The Observatory
-
November 28, 2012 03:30 PM
Dull news from Doha
UN climate summit a ho-hum affair for the press
The United Nations climate-change summit that began in Doha, Qatar, on Monday has so far been a ho-hum affair for the press.
Most American news outlets didn’t even bother to send a correspondent, reflecting a general decline in attendance at the annual meeting by North American and European journalists. Coverage may pick up as the two-week confab wears on, but...
Continue reading -
November 20, 2012 12:15 PM
Highway to the danger zone
Following Sandy, HuffPo and NYT dig into the folly of coastal development
Hurricane Sandy renewed the media’s interest in the many foolish ways that we increase our vulnerability to extreme weather. There’s climate change, of course. That came up right away.
But carbon pollution isn’t the only, or even the most immediate, thing that we’re doing to imperil ourselves. There’s also relentless, right-up-to-the-water’s-edge-in-a-floodplain coastal development.
After focusing on global warming in the...
Continue reading -
November 16, 2012 11:00 AM
Climate roller coaster back on track
With Obama talking global warming, media see ups and downs
At his first post-election press conference on Wednesday, President Obama talked about his current position on climate change in greater detail than he’s done in two years. News outlets’ attempts to interpret the meaning of his remarks produced bewilderingly disparate takes, however, whether that involved Obama’s personal commitment to addressing the issue:
“Obama vows to take personal charge...
Continue reading -
November 15, 2012 03:30 PM
What’s the MATTER?
A Kickstarter-funded longform narrative science journalism site launches
MATTER, a Kickstarter-funded longform science journalism project, launched on Wednesday with its first article, written by prominent science writer Anil Ananthaswamy. Just shy of 7,800 words, it tells the story of a man, "David," and his struggle with Body Integrity Identity Disorder. Basically, David desperately wants to cut one of his legs off. He's helped on his quest by a...
Continue reading -
November 14, 2012 12:00 PM
Salazar threatens to ‘punch out’ reporter
Interior Secretary angered by tough questions at Obama campaign event
Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar threatened to “punch out” a journalist for having the temerity to ask him questions about public policy at an Election-Day event in Colorado last week.
Salazar was at an Obama campaign office in Fountain, CO, as part of a tour through the state to support the president and encourage voter turnout. Dave Philipps, a...
Continue reading -
November 12, 2012 03:00 PM
Take a beat
Media pump too much news from heart association meeting, critic says
More than 10,000 stories came out of the annual meeting of the American Heart Association (AHA), which took place in Los Angeles last week, but it was the media’s ticker that was beating too fast and too hard, according to the media criticism website HealthNewsReview.org.
The cardiac confab is always a big draw for journalists, and as with other scientific...
Continue reading -
November 8, 2012 03:00 PM
Obama and the environment
Media react to the election with speculation, some insights
Journalists didn’t leave energy and the environment out of post-election speculation about what President Obama’s second term might look like.
A lot of the commentary was a recitation of the ups and downs of Obama’s record during the first four years—from tightening vehicle fuel-efficiency standards to dropping a plan to reduce smog—and prognosticating about what the next four years could...
Continue reading -
November 6, 2012 11:00 AM
Lemmings like us
Businessweek’s climate-change broadside is powerful, but ignores the allure of waterfront property
Hurricane Sandy finally got the media talking about climate change last week, but Bloomberg Businessweek spoke the loudest with a bold, red cover that featured a picture of a flooded New York City street and the words, “It’s Global Warming, Stupid,” in big, black letters above it.
As the cyclone spun up the eastern seaboard, I warned against making overstatements...
Continue reading -
November 1, 2012 01:00 PM
Bad hippie!
Is it wrong to ‘scold’ exaggerations about climate and weather?
David Roberts has a long essay over at Grist complaining about "scolds" (The New York Times’s Andrew Revkin, in particular) who criticize others for making too much of the link between climate change and extreme weather events like Hurricane Sandy.
Roberts’s commentary jumps off from a self-reflective post by Revkin about whether he is guilty of what one of his...
Continue reading -
October 30, 2012 04:15 PM
Sandy’s climate context
Why generalizing about extreme weather helps no one
It should come as no surprise that as Hurricane Sandy spiraled up the eastern seaboard, a variety of media outlets sought to explain the so-called super storm’s relationship to climate change. A few did well, but generalizations about extreme weather continue to mar this type of coverage.
