ABOUT THE SERIES
Welcome to The Investigators, an ongoing web-video series produced by the Center for Investigative Reporting highlighting incisive work—as it happens—by journalists around the world. The series features interviews with journalists, who share the stories behind their groundbreaking international investigations into human rights abuses, financial corruption, political malfeasance, environmental destruction and other abuses of power. Often these journalists work in dangerous circumstances, risking their lives to reveal stories that have far-reaching impact and are relevant to us all. The original series is available at the Center for Investigative Reporting’s Web site.
ABOUT CONTRAVIA
[UPDATE: On Link TV’s “Latin Pulse,” CIR’s Mark Schapiro talks to Morris via Skype about new developments with his television show, Contravia—including a recent scandal involving the Colombian secret service, which had been conducting systematic surveillance of Morris’ mail, movements, and computer communications for years, according to documents released in the Colombian Congress in March. Watch it here.]
Our first segment features Colombian journalists Hollman Morris and Juan Pablo Morris, who created a series on Colombian television that is unearthing the largely hidden history of the country’s long-running guerilla wars. The series, called Contravía, airs on Colombia’s third public channel and online at www.contravia.tv.
While the violent tactics of the left-wing guerilla movement, the FARC, have generated considerable press attention—most recently after the release of kidnapped former congresswoman Ingrid Betancourt and other hostages in July 2008—a major component of that violence, by right-wing paramilitary groups, has gone largely unreported. Founded some twenty years ago by landowners to combat the guerillas, the paramilitary groups have transformed into violent criminal enterprises financed through cocaine exports and kidnappings—much like the FARC itself. Over more than two decades, the paramilitary squads have been responsible for the deaths and disappearance of as many as 20,000 people, according to the National Movement of Victims of State Crimes, a human rights group established to protest paramilitary abuses.
The Morris brothers take their cameras deep into the Colombian countryside to probe into the disappearance of thousands of individuals kidnapped over the past decade, and track efforts to unearth their graves far from the cosmopolitan capital city of Bogotá or the eyes of the international or global press. “Our aim,” Juan Pablo told us, “is to reconstruct the memory of those atrocities…. Many of the people who followed the paramilitaries in the 1980s and 90s are running the country today.”
Contravia has uncovered links between paramilitary leaders and high officials in Colombian politics and finance. Thirty senators and representatives in the Colombian Congress have been imprisoned because of their ties to the paramilitary death squads; another sixty have been investigated. That’s a third of Colombia’s 268-member Congress, giving rise to a new term—‘para-politica’—to describe the ongoing crisis as one top politician after another is accused of complicity with the paramilitary squads. Most of those accused represent political parties that are part of the governing coalition led by President Alvaro Uribe.
Hollman Morris was given the Human Rights Defender Award by Human Rights Watch in 2007. He has been forced to leave Colombia several times for extended periods after the airing of Contravía revelations. The show does not receive commercial backing; subsidies come from the Open Society Institute, the European Union, and other international sources.
In February 2009, Colombia’s Minister of Defense, Juan Manuel Santos, accused Hollman Morris on national radio of being “close to the guerillas,” after he conducted several interviews with FARC hostages who were later released. Uribe himself denounced Morris to the national press, and implied he was a member of the “intellectual bloc” of the FARC.
Such accusations in Colombia can have fatal consequences. Death threats followed. Shortly thereafter, Morris defended himself from the government’s charges on one of Colombia’s most popular morning talk shows; Contravía filmed Morris’s part of the conversation with host Julio Sanchez and produced an English translation of the interview.
The government’s accusations prompted a protest by the Committee to Protect Journalists and Human Rights Watch, which claimed in a letter to President Uribe that there was no evidence for such a statement, which could lead to “serious threats” of violence, and “undermines … freedom of expression” in Colombia.
The Inter-American Human Rights Commission (IAHRC) of the Organization of American States issued a statement criticizing the Colombian government’s effort to vilify the journalists and link them to the guerillas. On March 23, attorneys for the Committee for Free Expression in Colombia and other free press advocates publicly challenged the Colombian government’s version of events, and described the potentially corrosive effects the personal attacks were having on the willingness of Colombian journalists to pursue controversial human rights stories.
Two days after that presentation, Juan Pablo Morris commented by phone from Bogotá that Contravía will continue to defy efforts by Uribe to “link journalists who question the government to ‘terrorists’.”
