transformed a once thriving factory town into a destitute crime-ridden city full of ignorant, unskilled laborers scrambling to line up for low-paying work.
Unionizing won't get anywhere - IKEA can open a similar plant anywhere in the South if labor costs exceed market rates.
#4 Posted by padikiller, CJR on Thu 14 Apr 2011 at 02:54 PM
I get it the poor slobs should be thankful for the wages they get.
Oh yeah unions had nothing to do with the 40 hr work week.
But that's okay its those devil liberals that caused all the problems.
Hey, welcome to the third world America. You know if we are real
lucky we just might to get to keep some of that money. Of course
if the oil companies don't price oil to high. Or maybe the large health,
companies don't price us into losing our homes. Or,or,or, but it doesn't
matter there are just to many yahoos who are willing to follow the dogma
of the rich and powerful. It's good to suck up to the rich maybe, just maybe
they'll throw us some crumbs now and then and we'll feel well fed.
Herbert Hoover must be dancing in his grave.
#5 Posted by jd2882, CJR on Thu 14 Apr 2011 at 09:35 PM
It's not the fault of the oil companies that people are lining up to work for $8 an hour in cities like Danville.
The problem is that most of our formerly industrial cities are full of ignorant, uneducated and unskilled residents. Fifty years of federal intervention in public schools has rendered them useless. Welfare programs that promised to elevate an entire class of society have instead created a permanent underclass - a matriarchal dependency that plagues the crime-infested, filthy public housing projects across the country.
Unemployment in Danville is 12.5%. The murder rate is about four times the national average.
Oil companies didn't do this.
Liberals did it.
Unions don't help unskilled labor in an economy with more than 10% unemployment. Don't get me wrong- If the workers at this IKEA plant want to organize and collectively bargain, I fully support their right to do so - I am a former member of two trade unions. I'm just saying that in this market, it won't do them any good. If people are lining up to make a pittance, there is zero chance that union leadership will muster the stamina for a strike or lockout, and IKEA certainly knows that.
#6 Posted by padikiller, CJR on Fri 15 Apr 2011 at 07:36 AM
Tim Kaine, the Democratic former governor of Virginia, brought $8 an hour IKEA contract jobs to Danville...
Bob McDonnell, the GOP current governor, is bringing high-tech jobs to Danville....
http://www.wset.com/story/14922442/supercomputer-coming-to-white-mill-building
#7 Posted by padikiller, CJR on Thu 16 Jun 2011 at 04:44 PM