Exhibit 05092009, from The New York Times, a Sunday front-page profile of Margaret Chan, the director-general of the World Health Organization, who is being hailed for her authoritative response to the swine-flu pandemic. And, so the Times offered some glimpses into the life and personality of the woman at the helm (emphasis mine).
All of this authority is packed into a diminutive woman with large glasses who does not drive, type or cook, is fond of sharp suits and silver pins, and may be among the most qualified people in the world to lead the global response to the threat of a pandemic flu.
Really? And…
And it all started because her boyfriend decided to move to Canada.
Born in 1947, Dr. Chan grew up in Hong Kong and became a teacher. When David Chan, who would become her husband, left Hong Kong for college in Canada in 1969, she worried that the separation would end their relationship. So she consulted her mother, who told her to follow her heart to Canada.
Then, when he decided to become a doctor, she worried that his medical studies would leave him no time for her. So she decided to become a doctor with him. But first, she had to win over a dean at the University of Western Ontario who, in her admissions interview, told her that she should become a homemaker, not a doctor.
It’s clear that Dr. Chan is a woman who overcame all sorts of stereotypes to attain her position. And, it’s too bad that the Times turned to stereotypes to create this portrait.
i can see your point on the first breakout. I like the details, but they should have included included them without playing to stereotypes - just state them mater-of-factly and don't imply surprise.
however, the second breakout is a stretch, perhaps because at this point you were looking for hints of condescension. It's not offensive, it's biographical. Her decisions reflect the times she lived it, and the culture she came from. It does nothing more than tell us a little bit about her past. She is obviously intelligent, supremely competent and a force of nature, and the writers say so.
#1 Posted by KJ, CJR on Mon 11 May 2009 at 10:06 PM