Join us
 

If Objectivity Is Dead, Should Journalists Care?

A path through journalism’s endless debate.

November 19, 2026

Sign up for the daily CJR newsletter.

“No term has created more confusion in journalism than objectivity,” Tom Rosenstiel writes in The Next Journalism, his recent book. It has caused civil wars in newsrooms and endless debate among journalists. In today’s hyper-partisan media environment, objectivity as a journalistic value may feel especially rare and anachronistic. Is it time for journalists to ditch the term entirely?

In this episode of Journalism 2050, Rosenstiel joins cohosts Emily Bell, Heather Chaplin, and Samuel Earle to discuss how journalists should approach their work when platforms decide how news reaches audiences, tech oligarchs pump unprecedented sums into politics, and AI chatbots recast information that is often harvested from news websites without their permission.

Rosenstiel argues that disparate views on the concept of objectivity conceal greater agreement about journalism’s purpose—whether among traditional reporters or news creators. As he puts it: “The essence of good journalism is open-minded inquiry grounded in the discipline of verification.”

Credits:

Producer: Sarah Myles

Research: Samuel Earle

Production assistant: Hana Joy

Art: Katie Kosma

Music: Henry Crooks

Has America ever needed a media defender more than now? Help us by joining CJR today.

Emily Bell is a frequent CJR contributor and the director of Columbia’s Tow Center for Digital Journalism. Previously, she oversaw digital publishing at The Guardian.
Heather Chaplin is the founding director of the Journalism + Design program at The New School.

More from CJR