First Day
It is 10:40 on a sunny and warm Saturday morning, and time for my walk through Gaza. I take a break from people’s chattering and from traffic noise and listen to my iPod. The streets are crowded, as they always are on the first day of the week. Despite the embargo, students, salesmen, taxi drivers, police—all have things to do. I am always fascinated by the human will to go on with life despite the absence of what most people understand as normal circumstances.
I listen to Cat Stevens’s “Wild World” and smile, knowing that my friend, Smadar Perry, will soon be listening to the same tune. Smadar is a journalist at Yediot Ahronot, the Tel Aviv-based daily. She called on Friday, asking for my favorite song, because she was to be a guest at 11 a.m. on a radio station there and wanted to talk to her listeners about our friendship, and to play the music. But at a traffic light I switch to Mamma Mia!—a soundtrack for a faster and more determined pace. At 11:15 a.m., Israeli bombs begin falling, close by; bombardment is suddenly the new norm.
For a second I am frozen, then ask loudly: “Where are they bombing?” Nobody knows. And nobody knows which building will be hit next. I ask a couple, “Is there any Hamas leader living in this building?” “No!,” they reply. I run toward a cloud of smoke. One-way streets become two-way; parents run into schools to collect their kids. I jump into a taxi that is headed toward the main hospital, and ask the driver why he is going in that direction when everyone else is heading the other way. His son is a policeman, he explains. He wants to see if he is okay. “Israel is launching a war against Hamas—do you blame Hamas?” I ask him. The driver’s answer is to begin to sob.
The moment I step out of the car, something hits my head: it is the body of a policeman being carried by two men toward the emergency room. His legs are deeply cut. Another car stops with two more policemen, both missing their legs. I run to the emergency room but am blocked by what seems like dozens of bodies on the floor near the entrance—brains out, legs gone, no signs of life—all in civil police uniforms. In the corner I see a policeman who is injured but alive, and step over bodies to reach him. Several Hamas security members rise up, shouting at me to get out. I say, “You have a job to do and I have a job, too.” They leave me alone.
I’m lucky that I passed by that police station before it was bombed, I tell myself. I’m lucky, too, that I didn’t arrange to meet with the head of the police that day, since I am staring at his body. I head to the morgue, where more than a hundred bodies are laid out—I see an infant and a dead child in a school uniform—and where families are coming to search for loved ones. At these moments, you don’t want to ask questions; you just observe and write down the words that come from people’s mouths.
I had observed the First Intifada, covered the Second Intifada, and covered the internal conflict between Hamas and Fatah, but this is different. I find my driver and make sure he has enough fuel to help me cover the war.
People want to talk. There are those who support Hamas, and those who do not. There are others who monitor what people say. I need to be quick and patient and respectful. The story is all around me.
Israel did not let any international journalists into Gaza, so I feel the weight of responsibility, the need to explain to the world what is happening. And that is one of several kinds of pressure: I want to maintain my credibility, so I work hard not to exclude any element of the story. I deal with Hamas watchers and fighters, which I know how to do. I feel the pressure of possible death from Israeli drones, F16s, helicopters, and tanks.

What happened Taghreed to your reporting ? when you write in NY times you sound like a Zionist and write like Zionist but here you sound bit like somebody who repented and wants to "correct" your horrible reporting from Gaza
#1 Posted by Elmashkalgee, CJR on Fri 22 May 2009 at 12:05 PM
I was going to ask the same question asked by Elmashkalgee any Article by You on NYtimes , and you would visualize a zionist who is writing and certainly not a palestinian . Now I can see and read about compassion for the samouni family wow . thats a change . keep it up , principles are worth a lot more than dollars
#2 Posted by leyla, CJR on Fri 22 May 2009 at 12:41 PM
Taghreed to be honest, your a disgrace, you sell your own people to keep ur job at the NY times and report in the way they have decided for you in that website. I dont care if you have to report in that way to keep ur job, a person with dignity wouldnt do it for all the money in the world. I dont believe you are honest in ur reporting, you make up things, that is what i believe and since u work for a zionist paper, that is expected and you wouldnt have had that job in the first place if your not willing to make up things. I hope everyone in Gaza knows who you are and who you work for so they wont be fooled by you when you ask them for a statement that you will write down in the way you feel will please ur zionist master. Shame on you. Perhaps the zionists are happy with you, but the Palestinians see you as a traitor and you know deep down they are right. By the way, all the collaborators that were killed deserved it, perhaps you consider it a crime when the US executes criminals as well? No? why so? is it because its not the opinion of the NY Times? Assisting terrorist zionists is not a crime according to you, instead u want the collaborators to be praised, never mind that they participated in the massacres by assisting the zionists! Your a disgrace and an unproffessional journalist. You sold the truth in order to keep a job at a zionist website. You must feel so proud of yourself. One day you will feel ashamed of urself when u realize how u were just a pawn for the zionists, u will wish you could remove all the zionist propaganda you wrote down for the NY times. By the way, Dont go to scenes of massacres if you cant handle the smell of massacres, how disrespectful of you to go them and say you want to puke in front of the survivors of a massacre. Nobody invited you in the first place. And a girl just happened to tell you out of nowhere that she is loosing faith in God right? In the middle of the chaos she just happened to see you and yell out: Taghreed, i have lost my faith in God. Lol yeah right. Poor taghreed, you sold your soul to the zionist devil in order to recieve ur 15 minutes of fame as a "moderate arab", in order words, a pawn for zionism that will be used and then thrown away just like the collaborators in Lebanon. Where is the Mossad to help them now? Zionists use people like u for their benefit and then when they cant squeeze out more of you they throw you away.
