I always thought Bob Butler would live forever. After all, he was Mr. Live A Long Life, and preached the gospel of helping Americans do just that. I never thought of Bob getting old, although the last time I saw him, about a year ago at a brown bag lunch for his staff, I had to reluctantly admit to myself that he was showing his age. His mind was sharp, and we had one of our usual discussions about the media’s struggle to write well about old people while simultaneously chasing advertiser dollars for younger ones they needed to feature in their news columns or on the air. After all, he did coin the word “ageism,” the prejudice against the elderly which shows up all too often in the media.
As journalist Paul Kleyman pointed out today in his Generations Beat Online post, Butler was always eager to help reporters—and not just with a quote. “If you had time and seemed interested in writing more about issues in aging, he wanted to know about you and your work,” Kleyman wrote. Over the years, Kleyman introduced many journalists to Butler, who educated them on the need to write passionately, accurately, and forthrightly about aging, even if their editors didn’t want to go there. He designed a training program for journalists: the annual Age Boom Academy, which propelled journalists far along on the learning curve. It was rigorous, and even veteran journalists went and learned a lot.
I first met Bob when I was on my way to Japan as a Fulbrighter and needed help setting up my program in a country where I knew no one. One of my goals was to report on the Japanese models of long-term care, and I didn’t know beans about the subject. My ambitions needed some grounding in reality. So I went up to Butler’s International Longevity Center, which he founded, and asked for help. Bob and his assistant, Mal Schechter, eagerly introduced me to the ILC’s counterpart in Tokyo, and from there I was in good hands learning the ins and outs of the Japanese system of health care and long-term care. Thanks to Bob, there are ILCs all over the world carrying out his vision of productive aging.
His passing is poignant, coming in the midst of yet another ideological debate over Social Security and which generation has the greater claim on the country’s resources—the young or the old. Media stories are once again creating an either/or issue. From Bob, I learned that aging is a neither an issue for the young nor for the old. It’s a family issue—the small immediate family, and the larger family of all Americans, and even the world family in far-off countries. I took him seriously and dragged my daughter to my interviews with old people and to nursing homes to observe whether the care was good or bad. She needed to know that the elderly are neither to be shunned nor feared.
This morning, my daughter sent me the statement from Mayor Bloomberg’s office and asked if I knew about Bob’s death at age eighty-three. The mayor talked about Bob’s contributions to New York City’s Age Friendly Initiative. “His passing is deeply mourned but he leaves a lasting legacy,” Bloomberg said. He also left a lasting impression on my daughter. “I was saddened to hear the news,” she said. “I remember meeting him when I was little.” I then recalled taking her to my first visit at ILC. She was eight at the time, but still remembered that meeting from long ago.
Kleyman called Bob a humanist. Indeed he was. Journalists wanting to interpret the looming, crucial issues of aging going forward will have a hard time finding teachers as good as Bob.
Nice recollection Trudy. Bob was very active until the end. Here's one of the last interviews he did, captured in audio and text by one of Columbia's News21 fellows just a couple of weeks ago, and posted today in the N.Y. Times New Old Age blog: http://newoldage.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/07/07/a-last-conversation-with-dr-robert-butler/
#1 Posted by Adam Glenn, CJR on Wed 7 Jul 2010 at 05:20 PM
A wonderful tribute to Dr. Butler. I decided to read more about him as just this week saw an interview with Dr. Butler in a documentary "I Remember Better When I Paint" which made me want to learn more about his work. So sad to hear he has passed away. He has done so much to remove the stigmatization surrounding aging.
#2 Posted by Don, CJR on Thu 8 Jul 2010 at 08:29 AM
Dr. Butler might have been better served if the article were devoted to him exclusively and not to the writer's personal anecdotes. He certainly deserved it.
#3 Posted by dpjbro, CJR on Thu 8 Jul 2010 at 11:30 AM
First, thanks to Trudy for referring to my piece on Bob in Generations Beat Online.
But I want to respond to "dpjbro." Journalism is not strictly a matter of listing resume accomplishments, although in the case of someone like Bob Butler, the excellent obituaries in the New York Times, Washington Post and elsewhere amply provide that reportage.
However, those of us in journalism, who were touched deeply by this most unusual man, now find ourselves moved to recount the personal attention and genuine inspiration he would bring to us. The doctor had what I'd call a deadline-side manner that went far beyond that of any other "expert" most of us might encounter. Bob Butler was a fervent advocate of journalism and -- this is important -- of journalists. Trudy Lieberman's thoughtful reflections her go right along with those I've received from some of the top journalists in the field. Reporters since Lincoln Steffens have known when we get a prime source, some who cares enough for their cause but also about those of us who can bring those stories to the public. Bob didn't just stand on a soap box but devoted time and I'd add a lot of heart to explaining the issues to reporters in all corners of journalism. You didn't have to be at the NYT to get a call back. when a wrote a book chapter about media for health care professionals some years ago about working with reporters, I quoted Bob's urging of them not simply to push their programs but to spend time with reporters and suggest sources -- even ostensibly competing ones -- to help journalists see the larger issues of our aging society.
Bob Butler was not only another genius among others you might interview, he was that rare authority who was also a mensch. I find it entirely appropriate that CJR readers learn about the golden standard among sources. Build your Rolodex and collect your facts -- but also pay attention to the special ones who really grasp what journalism is all about and help us do our jobs -- with heart. Heart is why the best in our field are now remembering how Bob Butler made us care about and continue reporting on these issues.
#4 Posted by Paul Kleyman, CJR on Thu 8 Jul 2010 at 04:22 PM