Subscribe Today

The Kicker

Star Wars Episode VI: Re-Spurn of the Jedi

By Megan Garber Thu 8 May 2008 02:41 PM 

Howard Kurtz today takes a macrocosmic—literally, macrocosmic—view of the media’s post-Tuesday treatment of the Democrats’ Epic Battle for Cosmic Domina—er, Nomination:

For the moment, there seem to be two separate media universes out there.

In the mainstream print galaxy, Hillary’s “options” are “dwindling,” her “path” to the nomination is “narrowing,” the “math” is “challenging,” Obama is drawing “closer” to the prize.

On MSNBC, the morning shows and the blogosphere, it’s game, set, match. The race is finis, the last rites are being administered, and the debate is about Obama’s chances against McCain.

It’s a fascinating case study: Do the remnants of the MSM that are still treating this as a semi-competitive race believe that Clinton has a serious shot at the nomination, but feel bound by the rule of objectivity not to say so?

Or are the pundits going out on a limb, prematurely writing off Clinton as they have done several times before?

I’d say it’s both. Talk about worlds colliding.

CJR

Subscribe Today
Post a comment

We ask our readers to express opinions in a manner respectful to the readers and writers of CJR. Criticism of ideas is strongly encouraged, but personal, ad hominem attack will result in deletion of posted comments and, after one repeat violation, banning of the individual user. CJR reserves the right to edit or delete, for reasons of content, comments submitted to CJR. We also ask users to please keep posts to the topic at hand; those wandering far afield or appearing to be spam may be deleted. Please read the complete comment policy and full legal disclaimer.

 


About the Author
Megan Garber is an assistant editor at CJR.
Current Cover

May / June 08

Table of Contents Browse Back Issues Subscribe Mission Revisited Getting Bit More...
  • Club Med(vedev)

    The inauguration of Dmitri Medvedev as Russia's new president this week is one of those fantastic Historical Occasions for which air quotes (yes, "air quotes") seem designed. In the sense that the inauguration is basically a farce. Medvedev is, if...

  • EJ Graff Joins the XX Factor

    The XX Factor, Slate's women-written blog, welcomes a new voice today: EJ Graff. Graff, the author of Getting Even and What Is Marriage For?, is an expert on social policy, with a particular focus on women's issues. She's a senior...

  • More ...
The American Newsroom Series

The Associated Press. Miami, Florida. Photo by Sean Hemmerle. More...

Top Stories
Recent Comments