In a recent column for The Washington Post, Richard Cohen recounted how FDR cried when he learned that children living in migrant worker camps had no toys for Christmas. “Don’t tell me any more, Helen,” he said to Helen Gahagan Douglas—who, political junkies will remember, later lost a nasty Senate race to Richard Nixon. Roosevelt, the patrician, could connect to the less fortunate. Could Obama, Cohen asks? When the stock market fell by more than 500 points in August, the image that night was of the president whooping it up at his birthday party. “He does not seem to care,” Cohen concludes.
Yale professor emeritus Ted Marmor and Yale law professor Jerry Mashaw made similar points in a New York Times op-ed a couple weeks ago. They drew a distinction between the language Roosevelt used to talk about the country’s severe economic distress and the words the president uses to talk about such distress today. Roosevelt told Congress that he placed “the security of the men, and women and children of the nation first.” They “want decent homes to live in; they want to locate them where they can engage in productive work; and they want some safeguard against misfortunes which cannot be wholly eliminated in this man-made world of ours.”
Contrast FDR’s words with Obama’s language when he appointed his fiscal commission. Marmor and Mashaw wrote that Obama said the commission’s task was “to improve the fiscal situation” “to achieve fiscal sustainability over the long run” and to address “the growth of entitlement spending.” What exactly did those words convey to men and women on the street?
Wanting some empirical evidence of whether the president was speaking to ordinary people, I walked the streets of Lincoln, Nebraska, asking those I met if Obama was listening to their concerns. Was he connecting to them? The general consensus was that he was not. I had hardly had asked my question when Le Ann Goebel, a sixty-nine-year old filling her grocery cart at a Hy-Vee Supermarket, shouted no. “I have no love for Obama; he’s all talk and no go. I don’t listen to him. He’s nothing but campaigning for himself,” she said. Goebel, who worked in a high school kitchen, was concerned both for herself and for the country. “The job situation has to change,” she told me, and then talked about her own worries. “Medicare and Social Security are the main topics here,” Goebel said. “They are cutting down Medicare and that means our insurance company will have to pick up more and our supplements will go up.”
Her Medigap policies from Mutual of Omaha cost about $400 a month for her and her husband. She knew she had a supplement called Plan F, and that the health law had mandated higher amounts of cost-sharing for that policy. That meant that she might have to pay more down the road, and she was not pleased. As for Social Security, she worried that her children, now in their late forties, wouldn’t get it.
Another shopper, Angela Schiltz, a twenty-five-year-old single mom with a sixteen-month-old baby, worries about jobs and completing a community college program so she can become a medical lab technician. The average pay, she said, would be about $19 an hour when she started out, but it would be steady work with health insurance. “I am a working single mother trying to make things better for me,” she said. Earlier this year she lost her job at a medical software design company, but quickly found other employment at a call center. It pays only $8.75 an hour for fifteen hours of work, instead of the $11 she was earning at the old job. Money is tight; she has no cable TV channels, but buys the newspapers a few days a week “to stay in the loop.”
who cares what these people think? aren't these the same Americans who bought Taylor Swift's albums and watched Dear John in theaters? there are plenty of valid criticisms of Obama, but whether he is connecting with hoi polloi is the least of my concerns.
#1 Posted by Hardrada, CJR on Thu 6 Oct 2011 at 03:19 PM
there are plenty of valid criticisms of Obama, but whether he is connecting with hoi polloi is the least of my concerns.
And thats precisely why he's going to get CREAMED in the general election. After all, us "hoi polloi", flyover folks and bitter clingers vote, and you cant muscle us with white liberal guilt again.
#2 Posted by Mike H, CJR on Thu 6 Oct 2011 at 05:39 PM
Well good for you Mike, but I'm more concerned about whether our president is doing the right thing than whether he's popular or not.
Tattoo artist Cody Schneider admits he's "uneducated and unreached." That's great; maybe if that's the case, he should, y'know, not vote.