CIR Editorial Director Mark Schapiro interviewed Hollman and Juan Pablo Morris via Webcam at their studio in Bogotá.




Dear sir / madam,
When seeing you had published an item on Contravia on cjr.org I was very pleasantly surprised to see that Hollman Morris was receiving the credit he deserves for his incredible work. The man is a journalistic hero and deserves and needs the back up and respect of international journalists and news consumers. Reports like the one you did on Contravia is therefore very much appreciated.
However, I was very disappointed to see that while the voice-over said "While Colombian news outlets are often flooded with gruesome violence of the left wing guerrillas" a screenshot appeared of a Colombia Reports article about an attack by the FARC costing the live of six military officials. On the one hand I understand that the screenshot of this one article visually supports what the voice over is explaining and it's an honor for me to see Colombia Reports appear on your website. However I do wish to express my sadness that, of all Colombian or international media, you chose to use Colombia Reports as the example of Colombian news outlets and their one sided reporting on Colombia's conflict and the country's social and economic problems.
We at Colombia Reports, since its founding on February 9, 2008, have independently been striving to improve knowledge about Colombia's conflict. The website had and has the goal of improving the understanding of the complexity of the conflict because none of the mainstream English-language media were willing to cover the conflict in a balanced manner. From the beginning we have reported on paramilitary violence, the rebirth of the paramilitary groups, corruption, conflicts of interests of Colombian media, extrajudicial executions by the army and the impunity of crimes committed by paramilitary and state forces at a time when these topics were being ignored, not just by the Colombian, but also by U.S. and European media.
Colombia Reports, with the little manpower and resources it has, has supported independent bloggers, students, the Colombian Foundation for the Liberty of Press (FLIP) and most important of all, victims of violence who just wanted their story told.
The website was funded personally without any corporate help and grew from a simple weblog maintained by one Dutch journalist and a Colombian trainee to the biggest English-language news source on Colombia, despite competition from the Colombian mainstream outlets. We have maintained our independence and have, without one day of vacation and with hardly any money, reported on all sides of the Colombian story. More than 15 people are involved now, mostly voluntarily, but all with a passion for Colombia and a passion for honest reporting.
When taking a second look, I think you will agree that the particular article portrayed in your documentary had legitimate news value and was taken out of context in your item.
I am honored you were fooled into seeing our free, Joomla-based, 20-dollar-a-month website as an established media outlet, but you haven't seen us establish yet. I hope my colleges and I will at some point be able to seriously impress you.
Having said this, I wish you the very best with the work you are doing. I have great respect and appreciation for your magazine. Anytime we can be of assistance to you or you would like to be of assistance to what we do, please contact us.
Kind regards,
Adriaan Alsema
Editor-in-chief
Colombia Reports
Posted by Adriaan Alsema on Thu 11 Jun 2009 at 12:19 PM
Dear Editor — First of all, my apologies .....The writer is correct: the image flashed briefly on the screen in association with my description of media coverage of the FARC is drawn from the Colombia Report, which indeed is difficult to quantify as “mainstream media.” Our intent, frankly, was to have a quick image of a headline and picture evoking the FARC, and not an image evoking the “mainstream media.” I have read Colombia Report periodically, and found its original take on Colombia refreshing, but our intent was neither to highlight it nor any other particular publication. In this instance, the medium was not the message. In the rush of production, we looked for the image rather than the masthead. Our point was to offer an evokative image of the FARC to cover an important point of narration-- while attention is often lavished on violent abuses by the left-wing FARC, often for sound journalistic reasons, as the writer correctly points out, there is little corresponding coverage of abuses by their right-wing para-military counterparts. Addressing this imbalance lies at the heart of the Colombian television show Contravia’s reason for being.
On a related, highly relevant front: I just received word from Hollman Morris in Bogota that documents released yesterday in the Colombian Congress confirm that the country’s intelligence service, the DAS, has been conducting systematic surveillance of Morris’ mail, movements and computer communications for several years. This is part of a larger process at play in Colombia to demonize and marginalize independent journalists, human rights activists and attorneys who are determined to provide unbiased reports on the players, from all sides, in Colombia’s long-running civil war.
The revelations are described on Contravia’s Web site.
Posted by Mark Schapiro on Fri 12 Jun 2009 at 03:44 PM