Subscribe Today

Campaign Desk

Announcing Last Night’s Rashomon Awards

Today’s Oscar announcement? It’s got nothing on the ‘Demmys’

By Megan Garber Tue 22 Jan 2008 12:14 PM 

And the winners are…

Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama! The candidates swept the Distracting Sideshow category of last night’s CNN/Congressional Black Caucus Institute debate, winning for their co-starring roles in the short political docu-dramedy Reagan: The Man, The Myth, The Metaphor.

Go ahead and take a minute to applaud them.

The winning act came during one of the debate performance’s many Fight Scenes, when, at Clinton’s behest, the two senators were squabble-spinning Obama’s now-infamous line about the Reagan legacy—infamous largely because, as we noted yesterday, it’s been used out of context. Watch the film clip here, and here’s the script (emphasis ours):

Clinton:
The facts are that he has said in the last week that he really liked the ideas of the Republicans over the last 10 to 15 years, and we can give you the exact quote.
Obama:
What I said—and I will provide you with a quote—what I said was is that Ronald Reagan was a transformative political figure because he was able to get Democrats to vote against their economic interests to form a majority to push through their agenda, an agenda that I objected to.

Cut. And bravo! One line, sure, one documented quote—but two different characters, two different scripts, two different takes. Mr. Kurosawa, if not Dr. King, would be proud.

CJR

If you enjoy this kind of press criticism please consider a subscription to our magazine, Columbia Journalism Review—a deal via the Web site at $19.95.

To subscribe, to give CJR as a gift, to renew, or to check student and CJR in the Classroom rates, click here.

Subscribe Today
Post a comment




About the Author
Megan Garber is a staff writer at CJR.
Also by Megan Garber
Current Cover

July / August 08

Table of Contents Browse Back Issues Subscribe Crossing Lines Second Life More...
Campaign Email
Campaign Tools
The American Newsroom Series

The Associated Press. Miami, Florida. Photo by Sean Hemmerle. More...

Top Stories
  • Parting Thoughts: An Invitation

    Give us your thoughts on journalism’s state and its future

  • Opening Bell: Oil Slicks

    As prices soar, U.S. looks for scapegoats; UBS ready to roll over; Jimmy Cayne, pariah; Rachael Ray, jihadi; etc.

  • Mort Rosenblum on Dispatches

    New quarterly bucks industry trend, exudes smart idealism

  • Cut the Dividends!

    Newspaper companies fork over hundreds of millions a year—and for what?

  • Opening Bell: The Hours

    Americans are working fewer, but not by choice; cuts on Wall Street; jobless ranks swell; etc.

  • Wiring Journalism 2.0

    Brad Stenger on the intersection of the press and computer science

  • Opening Bell

    In CJR's a.m. guide to the business press: Grim tidings on housing; WP says a veto threatened on bailouts; 50 bank failures? etc. etc.

  • The Opening Bell

    Pause in the panic; the Times on useless insurance; more bad news for a fallen titan, etc.

Recent Comments