#3 Posted by Hardrada, CJR on Thu 6 Oct 2011 at 11:27 PM
“They can’t find any records from school; he’s refused to release a birth certificate,” sez 82-year-old knuckle-draggin' mouth-breather Homer Puderbaugh.
I hope you're proud, Mike.
#4 Posted by Hardrada, CJR on Thu 6 Oct 2011 at 11:29 PM
I'm more concerned about whether our president is doing the right thing than whether he's popular or not
Unfortunately for the unwashed proles in the little speck of land between LA and New York, commonly refered to around here as America, he is neither popular nor doing the right thing.
#5 Posted by Mike H, CJR on Thu 6 Oct 2011 at 11:32 PM
The info here would be more meaningful if you knew how many of these people actually voted and voted for President Obama.
I live in Texas and I know no one who voted for him who is UNhappy with him. They believe he is making progress in very difficult circumstances.
Those who did not vote for him never connected with him and never will. Those who are not paying attention only know the narrative of headlines. Headlines written/spoken to attract attention of most readers/watchers and attention is given to negatives and conflict so those are the headlines.
#6 Posted by JDS, CJR on Fri 7 Oct 2011 at 11:04 AM
If you ask me, the real reason Obama lacks connection is because he continually tries to be the man of no sides, the man who stands above the fray and "shakes it off" while brushing his shoulders while idiots accuse him of being a communist, make him work with a skeleton cabinet while the worst global economic collapse is on going, and actively attempt to sabotage the country with his presidency.
So I get it, the guy has challenges. However, the result of his stance is a perception - when a man has no sides, he doesn't stand on yours. This is compounded by the fact that when Obama does get angry and does pick sides, he picks the "safe targets", people he knows are going to vote for him whether they will be pumped up as they were in 2008 or whether they'll be holding their noses as they will in 2012. They won't be voting republican after all. He attacks his allies and puts forth policies hostile to his allies in order to prove he's not on "their side".
That is what really hurts in the long run. Yes, Obama doesn't alienate any voters by being neutral (except for the ones who will vote for him anyway) but he doesn't grow his base, he doesn't make make a case for the people who support him and the ideas they advocate. Why has Obama messaging been such a muddle since the election? Because Obama can't point to the villains and the ideas responsible for the 2008 catastrophe without taking sides and alienating their supporters.
And therefore these people have had no public accounting and feel no shame. Shame is for liberals who haven't been supportive enough of the alloof guy.
#7 Posted by Thimbles, CJR on Fri 7 Oct 2011 at 12:29 PM
"Unfortunately for the unwashed proles in the little speck of land between LA and New York, commonly refered to around here as America."
Yeah, I used to live in Nebraska. It's not special
#8 Posted by Hardrada, CJR on Fri 7 Oct 2011 at 03:51 PM
Yeah, they just let anybody teach Architecture. Nice typical liberal comeback Hrdrada. I live here in Nebraska and love it. I am glad you are gone. This is a special place and every time I travel out of state I am thankful to get back here.
Go join the others wasting time occupying Wall Street. Meanwhile you will still buy goods produced overseas. You will still donate to democrat campaigns who will in turn use the money to buy ads on corporate tv and radio stations, lining the pockets of the fat cats laughing at you. Why don't these protesters go to Maytag Headquarters or Whirlpool headquarters and protest there.If they said that they will not buy any appliance made overseas, then you would see manufacturing jobs come back to the US. The middle class would expand and the goals of both left and right wing voters would be acheived peacefully.
#9 Posted by Proud Husker, CJR on Fri 7 Oct 2011 at 09:10 PM
SHELLACKING II, 11-6-2011
OweBama went to Harvard and criticizes America. Herman Cain is a Navy vet and Purdue M.S. (CIS) and worked like a dog. Yes, the Republicans are racist (LOL)
The 99% -- who only pay 60% of taxes. No wonder the USA has been invaded by illegals. They'll take the citizenship of any of any P.Ant. in that park.
U-Haul -- will need a lot of trucks, DC to Chic., after next election
#10 Posted by Frank, CJR on Fri 14 Oct 2011 at 09:18 PM