As obituaries published today by major newspapers make clear, Edward Kennedy, the senior senator from Massachusetts who died of brain cancer last night, was a towering political presence, a savvy champion of liberal causes, and a personally flawed figure whose troubles played out on a public stage.
Liberal writers have penned heartfelt tributes, Democrats in Congress have vowed to push forward in his memory, and Republican politicians, with whom Kennedy often worked, have expressed sadness at his passing. But how has the conservative media—both long-established publications and the newer voices of the blogosphere—responded?
Silently, in a few cases. The Weekly Standard’s blog makes no mention of Kennedy’s passing; neither does Opinion Journal. But in the circles where Kennedy’s death is being treated as a big story, it’s handled in different ways. Michelle Malkin urges her readers to show restraint:
Put aside your ideological differences for an appropriate moment and mark this passing with solemnity.
There is a time and place for political analysis and criticism. Not now.
Yes, there will be a nauseating excess of MSM hagiographies and lionizations — and crass calls to pass the health care takeover to memorialize his death.
That’s no excuse to demonstrate the same lack of restraint in the other direction. Not now.
And at Powerline, Paul Mirengoff was outright charitable to the liberal lion:
With the passing of Sen. Edward Kennedy, we can expect the usual suspects — liberal talking heads, Senate colleagues and the like — to tell us how Kennedy was a giant of the Senate, among the most influential Senators of the 20th century, etc.
This time, the usual suspects will be right.
…A great many people thought Kennedy was on their side and the outpouring of sentiment we are starting to witness will, in part, be reflection of this fact.
Not everyone was so positive. At RedState, Erick Erickson relayed mentions that Kennedy was “very nice” the one time they met, but adds:
I can’t say that I’ll miss him. He, to me, represented all that is wrong with Washington — a kingdom of nepotism and worship at the altar of failed liberal policies that get repeated ad infinitum. He opposed school choice for the poor while segregating his kids from the poor in school. He supported policies opposed to life except when life could be advanced through the destruction of the unborn. He opposed a strong national security against even the evidence of its necessity during his brother’s Presidential administration.
Ted Kennedy supported the expansion of the welfare state and a culture of dependency on government, made all the more tragic given how ensnared his life was to dependency. He should have known better given his own life and that of his family.
And then there’s Mary Jo Kopechne. May she rest in peace.
Kopechne, of course, is the young aide who was killed in the accident at Chappaquiddick, and, in addition to Kennedy’s role in derailing the nomination of Robert Bork, she is one of the recurring themes in much of the conservative commentary. At American Thinker, Rick Moran suggests a fitting epitaph would be a line James Taranto first penned a few years ago, before Kennedy fell ill: “Mary Jo Kopechne could not be reached for comment.” And New Criterion editor Roger Kimball wastes no words in a Pajamas Media blog post calling Kennedy a ‘“liar, drunk, cheat, philanderer, and — let’s not forget — inadvertent murderer”:
The tsunami of sentimental pap about Kennedy is already churning, gushing, rushing to inundate the public with a nauseating and untruthful fairy tale about the “Lion of the Senate.” The Lyin’ in the Senate is more like it. Kennedy was 77 when he was taken off last night, Mary Jo Kopechne had just turned 29 when Kennedy’s car veered off the bridge in Chappaquiddick and he wriggled free and swam to shore, leaving the young woman trapped in the car to drown.
- 1
- 2
Thank you for making the first step. We live in a two party system, Republicans and Conservatives can your sources too, but the first step is understanding us.
I was respectful on my Blog. But if the hagiogrophy goes overboard, I will not hold back.
#1 Posted by JSF, CJR on Wed 26 Aug 2009 at 03:44 PM
My personal tribute: I set my VCR to record six hours of CNN's coverage.
On my way home from work tonight, I'm picking up a bottle of Jameson's.
My brother and I are going to replay the tape, and take shots every time we hear the word "lion."
#2 Posted by Hardrada, CJR on Wed 26 Aug 2009 at 06:11 PM
This post is about Edward M. Kennedy
The Book ov Lev It A Kiss was inspired in 1969, when the author was on a ship, 40 days and 40 nights. It was not the author's idea that he would be given "words for all man kind," a Television Scripture to recite, to use as a base sewto create a twelve "our" video trans crypt, in a live performance from dusk until dawn, on whirled wide television, with every line a delicate sensible rhyme, for all the world's peoples to participate in all at once.
