Polls (polling data in the hands of cable pundits in particular) have earned a particularly bad name this election season.

So, what might be more credible or reliable than an actual poll? If not with a poll of a snapshot in time, how might we foretell the future? If not a poll, in what might we place our faith now?

A cable pundit’s hunch!

Tucker Carlson and Joe Scarborough on MSNBC this morning (emphasis mine):

CARLSON: We know that Bill Clinton, it’s a commonplace now, it’s conventional wisdom, has hurt his wife’s campaign. Nobody wants to hear this but I believe it’s true. I believe Barack Obama’s wife has hurt his campaign. I believe that. There is a widespread perception out there that she is an elitist even to a greater extent than he is and I bet if you polled on that, it’s true.

SCARBOROUGH: These are one of the things you’re not supposed to say on TV. I love Michelle Obama, I think she’s great but she gave a speech a week ago and she looked angry. I sat there and I was thinking that’s just not going to help Barack Obama. Mika [Brzezinski] said during the break, “Just be quiet. That’s not true.” And she thought there was something about race attached to what I was saying. Well, I said the same thing about Hillary Clinton in 1992…

I think [Michelle is] effective, too, at times, but I think also there’s a fine line the Obamas are walking right now, Tucker, on these elitist charges, again. People in central Pennsylvania, I don’t think — I don’t think they want to be talked down to by people that went to Princeton and Harvard.

CARLSON: I think if you polled that you would find it’s absolutely right. I don’t think it has to do with race. I think as popular as Michelle Obama is in the press I think she comes off as bitter to some voters.

I’ve seen plenty of pundits cherry pick polling data to try to support what they think to be true about a candidate, a primary, a group of voters, but, particularly given the blackeye that polls have earned this election season, does using a hypothetical poll to buttress what you “believe” really lend your opinion an air of authority?

If you'd like to get email from CJR writers and editors, add your email address to our newsletter roll and we'll be in touch.

Liz Cox Barrett is a writer at CJR.