Take Rebecca Leber’s attempt to bash the press for ignoring climate change at...
Continue reading -
October 29, 2012 06:50 AM
Jenny McCarthy as a Sun-Times columnist?
Science writers are skeptical, though McCarthy won't promote a fake link between vaccines and autism there
In her column, Minority Reports, Jennifer Vanasco analyzes how the mainstream media covers social minorities.
The Chicago Sun-Times created controversy this month by hiring Jenny McCarthy—an actress-model, author, and activist who promotes the discredited idea that vaccines cause autism—to blog online five days a week and write a weekly print advice column about sex, love, dating, and parenting. (The USA...
Continue reading -
October 25, 2012 05:15 PM
Junkets masquerading as prizes
To avoid conflicts of interest, read the fine print
With dwindling support for travel in most newsrooms, journalists may be tempted to apply for one of the many prizes or programs that offer the chance to get out of the office and visit a new destination—but buyer beware.
The Knight Science Journalism Tracker’s Paul Raeburn wrote a series of three posts about the risks associated with some of these...
Continue reading -
October 24, 2012 11:00 AM
Ask Obama and Romney this: What about climate change?
Schieffer misses media’s last chance to pop the question on a big stage
Over the final days of the campaign, CJR is running a series of pieces under the headline “Ask Obama This” and “Ask Romney This,” suggesting themes and questions that reporters and pundits can put to the presidential candidates. Previous installments have posed questions about a short-term plan for the jobs crisis; about housing; and about the Middle East, China, and...
Continue reading -
October 23, 2012 11:00 AM
Debunking the ‘war on coal,’ take two
The AP gets it right the second time around
If at first you don’t succeed, try, try again. Such was The Associated Press’s approach this month to explaining the so-called ‘war on coal’ that conservative spin doctors have been peddling throughout the presidential campaign.
An October 15 article by Donna Cassata failed miserably, recycling the narrative that environmental regulations under the Obama administration are the reason for recent turmoil...
Continue reading
Science Picture of the Day
NASA/JPL-Caltech/University of Arizona
The media went "nuts" over the first images from NASA's Curiosity rover, which landed successfully in a Martian crater on August 6 following an eight-month journey through space. The one above, taken by the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter, which shows the rover descending by parachute toward the surface, became an "instant classic," the Knight Science Journalism Tracker observed.
Press coverage focused primarily on the jubilation surrounding the landing. Weighing one ton, Curiosity was NASA heaviest and most fully loaded rover yet and the touchdown employed a sophisticated new landing system. The incredible image from the reconnaissance orbiter clearly fed the media frenzy, though.
As The New York Times reported, "NASA followed up its picture-perfect landing of a plutonium-powered rover with a picture of the picture-perfect landing."
After touchdown, the Mini Cooper-sized rover beamed back its first color photo of the ancient crater in which it landed, as well as "a video showing the last 2.5 minutes of tis white-knuckle dive through the Martian atmosphere," according to The Associated Press. The images will undoubtedly continue to drive coverage as the rovers sets out to study the local geology and tries to determine if Mars could ever have supported life. For the avid shutterbugs, Wired produced a useful "Photo-Geek's Guide" to Curiosity's 17 cameras.
—advertisement—
About The Observatory RSS
The Observatory critiques science, environment, and medical journalism. Our goal is to encourage clarity, accuracy, and accountability in the coverage all things technical and complex.
The Observatory Blogroll
Science News Aggregators, Critics
- Knight Science Journalism Tracker
- EJToday
- Health News Review
- Yale Forum on Climate Change & the Media
- Sigma Xi's Science in the News
- Kaiser Health News
- Environmental Health News
- Embargo Watch
- The Great Beyond
Science Blog Communities
Science Journalism Organizations
Desks
The Audit Business
- Audit Notes: pyramid people, Disney and ABC, no USA Today paywall Roddy Boyd digs into a diet-shake pyramid scheme
- Hot air Rises Above on CNBC An anchor pins a minor dip in stocks on the TV appearance of a minor politician
The Observatory Science
- Dull news from Doha UN climate summit a ho-hum affair for the press
- Highway to the danger zone Following Sandy, HuffPo and NYT dig into the folly of coastal development
Campaign Desk Politics & Policy
- NBC News sets good example for Medicare reporting People perspective leads to clear explanation of impact of proposed changes
- In Pennsylvania, a niche site with wide reach PoliticsPA drives political conversation in Keystone State
