Attention journalists! The flat thing on the desk in front of you is a keyboard. When you wish to write a story, press the little buttons with letters on them, and continue to do so until you’re all out of things to say.
That’s the impression I got last night when reading an internal Associated Press newsletter posted on Romenesko, in which former AP reporter Ron Fournier reminded the wire’s scribes how to do their jobs. Admittedly, I’ve never taken a journalism class in my life, but it read like the kind of thing you might learn in an Introduction to Journalism class at one of our nation’s more prestigious community colleges.
All joking aside, I have to say that while the memo relays some advice that shouldn’t have to be given to a professional journalist, many of Fournier’s tips sound like things CJR has griped about as being absent from too much contemporary journalism: things like following up on important stories once the initial splash fades; taking time to rebut, contextualize (or simply decline to publish) obvious falsehoods and spin; using the lame “critics say” construction without ever defining just who these critics are; and refusing to give all sides an equal say when one of those sides is obviously full of it.
In other words, as Fournier notes, reporters should “commit yourself and your leaders to the truth.”
I’m not criticizing Fournier here—what he says makes sense. The problem is that he felt compelled to write this primer in the first place. That some of this stuff might make light bulbs go off over some reporters’ heads is the kind of thing that should keep assignment editors—hell, the American people—awake at night. In a perfect world, of course, things like “Tak[ing] action when you hear a public official ‘spin’ away from the facts or lie. Don’t just roll your eyes and mark it off to politics as usual,” should be second nature to anyone who cashes a check written by a news organization. Apparently it isn’t.
Sticking to the “spin” theme (we’ve written dozens of posts about it, and not enough can be said of the importance of weaning journalists off the habit of simply writing down what they’re told), Fournier adds that journalists shouldn’t “give equal weight to spin. Just because a public official says it doesn’t mean you need to put it in your story or give his claim equal billing to what you know to be true. We have an obligation to write factual and fair stories, but we are not obliged to print attacks, spin or distortion under the cover of ‘fair comment.’”
Got it? There will be a test next week.




Yeah...hey, don't go hatin' on the community college graduates there!
The stuff that my community college newspaper did whilst I was there was more trustworthy than most of the stuff I see in print and on the tube these days. Just less polished.
Posted by Samuel John Klein
on Wed 13 Jun 2007 at 06:04 PM
Yeah, what's with the jab at community colleges? It's elitist and unnecessary and makes me grouchy.
Posted by Thers
on Wed 13 Jun 2007 at 08:43 PM
Oh yeah...
The press is right there to question every claim of politicians...
Like John Kerry's claim to have to have "botched a joke" at the expense of the American soldiers serving in Iraq.. Paul McLeary was right there tracking that claim down, wasn't he?..
Oh wait... No he wasn't!...
As I recall... Mr. McLeary was right there scooting the story out of public scrutiny just as fast he could... "Move on, people! Nothing to see here!" was the gist of McLeary's advice to his "professional" collegues...
Mr. McLeary and his colleagues similary ignored Kerry's curiously undocumented claims to have run two Boston Marathons... Or Kerry's similary unchronicled "secret mission" to Cambodia- you know, the one President Nixon sent him on, in December 1968 (during the Johnson administration)...
Let's see if we can find more examples of Mr. McLeary's hard-hitting, colorblind "journalism", shall we?...
Two Senators were recently up for reelection in neighboring states... Sen. Allen in Virignia, and Sen. Byrd in West Virginia...
Paul McLeary brought us no end of preelection hit stories of the trumped up, unsubstatiated allegations of racism against Sen. Allen... But McLeary somehow managed to let the election slide by without a PEEP about the fact that Sen. Byrd (a former KKK terrorist) has recently used the "n-word" in public...
When it turned out before the Presidential election that John Kerry lacks a single Irish gene and is instead half Jewish, CJR didn't have a thing to say about it... But Paul McLeary told us that the preelection publicity regarding Sen. Allen's Jewish heritage was nothing less than a "blockbuster" story of national import...
Oh yeah... Paul McLeary and his ilk are out there asking ALL the hard-hitting questions... Of Republicans, that is.... Democrats routinely get a free ride from the wannabe "professionals"...
Posted by padikiller
on Thu 14 Jun 2007 at 05:19 PM
I see the CJR comment police took offense at my takedown of Paul McLeary's snobbism and censored yet another of my posts....
You guys have some thin skins!...
Posted by padikiller
on Fri 15 Jun 2007 at 03:05 PM
Revolution, a new beginning. America wakes up and decides to work together for a true cause.
New foundations are poured. Tax day tea partys were not party oriented. Tax day tea partys will surely result in common belief. Get out of our way Big Brother and let states and communiy flourish. We are the USA, sons, daughters of wars and humble starts. Get out of our way, you are fired! We worked all through your egoism and we will now tear you down to bring the Constitution and the work of so many back to be a USA!
Posted by Eugene W Knerr on Thu 16 Apr 2009 at 03:27 AM
please fund for me a writing course, am too old to achieve a degree, it would be so very proper to have a fathers son have one published article on stupidity of our elected officials
i am honest and report what i see, history is just that, there is a choice to be a enabler? or a true patriot?
matters not, you cannot fire me for my opinion!
Posted by Eugene W Knerr on Thu 16 Apr 2009 at 03:35 AM
what is the history of journalism? some gossip column in the 15th century while men were at war? what is the history of a clown, is it a court jester? what is journalism history if not well written like the longest history that is challenged still today? the Bible is still and will always be the longest history, many chapters and written at first by who? Am not an egoist by any means, the desire is to seek truth in word. Not sensationalism! If Jesus sat next to you just now, would you ask Jesus for his story or listen and tell everyone that Jesus is true? A matter of choice surely, sensationalism or bringing Jesus into many lives? I beleive in Jesus and am a Christian, in no way do I wish to offend. I do wish to be with Jesus one day!
Posted by Eugene W Knerr on Thu 16 Apr 2009 at 04:04 AM
if you try to reach this author it will be denied, why is that Paul?
egoism 101?
Posted by Eugene W Knerr on Thu 16 Apr 2009 at 04:10 AM