That was and is the michael stephen levinson plan. Here is a column from The Book ov Lev. It begins with reference to "Sirhan Bishra Sirhan / The ass ass in be gan / As a gjenteel man" (but those three lines are at the bottom of the column leading into what I have copied here.)
In this lan duv
Male or dur guns
Wor ship no idols
They shall be smote down.
Frum a soft asst sel
The smirk in for in er
Smirks at us all
Liv in bed er then moes
He God a cough e pot
Ina pre vert id guard
Call it a filmd e vent
Dis poze uv him ina
Pair a shoot on the Nile.
Ov the girl Kopechne
Who died at Mar thuz
Vin yurd
Let the ded lie buried
Lie down on er grave
Those who wud or
Dur her grave dug
Wud dig ov thoze
Who ar God's own
Her soul is in ter red
Adman will clean air
In free her she was good
Ov the rest uv the
Ken E de die nasty
Joe syph the hate er
Made a rose draw blood
The luv er uv Hit ler
Died ina bed spoon fed
Lee Oswald was
A co in se dense
Wut a man dont no
Duz in hurt im
"Adman will clean air in free her she was good."
What happened in the car when Kennedy lost control on the bridge and the car went over the side into the water?
He put her hand on his pants, and it got crowded inside. He said, "Take it out." She unzipped his trousers. She was a good Catholic girl. She worshipped the Kennedys! She took one look and the 28 year old virgin went down on him.
Had Teddy not been drinking maybe none of this would have happened. He was an Irish guy with at least three drinks under his belt. He immediately popped his nuts and lost control of the car. Had it been a hand job he would have made it over the bridge.
That is what happened. The Kennedy family fought exhuming her grave to conduct an autopsy because they would have found (Ted's) seminal salt in her throat. That is what the Lev (michael stephen levinson) was going to recite - tell the world, as it was written - Adman will clean air In free her she was good - during his world wide broadcast, which Lev expected to accomplish in 1972, at 2:00 a.m. in the morning, after retelling the story of Adman and Even in the Gar Den ov Edum, and the Creation being how G-d created Adman in His image, and tracing all the generations of men, settling up with the Russians to bring an end to the Cold War, and so much more.
Lev was going to tell what happened to Kennedy that night in the car.
Levinson also talked about this to grad stew dense (dent is the singular) he trusted and amongst those students were f be eye people who passed this information on to j. edgarina, the cross dressing fascist pervert of dirt, who was outraged. Hoover made Michael Stephen Levinson a person of 'Special' interest and to this day f b i interferes with his life.
The man was on a ship 40 days and 40 nights in 1969 and this is all news to you. He has an innovative solution for every prob limb facing our nation and you know nothing about this man.
One likes to imagine the world would be interested in a creative man who created a work of prophetic art expressly for all
#3 Posted by Michael Stephen Levinson, CJR on Wed 26 Aug 2009 at 07:44 PM
This post is about Edward M. Kennedy
The Book ov Lev It A Kiss was inspired in 1969, when the author was on a ship, 40 days and 40 nights. It was not the author's idea that he would be given "words for all man kind," a Television Scripture to recite, to use as a base sewto create a twelve "our" video trans crypt, in a live performance from dusk until dawn, on whirled wide television, with every line a delicate sensible rhyme, for all the world's peoples to participate in all at once.
That was and is the michael stephen levinson plan. Here is a column from The Book ov Lev. It begins with reference to "Sirhan Bishra Sirhan / The ass ass in be gan / As a gjenteel man" (but those three lines are at the bottom of the column leading into what I have copied here.)
In this lan duv
Male or dur guns
Wor ship no idols
They shall be smote down.
Frum a soft asst sel
The smirk in for in er
Smirks at us all
Liv in bed er then moes
He God a cough e pot
Ina pre vert id guard
Call it a filmd e vent
Pair a shoot on the Nile.
