Yes, that’s right. My folks were put into that type of loan unbeknownst to them, and even against their expressed wishes. Hard to believe, I know, but unfortunately it’s very true. I’m glad your broker seems to have been honest, though the broker who dealt with my did too until they went to sell their house, but it’s clear that many, many were not.
The point of “My Foreclosure” was simply to tell what it’s like to lose your home. It’s a real trauma and I feared the awfulness of it might get slightly lost in the blizzard of bad news and statistics. We thought business reporters, especially in the elite publications read by the national and global decision-makers, might be somewhat detached from this reality.
So to further get the point across, check out journalist Darleene’s poignant post about her own experience a decade ago, which she linked to in the “My Foreclosure” comments.
And I’ll conclude with an e-mail from a reader named Erin, who heard me on an NPR program last week. She and I are old enough to talk about this, but for many of the hundreds of thousands of kids going through this now, it will take years for them to come to terms with it:
I just happened to hear you on Here and Now in my car on XM. Your story is somewhat the same as my family’s. My father owned a gas station in the 70s, but by the early 80s he was the only person he could afford to employ so he worked long hours and finally he just couldn’t make it. My parents declared bankruptcy and we lost our home when I was 11. We moved out of town which is probably a good thing looking back. But my dad spent almost the next ten years trying to find steady work. It’s hard when you’re in your 40s, with an MBA and a former self-employed person to find someone to hire you. My father also had worked since he was old enough to have a paper route (and like your parents — staunch Republican). I remember how I was known for not eating lunch in middle school — my friends thought I wasn’t hungry, but I was actually too ashamed to go get the free tickets from the secretary because someone might hear. I didn’t eat lunch regularly until I went to college.My parents still rent — 20 years later. I own a home with my husband, but we didn’t buy at the high end of what we could afford and we plan to make due with this home even if more children make it a tight squeeze. I also used to be in the mortgage industry and I also agree that there are plenty of people out there ready to make a buck off of people anyway they can. I also know that not many people are educated about mortgages and home financing, especially those whose parents didn’t own their homes.
Anyway, thanks for sharing your story. It’s always good to hear someone else whose background is similar to mine. It also throws people’s ideas about welfare and government programs out the window. If people think there are a lot of people who are looking for ways to get on welfare — they are wrong. Another thing — my older brother got a job and worked through high school to pay for his own car, pay for opportunities like playing sports. Our state government found out and my parents had to pay back some of the money they were given. Forget that they had 3 other children. So we were penalized for my brother paying for himself because they thought he should pay things for my parents. It was an awful feeling for all of us because we knew how hard my brother worked and how proud my dad was.
Thanks again,
Erin
- 1
- 2





I agree that most of the blame belongs to the banks and mortgage broker. The thing that keeps coming to mind is that the first thing one learns in ethics class is that you don’t use your knowledge in your field of expertise to take advantage of your client. There was an article in the Times a little while back about many lenders are splitting (50/50) the loss on a short sale. I don’t think 100/0 or 0/100 is fair, but 50/50 seems to imply that the burden is shared equally. I don’t buy that.
Additionally, I know that when I bought my first house I didn’t read every line of papers. Luckily I was working with a local trusted bank who has survived this mortgage crisis quiet well. But with all the stories out there, I know next time I will be reading it much more carefully. Even still, it took a couple of hours to sign everything. Reading everything will take a couple of days. Probably not a bad idea though now.
Posted by Ryan on Mon 3 Nov 2008 at 11:59 AM
"Our state government found out and my parents had to pay back some of the money they were given"
...so this happened in ol' Russia, right ??
Posted by at on Mon 3 Nov 2008 at 02:56 PM
"My folks were put into that type of loan unbeknownst to them, and even against their expressed wishes. Hard to believe, I know, but unfortunately it’s very true"
One isn't "put" into a loan by any "unbeknownst" process. One "gets" into a loan by signing a mortgage and settlement agreements.
Adults with legal capacity to contract voluntarily sign agreements and deeds of trust.
If people are too lazy, uneducated or unsophisticated to read and understand documents that bind them to thirty years of contractual obligation, then these people should not own real estate.
Who to feel sorry for here? Certainly for any child tossed out of his home because of his parents' mistake. I'm not trying to downplay the horrible experience Mr. Chittum suffered (I have a niece and nephew in similar circumstances).
But how about the taxpaying single mother who pays her mortgage faithfully and who is now saddled with the responsibility of bailing out her irresponsible neighbors? (I have a sister-in-law in this situation)
This whole scandal devolves into a few million instances of the same event- a borrower gets money from a lender and agrees to pay according to the terms of the contract. And in every case, the borrower reneges. To place the blame on lenders is just silly- they did exactly what they contracted to do.
Nobody wants to take personal responsibility for anything anymore. Blame the banks. Blame the government. Blame somebody else. Democracy can't last long in such an environment.
Posted by padikiller on Mon 3 Nov 2008 at 06:54 PM
Hate to say it, but if you can afford a) college, b) Disneyworld, and c) a hotel room AT ALL, to many people in America - you ARE an elitist. That's what Mary means. Your idea of "working class" or "poor" is incredibly skewed.
Talk to me when you can just afford sending your kids to public high school if you cut down on your own lunches. Talk to me when you don't have a vacation in twenty years. Talk to me when you can't afford a car and have to access the internet from the library. THAT is working-class.
Poor is a tar-paper shack and starvation, not renting.
Posted by Charlene on Tue 30 Dec 2008 at 01:29 AM
Great story Ryan, thanks for re-posting it for your new readers.
As a relative free-marketeer, I am jealous of the rhetorical weapons the market skeptics have at their disposal. Those who support Fannie and Freddie, farm subsidies and steel tariffs can point to evicted families, foreclosed farms and unemployed salt of the earth sixty-year-olds. Those who support free trade and lean regulation have a more academic case to make. Either that or they must point the finger at lazy free-loaders, appealing to some less honorable emotions.
Posted by Chris Corliss on Tue 30 Dec 2008 at 02:31 PM
Charlene, we lost our house 15 years ago. Disney World wasn't even dreamed about then. We didn't have vacations for about a decade in there. We depended on food stamps and groceries from grandma for several years around that time, as I wrote.
And by the way, my parents couldn't afford college at all. I made it through a state school with scholarships, Pell Grants, and student loans--and not one dime from my folks, who couldn't have spared it. So did my sister.
As I said in the first installment (see link below), my dad's health has improved, my mom went back to school and got a better job, and they're much better off financially in the last few years than they ever have been. God bless 'em.
Believe me, I understand what you're feeling. That's why I wrote the original piece in the first place.
http://www.cjr.org/the_audit/my_foreclosure.php?page=all
Posted by Ryan Chittum on Wed 31 Dec 2008 at 01:29 AM