#3 Posted by Bella, CJR on Fri 22 May 2009 at 02:08 PM
guys i totally agree with you..everyone who is clear headed have noticed how the reporting and the writing have changed..i don't know if you should blame taghreed..or blame NYT...taghreed tells people what they want to hear...her writing is different for different audience,,to be a NYt reporter one should pay a price...right?
#4 Posted by humam, CJR on Fri 22 May 2009 at 09:51 PM
Sadly not one comment in support of Thagreed. I wonder if she will read these comments and get the message. I do want to point out that there are many phonies writing in the arabic media for masters that require particular and biased viewpoints. We call that propaganda not journalism which has been dead a long time. Thagreed is not the disease, she is a symptom. Bottom line is she is no better than the non arab writers who write about the middle east. The truth is whatever the paymaster says it is. Sleep well Taghreed.
#5 Posted by Thomas, CJR on Fri 22 May 2009 at 11:23 PM
I don't see much different from her slovenly NYT stuff:
"There are moments of fear, when I file; for a few seconds, I think, What if Israel does not like what I say?"
History will be a swift and cruel judge of this shameful work.
It has nothing to do with 'supporting your people' - though I suspect you'll rightly be reckoning with that in time, too - it is a simple matter of professionalism. To care about what a state will say about your work is pathetic; that you feel primary concern literally in the midst of a massacre is unforgivable.
Your professionalism is the type that is similarly afraid of what the Apartheid regime would say about a report on Sharpeville, what the Irgun would say about a report from Deir Yassin, what the Phalange would say about a story from inside Sabra or Shatilla... history will be unkind to you, indeed. That your wilful omissions and ignorant or criminal mis-characterizations are archived in the newspaper of record only assures your name will not be lost to history, unlike your colleagues.
Good luck to you.
#6 Posted by Todd, CJR on Sat 23 May 2009 at 01:33 AM
These are ridiculously spiteful comments from people who, I assume, were nowhere near Gaza during the bombardment, let alone risking their lives to report what they saw. Judging by their shock that a personal diary should sound different to a published report, which is chewed over by several editors and combined with other reporters' filings, they probably have never worked in an actual newsroom either.
As for the Samouni family, a quick search on NYT brings up a story with Taghreed's byline from January 9, which struck me as more than sympathetic.
#7 Posted by Roger, CJR on Sat 23 May 2009 at 06:42 AM
People need to calm down here a bit.
First, you can't compare this article with the author's reporting in the NY Times. The stories she files in the NYT are reporting; it's her investigating the facts and making them known to the world. Professionalism and objectivity are the name of the game.
This article here, on the other hand, is a candid and honest story about how she conducts her work - hence the more obviously personal tone, the feelings and emotions that seep through the words. It's actually a rather unique take on the war journalism profession, especially when the war happens in your own home.
If you want to read propaganda, there's plenty of that floating around the Internet. All those seeking to confirm the opinions they already have, and indulge in a pat-on-the-back that "I'm right and everyone else is wrong" - you're in the wrong place.
If you wish to know what professional journalism is, then Taghreed El-Khodary's examplary coverage of the war on Gaza is for you. Like it or not, this is what real journalism is about. And we should be grateful that there's someone as good as her to tell the story. To tell it to us, and to the rest of the world.
Oh, and Bella - a decomposing body is a seriously disgusting smell. Shaheed or no shaheed, it's all decomposing flesh.
You simply have no idea what you're talking about.
#8 Posted by Mo-ha-med, CJR on Sat 23 May 2009 at 08:17 AM
The Angry Arab does a fairly good job explaining what is offensive about Taghreed's reporting in the NYT---
Link
#9 Posted by Donald, CJR on Sat 23 May 2009 at 12:52 PM
I've lived and worked in Gaza, my spite comes from rage. And the spite is not based on one story, either; it's has been almost a decade of shame from her.
#10 Posted by Todd, CJR on Sat 23 May 2009 at 02:59 PM
Todd: I appreciate you have lived and worked in Gaza, but as a journalist? If so, I would be interested to see what I assume history WILL be kind to...
#11 Posted by Roger, CJR on Sat 23 May 2009 at 04:56 PM
Thank you, Taghreed, for your courage and discrimination in this most difficult of jobs.
#12 Posted by Eric S., CJR on Sat 23 May 2009 at 05:15 PM
Taghreed is one of the most remarkable people I've ever had the privilege to meet. I can't imagine the personal risk she takes daily to report on a war-torn region that is so severely under-covered. She stays in her homeland to share its story with the world.
When I read comments bashing her like those at the start of this thread, it makes me question the wisdom of legitimate sites allowing anonymous comments.
Please stay safe, my friend, and keep up the important work you're doing.
#13 Posted by Chris Cobler, CJR on Sun 24 May 2009 at 02:01 PM
This lady is courageously doing her work in Gaza.
As we say in France : "if you report on the israli-palestinian conflict and you get insulted by both Isralis and Palestinians, you should not worry : you're doing your job as a journalist".
#14 Posted by Carine, CJR on Fri 29 May 2009 at 08:23 AM
Until she speaks out against the Islamic fascism imposed by Hamas and other terrorist groups that control Palestinian lives, nothing will change.
#15 Posted by Craig, CJR on Sat 13 Jun 2009 at 04:05 AM