Ov the girl Kopechne
Who died at Mar thuz
Vin yurd
Let the ded lie buried
Lie down on er grave
Those who wud or
Dur her grave dug
Wud dig ov thoze
Who ar God's own
Her soul is in ter red
Adman will clean air
In free her she was good
Ov the rest uv the
Ken E de die nasty
Joe syph the hate er
Made a rose draw blood
The luv er uv Hit ler
Died ina bed spoon fed
Lee Oswald was
A co in se dense
Wut a man dont no
Duz in hurt im
"Adman will clean air in free her she was good."
What happened in the car when Kennedy lost control on the bridge and the car went over the side into the water?
He put her hand on his pants, and it got crowded inside. He said, "Take it out." She unzipped his trousers. She was a good Catholic girl. She worshipped the Kennedys! She took one look and the 28 year old virgin went down on him.
Had Teddy not been drinking maybe none of this would have happened. He was an Irish guy with at least three drinks under his belt. He immediately popped his nuts and lost control of the car. Had it been a hand job he would have made it over the bridge.
That is what happened. The Kennedy family fought exhuming her grave to conduct an autopsy because they would have found (Ted's) seminal salt in her throat. That is what the Lev (michael stephen levinson) was going to recite - tell the world, as it was written - Adman will clean air In free her she was good - during his world wide broadcast, which Lev expected to accomplish in 1972, at 2:00 a.m. in the morning, after retelling the story of Adman and Even in the Gar Den ov Edum, and the Creation being how G-d created Adman in His image, and tracing all the generations of men, settling up with the Russians to bring an end to the Cold War, and so much more.
Lev was going to tell what happened to Kennedy that night in the car.
Levinson also talked about this to grad stew dense (dent is the singular) he trusted and amongst those students were f be eye people who passed this information on to j. edgarina, the cross dressing fascist pervert of dirt, who was outraged. Hoover made Michael Stephen Levinson a person of 'Special' interest and to this day f b i interferes with his life.
The man was on a ship 40 days and 40 nights in 1969 and this is all news to you. He has an innovative solution for every prob limb facing our nation and you know nothing about this man.
One likes to imagine the world would be interested in a creative man who created a work of prophetic art expressly for all man kind, a work of art that could initiate World P
#4 Posted by michael Stephen Levinson, CJR on Wed 26 Aug 2009 at 07:53 PM
The column was a good idea, and fairly handled. It should be added that the conservative blogosphere has been sorely provoked by the worshipful 'mainstream media' coverage of Kennedy's career.
The recurring problem of these news outlets being located in overwhelmingly 'blue' states and precincts, so that urban liberalism of the sort that still adores the Kennedys (I used to live in NYC, and was amazed at how Moonie-like were otherwise sophisticated people at the Kennedy family narrative) is in the air that they breathe. It comes through at moments such as this, greatly distorting the degree to which Kennedy was popular and influential outside the rank and file of the Democratic Party.
Many reports make a big deal of Ted Kennedy's endorsement of Obama in last year's Democratic primaries, without remembering that Obama lost the Massachusetts primary - yes, in Kennedy's own state - which followed. This and other events (the fiasco of Caroline Kennedy seeking a Senate seat in true-blue New York a few months ago) remind us that, while Kennedy-family stories are good tabloid fodder, the politics of the Kennedy family have long been under very critical scrutiny by centrist voters. To misinterpret public interest in the family's story as support for their rather 'right-wing lifestyles for me, left-wing social programs for the masses' political ideology is poor analysis.
Not even Ronald Reagan among 'conservative' heroes was given such hagiographic treatment by our politically 'objective' MSM at his death; even comments about his popularity were always qualified by some convenient pundit, though Reagan was far more popular than Edward Kennedy. Sometimes the exasperated conservative blogosphere have to constitute the go-to information sites when the mainstream media goes into one of its orgies of liberal hero worship.
#5 Posted by Mark Richard, CJR on Thu 27 Aug 2009 at 12:40 PM
Mark, do those claws ever retract?
#6 Posted by Hardrada, CJR on Thu 27 Aug 2009 at 03:11 PM
(Lol) Hardrada, I always think I'm being the voice of sweet reason . . . you mean, I'm not?
#7 Posted by Mark Richard, CJR on Fri 28 Aug 2009 at 12:09 PM