In their haste to curb bad speech, regulators could endanger all speech
Unless sex trafficking is something you have a specific interest in, you might not be familiar with a bill that was has been making its way through Congress, known as the Stop Enabling Sex Trafficking Act, or SESTA. The bill has already been approved by the House, and on Wednesday was overwhelmingly approved by the Senate, which means it is on its way to President Trump for approval, and if he signs it—which seems likely—SESTA will become law.
Why should you care? Because in the process of trying to combat sex trafficking, Congress could wind up endangering free speech. As CJR described in a piece on the law last year, when it was still going through the House, SESTA effectively weakens one of the key pillars of online speech: Namely, Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act of 1996. That’s the clause that gives platforms like Facebook and Google “safe harbor” for the user-generated content that appears on their platforms.
— Scott Thurm (@ScottThurm) March 22, 2018
In a nutshell, Section 230 is the reason that Facebook, Google, and Twitter can distribute your tweets or status updates or video clips without being held legally liable for everything contained in them. SESTA effectively removes that protection or safe harbor in the case of anything involving sex trafficking—which wouldn’t be a problem, except for the fact that by removing that protection, free-speech advocates say it weakens the entire edifice that is Section 230.
This isn’t happening in isolation. Section 230’s safe-harbor provisions are already under fire from Congress because of the belief that they insulate platforms like Facebook or YouTube from responsibility for other kinds of speech the government doesn’t like, including Russian troll campaigns, “fake news,” sexual harassment, neo-Nazi sentiments, and anything that falls into the large and growing bucket labeled “terrorism.”
And there's more coming. When I asked @MarkWarner yesterday what regulation Facebook should face, he specifically mentioned further changes to Sec. 230 — the law that defines @facebook as a platform instead of as a publisher https://t.co/E3FPNJRbsE
— Kasie Hunt (@kasie) March 22, 2018
The risk is that if Section 230’s protections for speech are weakened—as similar protections are being weakened in Europe in an attempt to stamp out fake news and hate speech—it will give everyone from trolls to governments license to go after all kinds of speech they dislike or disagree with, because online publishers could become liable for that content. And while Facebook and Google might have the resources to deal with that, lots of small publishers and services don’t.
As Senator Ron Wyden, one of the authors of Section 230, put it during debate over the bill on Wednesday: “In the absence of Section 230, the internet as we know it would shrivel. Only the platforms run by those with deep pockets, and an even deeper bench of lawyers, would be able to make it.” In other words, the bill’s relaxation of that safe harbor for speech could entrench the dominance that Facebook, Google, and other massive platforms already have.
Did the Times change a story because Facebook complained?
It might not have registered for most people trying to keep up with the maelstrom of news this week about the Facebook data leak—the one in which the shadowy, Trump-linked data company Cambridge Analytica got personal details on more than 50 million users—but a number of critics noticed one of the The New York Times‘s […]
Old Facebook got away with murder, New Facebook not so much
As the mushroom cloud continued to spread over the weekend from Friday evening’s nuclear blast—the news that Facebook provided personal data on more than 50 million users to a Trump-linked data company called Cambridge Analytica—one consistent theme amid the chaos was the increasingly defensive argument from senior Facebook executives that a) What happened wasn’t technically […]
Facebook admits connecting the world isn’t always a good thing
One of the defining tenets of Facebook’s corporate philosophy is to connect people around the world, both to each other and to issues that matter to them. Co-founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg has said the social network’s mission is “to give people the power to share and to make the world more open and connected.” […]
Anti-terrorism and hate-speech law catches musicians and students instead
One of the risks when governments try to curb what they see as offensive speech is that other kinds of speech are caught in the same net. One of the most recent examples comes from Spain, where a vague anti-terrorism law has been used to charge and even imprison musicians and other artists. In a new […]
Google offers olive branch to newspapers, YouTube relies on Wikipedia
Google is planning to highlight content from newspapers with paywalls for users who are paying subscribers, according to a report from Bloomberg on Tuesday, March 14. So when users search for articles on a topic, results from sites they subscribe to will show up higher than results from regular websites. Google also plans to share […]
Project Veritas catfished Twitter staffers. Was it illegal?
When the political-action group known as Project Veritas came out with hidden-camera videos of a number of Twitter employees talking about the company’s practices last year, one of the mysteries was how the organization—infamous for its supposed “investigative” pieces on groups like Planned Parenthood—managed to record the videos. According to Kashmir Hill, in a piece […]
Apple buys Texture, the ‘Netflix of magazines’
Apple announced on March 12 that it has acquired Texture for an undisclosed sum. Often called the “Netflix of magazines,” Texture gives readers access to over 200 popular magazines through its app and website for a single monthly fee. It was originally called Next Issue Media when it launched in 2012, and had raised $130 […]
EU expert group on fake news releases recommendations
The European Union released the final report from its High Level Expert Group on fake news, entitled “A Multi-Dimensional Approach to Disinformation,” on March 12. Several of the experts involved in fact-checking and tracking disinformation, including Claire Wardle of First Draft and Alexios Mantzarlis of the International Fact-Checking Network, summed up the main points of […]
Russian trolls used Facebook as it was designed, law prof says
Joshua Geltzer, executive director of Georgetown Law’s Institute for Constitutional Advocacy and Protection and former senior director for counterterrorism at the National Security Council, writes in Wired on March 11 that the Russian trolls who tried to manipulate the 2016 election didn’t abuse Facebook or Twitter, they simply used those platforms in the way that […]
Sociologist Zeynep Tufekci says YouTube is an engine for radicalization
Sociologist Zeynep Tufekci wrote in an essay published in The New York Times on March 10 about experiments she performed on YouTube during the 2016 election, where she noticed that no matter what kind of political content she searched for, the recommended videos were always more extreme and inflammatory, whether politically or socially. This is a vicious […]
Top Facebook ‘reporters’ include fake news creators, hyper-partisan sources
NewsWhip, an analytics company that measures social-media activity, looked at its data and came up with a list of news reporters who get the most engagement on Facebook in February, and number one was Ryan Shattuck, of the satirical news site The Onion. Number 2 was Jonah Urich, who works for a left-wing site called […]
WhatsApp blamed for spreading misinformation about vaccines in Brazil
Most of the attention around fake news has focused on Facebook and YouTube, but other apps and services can also play a role in spreading misinformation, as Wired points out in a March 9 piece on the use of Facebook-owned messaging app WhatsApp in Brazil. Use of the app is apparently complicating the country’s attempts […]
Russian trolls followed same social-media strategy as ISIS
Renee DiResta, a researcher with New Knowledge and a Mozilla fellow specializing in misinformation, argues that by using Facebook to spread fake news during the 2016 election, the “Russian troll factory” known as the Internet Research Agency was duplicating a strategy initially developed by ISIS, which used digital platforms and social-media methods to spread its […]
Italy’s new right-wing political star gives credit to Facebook
The Trump campaign’s use of Facebook to connect with right-wing supporters has been widely credited with helping them win the 2016 election (along with the activities of some Russian trolls) and now another conservative politician is thanking social media for his victory. Italy’s new political star, Matteo Salvini of the far-right Lega party, gave credit […]
Is a newspaper oligopoly better than a web duopoly?
Newspaper companies have gotten their wish: A bill introduced on March 7 by Democratic Senator David Cicilline (of Rhode Island) would give them an exemption from antitrust so they could seek collective remedies against Facebook and Google. News Media Alliance head David Chavern has been calling for this for some time: Chavern says the alliance is seeking changes […]